3 ms·
Mercantile opposition seems to be transitional more than permanent. It was unable to entirely dominate "king cotton" during the later civil war despite huge los
by ggm 3y ago
Mercantile opposition seems to be transitional more than permanent. It was unable to entirely dominate "king cotton" during the later civil war despite huge losses to trade. So I don't see pre 76 opposition to westward development as particularly critical because influxes of money would have changed this. Had the British government offered land and titles to the right people, it would have vanished overnight.
But you're probably right a breach was inevitable. Perhaps the rush of loyalists north to Canada entrenched it as a set of colonies more than a dominion for some time.
Similarly if Darien hadn't failed, much would be different.
I don't understand your comment about indigenous slaughter. Did I not make it plain I believe it would have happened irrespective? Maybe "continued" would be better, is that it?
- eesmith 3y agoMy major issue was how you ignored mention of slavery at all in your counter-factual. Had the British government offered land and titles to the right people -- assuming such people existed, which seems unlikely -- how much longer would the British Empire have supported slavery as official policy? With titles would have come representation in Parliament, increasing the control of slaveholders on British rule. > I don't understand your comment about indigenous slaughter. You wrote "I hesitate to say the slaughter of indigenous would not have happened", implying you think it might not have happened.