5 ms·
Noting that most historians hate counterfactuals, many people have wondered over the years what the world would be like if the tax thing had been settled amicab
by ggm 3y ago
Noting that most historians hate counterfactuals, many people have wondered over the years what the world would be like if the tax thing had been settled amicably with suitable representation.
Aside from Baron Baltimore being less an anomoly and more a sign of landed gentry in the USA, I suspect it's very likely the confederation of north america would have become the logical heartland of a british empire/co-dominium and that at least two major wars of the 20th century would have taken different shape, if only because the need for a Pearl Harbour event to bring the US into the war would have not been present. Canada would be provinces of a unified (or not!) landmass.
I hesitate to say the slaughter of indigenous would not have happened, frankly the British are simply better at hiding their iniquity, I have little doubt they would have pushed tribes aside to occupy the land, every bit as much as the US states did. Only New Zealand stands as a treaty outcome (Hawaii was superceded by circumstances beyond their control) and it's far from perfect.
On the other hand since Australia exists in part, to solve the overflowing prison hulk system, a function of loss of ability to send people to America, my home would either not exist, or be french territory. Quelle Suprise!
German land holdings would have looked very different too, and Belgian. The white man's burden would have taken a very different shape if the British state was confident in the American landscape. India I suspect would have worked out exactly the same: the east india company had to be pushed aside well after the US thing, that wasn't going to change much.
I suspect the British would not have been able to resist taking up land across the Bering Straights. So what we think of as the "German problem" might in fact, have been "the Russian problem" re-written. There isn't much the Tsars could do if Vladivostok turned out to be Georgetown.
Perhaps not such a bad outcome?
George Bernard Shaw had a crack at the US coming back into the fold in "upset the apple cart" which is at least entertaining.
- defrost 3y ago> On the other hand since Australia exists in part, to solve the overflowing prison hulk system, a function of loss of ability to send people to America, my home would either not exist, or be french territory. Quelle Suprise! Perhaps in greater part due to a British desire to thumb their nose at the French (thanks to a letter from the infant US intelligence): The French had plans for the east coast, and planted a flag on the west: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-29/how-the-french-almost-colonised-australia/101008680 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-29/how-the-french-almost... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Western_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Western_Australia
- otabdeveloper4 3y agoThe British tried to expand across the Bering Strait during the Crimean War. They failed badly and abandoned the idea.
- eesmith 3y agoThe Bering Strait, which is between the Russian Far East and Alaska, is nowhere near where the Crimean War was. Do you mean the Black Sea straits?
- Dalewyn 3y agoNo, the Bering Strait. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Petropavlovsk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Petropavlovsk https://warfarehistorynetwork.com/article/petropavlovsk-the-crimean-wars-forgotten-battle/ https://warfarehistorynetwork.com/article/petropavlovsk-the-... https://dawlishchronicles.com/2021/12/04/crimean-wars-north-pacific-theatre-1854/ https://dawlishchronicles.com/2021/12/04/crimean-wars-north-...
- eesmith 3y agoI had no idea - thanks! I had double-checked the Crimean War Wikipedia page and saw no mention of the Bering Strait. Could you give me another pointer? Even with your links, I don't see how the Bering Strait was part of the Crimean War. Your first link mentions Novo-Arkhangelsk (modern day Sitka in southeast Alaska), Okhotsk (on the Sea of Okhotsk east of the Kamchatka Peninsula), and Petropavlovsk (on the southern end of the Kamchatka Peninsula). None of those are close to the Bering Strait. Petropavlovsk is about 2,000 km away, for example, and I don't see why anyone would travel to the north end of the Bering Sea in that theater. Your second link mentions the Battle of Tsushima Strait, between Korea and Japan but nothing about the Bering Strait or Bering Sea. The last link mentions the Bering Strait only because Petropavlovsk was founded by Bering.
- Dalewyn 3y agoI frankly have no idea how the Bering Strait relates to the war beyond the geographic proximity(?). I just found those links from dumping "bering strait crimean war britain" on Google.
- eesmith 3y agoAny reconciliation would have shattered within decades due to inherent differences in their respective support for slavery, which I note you oddly did not mention. The slaughter of indigenous had occurred also under British colonial rule in the Americas. It isn't like taxes were the sole issue. British control of the Americas was too weak to enforce the Proclamation Line of 1763, which "marked the beginning of a clear ideological break with the mother country" quoting https://www.mountvernon.org/library/digitalhistory/digital-encyclopedia/article/proclamation-line-of-1763/ https://www.mountvernon.org/library/digitalhistory/digital-e... . Also from that link, "the British government viewed westward expansion as a threat to their mercantile economic system, expressing concern that opening up the west to farming families would provide the colonies with opportunities to gain economic independence through commercial agriculture."
- ggm 3y agoMercantile opposition seems to be transitional more than permanent. It was unable to entirely dominate "king cotton" during the later civil war despite huge losses to trade. So I don't see pre 76 opposition to westward development as particularly critical because influxes of money would have changed this. Had the British government offered land and titles to the right people, it would have vanished overnight. But you're probably right a breach was inevitable. Perhaps the rush of loyalists north to Canada entrenched it as a set of colonies more than a dominion for some time. Similarly if Darien hadn't failed, much would be different. I don't understand your comment about indigenous slaughter. Did I not make it plain I believe it would have happened irrespective? Maybe "continued" would be better, is that it?
- eesmith 3y agoMy major issue was how you ignored mention of slavery at all in your counter-factual. Had the British government offered land and titles to the right people -- assuming such people existed, which seems unlikely -- how much longer would the British Empire have supported slavery as official policy? With titles would have come representation in Parliament, increasing the control of slaveholders on British rule. > I don't understand your comment about indigenous slaughter. You wrote "I hesitate to say the slaughter of indigenous would not have happened", implying you think it might not have happened.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mdekkers 3y ago> I hesitate to say the slaughter of indigenous would not have happened, frankly the British are simply better at hiding their iniquity. The British indigenous headcount is likely only surpassed by Ghengis Khan, and I am not at all convinced they really went out of their way to hide anything. At the time, nobody cared about the folks they slaughtered and enslaved, and many Western cultures _still_ don’t care about them. They are the people that do the mining, make your sneakers, and develop your shitty games. They are the tech support people that are doing the needful, they are the folks living in the lands where we dump our trash - we in the West have _never_ cared for them, why start now? The British didn’t need to _hide_ anything, they know that if they don’t bring it up, nobody else in polite society will either.