5 ms·
Why George Washington's Statue in London Doesn't Touch British Soil
- btbuilder 3y agoSix Frigates is an excellent book about the origins of the U.S. Navy. It also gives a little insight into how quickly Britain and the U.S. aligned themselves, helped in part by the French Revolution.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoWhy did the French revolution unite the US and UK? I thought the US was really into revolutions and against monarchies like the UK.
- Ancapistani 3y agoThe way I understand it, it's not quite so simple. The US is really into individual liberty and self-governance. There was a sizable monarchist contingent here after the Revolutionary War, and they were involved in creating the structure and adoption of the US Constitution (and before that, the Articles of Confederation). It wasn't at all a foregone conclusion that the US would end up as a republic.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoInteresting. I once came across an image of GW on the wall on the way to the loo in a pub in London. My jaw dropped and I stood there pondering it until nature called louder until I gave in.
- TMWNN 3y agoThe British view George Washington as among the greatest Englishmen. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Washington,_Tyne_and_Wear#/media/File:John_Washington_plaque.JPG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Washington,_Tyne_and_Wear#/med...> The American cause had many English sympathizers, from William Pitt the Elder on down, before, during, and after the Revolution, which contributed to the rapid resumption in good relations (with the War of 1812 being a minor interruption).
- swarnie 3y agoI'm sure we've seen plenty of pictures of Oliver Cromwell in the pub (the pub might even be named after him). If we still celebrate the victor of the 1st British civil war why not the 2nd?
- bitwize 3y ago"Because nothing will make an Englishman shit so quick as the sight of General Washington." --Attributed to Ethan Allen, by way of Abraham Lincoln
- thinkingemote 3y agothat's actually hilarious!
- bitwize 3y agoA variation of Lincoln's Ethan Allen story appears in the 2012 film Lincoln: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qRBmwljrHWw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qRBmwljrHWw
- ggm 3y agoNoting that most historians hate counterfactuals, many people have wondered over the years what the world would be like if the tax thing had been settled amicably with suitable representation. Aside from Baron Baltimore being less an anomoly and more a sign of landed gentry in the USA, I suspect it's very likely the confederation of north america would have become the logical heartland of a british empire/co-dominium and that at least two major wars of the 20th century would have taken different shape, if only because the need for a Pearl Harbour event to bring the US into the war would have not been present. Canada would be provinces of a unified (or not!) landmass. I hesitate to say the slaughter of indigenous would not have happened, frankly the British are simply better at hiding their iniquity, I have little doubt they would have pushed tribes aside to occupy the land, every bit as much as the US states did. Only New Zealand stands as a treaty outcome (Hawaii was superceded by circumstances beyond their control) and it's far from perfect. On the other hand since Australia exists in part, to solve the overflowing prison hulk system, a function of loss of ability to send people to America, my home would either not exist, or be french territory. Quelle Suprise! German land holdings would have looked very different too, and Belgian. The white man's burden would have taken a very different shape if the British state was confident in the American landscape. India I suspect would have worked out exactly the same: the east india company had to be pushed aside well after the US thing, that wasn't going to change much. I suspect the British would not have been able to resist taking up land across the Bering Straights. So what we think of as the "German problem" might in fact, have been "the Russian problem" re-written. There isn't much the Tsars could do if Vladivostok turned out to be Georgetown. Perhaps not such a bad outcome? George Bernard Shaw had a crack at the US coming back into the fold in "upset the apple cart" which is at least entertaining.
- defrost 3y ago> On the other hand since Australia exists in part, to solve the overflowing prison hulk system, a function of loss of ability to send people to America, my home would either not exist, or be french territory. Quelle Suprise! Perhaps in greater part due to a British desire to thumb their nose at the French (thanks to a letter from the infant US intelligence): The French had plans for the east coast, and planted a flag on the west: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-29/how-the-french-almost-colonised-australia/101008680 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-29/how-the-french-almost... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Western_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Western_Australia
- brcmthrowaway 3y ago[flagged]
- arlort 3y agoIf Washington had done nothing else but refuse to seek a third term he'd already deserve a substantial amount of praise He's been dead an buried for centuries, it doesn't really matter how he was as an individual because he, and all other historical figures, aren't really discussed as individuals but as ideas. He was no genius as a military leader though, not sure if that's what you meant or if he's considered to be so in the history you're referring to
- brcmthrowaway 3y agoAs a general, he was a failure?
- arlort 3y agoNo, he was a decent general, he won after all, and had a very hard job of keeping the continental army from disintegrating But he was no Napoleon or the likes
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jedberg 3y agoHis greatest accomplishment was stepping down from power when he didn't have to, setting a long precedent for peaceful transitions of power. And in this case, although history is written by the victors, it was also written by the defeated, since they were the British Empire and still held a lot of power.
- dralley 3y agoHistory is very often written by the losers, provided they're still alive. The "winners" are often too busy doing other things to write the history. https://scholars-stage.org/history-is-written-by-the-losers/ https://scholars-stage.org/history-is-written-by-the-losers/ > Had Thucydides defeated Brasidas, he would be known today not as a historian, but as a military strategist, a strategist who never had the time to travel the world and collect the material needed to write his history. Even winning historians need time in defeat to write their histories—had Churchill’s party not been kicked out of power by British voters after the Second World War was over, Churchill’s famous account of that war would never have been written. > When high position is stolen from you, and access to the heights of wealth and power denied, there is little one can do about it—except write. History is thus rarely a “weapon of the weak.” The judgments of the historian do not serve the margins. They do not even serve the masses. They are a weapon in the hand of defeated elites, the voices of men and women who could be in power, but are not. What was true in Thucydides day is true in our own. WWII history was also in many cases literally written by defeated German generals.
- curtis3389 3y agohttps://archive.is/SY44U https://archive.is/SY44U
- massifist 3y agoI just started reading a book called Almost A Miracle, about the War of Independence. It's really good, I haven't been able to put it down.