7 ms·
American society wasn't always so car-centric. Our future doesn't have to be
- mrangle 3y agoAmerican society is heavily suburban and rural, and therefore dependent on cars. None of that is going to change. And thanks for that. American cities are largely inhuman places.
- epistasis 3y ago"No wireless. Less space than a Nomad." The idea that things can't change, much less that cities of all places can't change, can only be thought by shortening knowledge of history to a tiny window. Even current American cities have changed drastically in the past 50 years. They will change again.
- mrangle 3y agoSpecifically, I wasn't commenting on urban living except to imply that a massive part of the population won't be amenable to moving to them. Given a hypothetical that there would even be room. Cities can change, but just like everything else cities will retain their innate attributes.
- seabea 3y agoSuburbs can be walkable. As can rural towns. For those who live away from any civilization, they've made their choice about transportation.
- mrangle 3y agoSuburbs are not walkable. The assertion only reveals lack of accurate conceptualization of American suburbs. Yes they have made their transport choice: they have cars. Modern cities aren't equivalent to "civilization" in this comparison.
- bowlich 3y agoSuburbs can be, see suburbs built pre-WWII which typically had a train line connecting them to the nearby city industrial center which was used for daily commuting of workers who walked or biked to the station.
- seabea 3y agoI agree that the vast majority are not walkable but it doesn't need to be that way. I live near an extremely walkable suburb. Storefronts at the sidewalk instead of on the other end of sprawling parking lot. Pedestrian crossings in the middle of longer stretches of road (as opposed to only at intersections). Dedicated bike paths throughout the entire town. Schools centrally located on a single campus in the middle of town. It goes to show what a town can do when the local government decides they want to be more than just a outpost for a larger city.
- mrangle 3y agoIt'll always be that way. The suburbs are vast. Walkability is the rare exception, not the rule. Due to distance. Some exceptional parts of some suburbs are walkable. For example, I have in mind the immense suburbs of a second tier US city. These are impossible to redesign, and travel to do simple errands is measured in half mile increments. With expanses of residential housing and heavily trafficked roads inbetween. This is for convenient locations. Much of the housing is less conveniently located.
- CalRobert 3y agoYou're generally right but suburbs _can_ be walkable if they're not designed by idiots. Houten, in the Netherlands, comes to mind. Or a lot of the US streetcar suburbs which these days are generally not considered suburbs - South Park, San Diego to give one example.
- mrangle 3y agoRespectfully, "can be" needs to be paired with "rarely". I'm not debating that the rare small section of expansive suburbs is walkable. That's found everywhere, rarely. The reason that I'm insistent on the distinction is the same reason that I suspect responders are insistent on giving the impression that walkability is generally possible in suburbia. That reason is that the crux of the debate is whether or not the automobile has to remain central to American travel. My POV is that suburbia is unavoidably car centric, almost all of the time with rare exceptions. Those taking the opposite pov are generally trying to give the impression that walkability is generally possible.
- nullindividual 3y agoA myopic focus on cities and cars making for a terrible headline.
- cbeach 3y agoCars give people the freedom to go places and carry luggage that would be impossible or inconvenient on public transport. Taking this freedom away from people is divisive, bordering on hostile. Ideologues in metropolitan bubbles talk a lot about getting rid of cars. They disregard, either ignorantly or willfully, the needs of everyone outside their bubble.
- gmm1990 3y agoInteresting, you could also argue using so many resources to get around is divisive.
- cbeach 3y agoHow so? I pay the fair market rate for the resources I use, and the people producing them are happy with the transaction. Oh and by the way, I drive an electric car, so I don't produce any emissions in the residential areas I drive in (although like all goods, some one-off emissions were produced during manufacture)
- acdha 3y agoYou aren’t paying the full price for the roads you use or the parking, or the zoning requirements which force almost every property owner to subsidize your transportation choice. You aren’t paying for the additional healthcare required for the people who live around where you drive, or compensating them for the lowered quality of life, or compensating for the impact your much greater carbon emissions profile has on the entire planet.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> You aren’t paying the full price for the roads you use The large majority of the cost of roads is a sunk cost, because regardless of whether cars are used for individual transportation, roads would still be needed for delivery trucks, buses and emergency vehicles. The incremental cost of an additional car is generally not going to be more than what the car owner is paying in fuel taxes and property taxes on it. > or the parking, or the zoning requirements which force almost every property owner to subsidize your transportation choice. These are both the same thing. If you live in the suburbs, you paid for the space where you park your car. The actual problem is minimum parking requirements in cities, which are stupid and should be gotten rid of, but even if you did there would still be many people who want cars and choose housing that provides parking. > You aren’t paying for the additional healthcare required for the people who live around where you drive Modern cars are pretty clean in terms of particulate emissions, to the point that the exhaust is actually cleaner than the air that went into the engine in some of the cities with dirtier air. > or compensating them for the lowered quality of life This isn't math. Are you proposing to compensate them for the lowered qualify of life of not having a car? If someone else has kids, do I get to bill them for the cost of having to compete with their kids for scarce resources? Or should I bill them for not having kids and depriving society of their contributions? Everything everybody does affects the whole of society. At some point you either have to accept that they'll make choices you don't like and in exchange you get to make choices they don't like, or you have to embrace totalitarianism, in which one person gets to make decisions they like and if anybody else doesn't like it they can go to prison. > or compensating for the impact your much greater carbon emissions profile has on the entire planet. This isn't really a cars thing, it's a burning fossil fuels thing. You can perfectly well charge an electric car entirely from solar panels.
- cbsmith 3y ago"In the paper, the researchers note that a large-scale transition to EVs would leave many problems related to auto-centric mobility unresolved." Not exactly a shocking discovery that a product explicitly designed to be an alternative fueled car is still a car.
- uoaei 3y agoAnd yet the fact it needs to be explained in order to proceed in a discussion on the matter says a lot about the cultural normalization of the car. Many do not consider resource consumption in production and disposal, as well as emissions as regards particulate matter (road and tire wear), when engaging in topics like this, so clearly this insight is not as obvious to many as it ought to be.
- cbsmith 3y agoYeah, I get it... I'm just continuously surprised by what constitutes insight. The idea of shifting away from our car-centered urban designs is pretty old; AFAIK the electric car was always seen as a way to get away from the disadvantages of gasoline while still remaining compatible with car-centered urban designs. Otherwise the EVs we'd be talking about would be the far easier to achieve electric scooters or bicycles.
- uoaei 3y agoThe inertia of urban planning is measured in decades, while that of the technologies we are developing today is measured in quarters or years. It makes sense why the market logic dictates the fervor for EVs, since market dynamics are inherently myopic, but if we are to address the issues on longer time scales we need to think beyond a market-supremacist outlook. E-scooters and e-bikes are indeed touted as ways to subvert market dynamics to encourage change in the less-temporary features of our living environments.
- FredPret 3y agoYale Climate Connections - didn't expect a politically neutral post from that. But they make a good argument for higher density, which I agree with. But there are some advantages to a car-centric society: - higher personal freedom - you can go anywhere, anytime. With transit / walking, you can go some places, some of the time. This is huge and opens up a lot of possibilities for work, vacations, socializing, healthcare. - bulk stores like Costco is only possible because people have cars. You will have to pry my Costco membership card from my cold, dead hands. It's a lot cheaper to let people drive in to a central bulk store like this and buy what they want in large quantities than to have a network of tiny, walkable stores and try to predict demand and optimally distribute goods to them with delivery vans.
- epistasis 3y ago> bulk stores like Costco is only possible because people have cars. You will have to pry my Costco membership card from my cold, dead hands. Costco users in urban areas would disagree with your assessment that it's only possible with cars. I'm looking at this Costco in Soma right now and watching people walk out with enough bulk goods to carry in their granny carts or bags in hands.
- AlotOfReading 3y agoI wish that Costco didn't have cars. I used to bike past it on my morning commute and it was heart-poundingly dangerous. Drivers will jump in front of you and slam on the brakes so they can get into the parking garage entrance. The taxis aggressively pulling out from the stop just add to the thrill.
- schoen 3y agoI had a friend in the city who was doing pretty well with Zipcar, where one could somewhat spontaneously rent a car in one's urban neighborhood to use for errands or trips. This could be a good solution in dense environments for Costco runs, especially when the nearest Zipcar lot is just a couple of minutes' walk away. I personally go shopping by bike, but I notice there are some things I can't readily buy that way, like furniture. (I did successfully buy a microwave by bike, but a larger appliance than that would be pretty daunting.) I have family visiting me right now in the big city from the small town, and it's weird for us to notice how different things are.
- s1gnp0st 3y agoYou will have to solve the epidemic of homelessness and crime in high-density areas of the United States before people will accept using mass transit. I fully support doing so - I would for example support a national project to build cheap concrete housing for all who need it - but that's the barrier. I used to live in Portland and Tri-Met and my bike were my two means of transportation for many years. I would absolutely not use public transportation in that city today.
- alexsereno 3y agoThe entire west coast is really bad about its strategy for tackling homelessness. The central issue there is the federal government needs to massively ramp up housing, it can’t be solved at a local level (there’s a role to play for cities but basically you need nationwide housing reform.) Chicago and NYC have massively used transit systems despite their homeless populations. I lived in Chicago and I miss a real transit system here in TX badly. That is to say, we don’t need to do A before B. We need to do A & B
- epistasis 3y agoI would love more state level control of housing, or at least permitting of housing. Cities have proven they can not responsibly decide how much housing is permitted. Its too corrupt and the incentives are off
- brocklobsta 3y agoI don’t understand how more state control is preferable. I live in California and the state government is not very in tune to the needs of my locality and seems very corrupt. Some cities do not want housing/population growth. Why is that not okay?
- jeffbee 3y agoIf your city is also not getting state roads, state universities, state law enforcement, and state fire protection then great. Any city that refuses to get on board with state housing policy should be cutoff from all of the above.
- dboreham 3y agoThe history of the LA area "Red Car" transit system makes for interesting reading (covered well on WikiPedia). A large well used, electric, urban rail system that no longer exists. Primarily because it was originally funded by the developers of the "beach" cities as a way to increase the value of their housing developments, since residents were able to commute to jobs downtown and elsewhere. However, once the houses were all built and sold, there was no incentive to keep funding the street cars and the system eventually closed. Many of the disused lines were used as the basis for new freeways, ironically.
- epistasis 3y agoTransit (and freeways) as property development schemes are very underecognized, thanks for pointing this out. The Henry George Theorem (Sitglitz 1977) states that (in the right conditions) funding of public goods like transit and freeways increases the land value and therefore land rents by more than the investment amount. Namely, it creates value, but for whoever owns the land. Changing to less car centric development has the potential to vastly increase value. I'd advocate for a land value tax to fund the public investment, but would be happy with whatever non-car centric options are made available, honestly.
- johngossman 3y agoIt also forms the basis for the plot of “Who Framed Roger Rabbit”
- scoofy 3y agoI talk about this a lot when I discuss transportation policy (not a professional or anything, just been interested in for two decades). People seem to think that there is some pendulum that swings in directions when it comes to infrastructure. It's really not. These things happen in cascades. Once a new mode is dominate, it takes over until it outlives it's usefulness and then collapses. The LA Red Car is exactly this scenario, as is long haul rail transportation. And if you've been reading the Chuck Marhon for the last decade, you might see the suburban development pattern leaning toward a similar cascade. I don't see the automobile disappearing from the American city any time soon (the hoi polloi love the idea of the damn things too much even if the hate being in traffic), but you can live car free in so many American cities these days, it's really shocking.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y ago> In “Fighting Traffic,” Norton argued that car culture was largely forced on an unwilling public by car dealers, manufacturers, automotive clubs, and others who banded together to promote automobile use, calling themselves “motordom.” The problem of this analysis is that at the time of the protests, cars were a luxury good for the rich. However, as cars have become ubiquitous, the opposition to them goes away and people want more infrastructure in support of them.
- seabea 3y agoCars are quickly becoming luxury goods again. Cars sold today are much more difficult to repair on your own than they were 20 years ago. Not to mention the cost of parts.
- CalRobert 3y agoI shouldn't have needed to move to the Netherlands to feel safe with my kids biking to school. The US is a wasteland and when you've seen otherwise it just seems like a nightmarish hellscape of stroads.
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoYou didn't need to. I bet most places in the US are safe for your kids to bike to school. I see kids walking and biking to and from school all the time in my neighborhood. Never heard of any problems with it.
- CalRobert 3y agoMy own experience was vastly different.
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoThe US is a large country.
- 0xdde 3y agoAnd your experience that you are citing is an exception within the country.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 303uru 3y agoUnhelpful without giving a location. In Denver (a supposedly bike friendly city) I would never let my children ride to school. Not due to crime, but thanks to unruly motorists who are driving commercial sized pickup trucks and SUVs like they're sportscars.
- axpy 3y agoI am interested about your experience since mine is quite different. In the last 10 years I have lived in Vancouver, Montreal, Pittsburgh, Sunnyvale, Saratoga and now in Spain. I was also choosing “walkable” neighborhoods and in my experience there is almost no places in the US or Canada I would feel safe letting my daughter ride her bike to school. For example, I was biking ~4 days a week from Saratoga to Mountain View and the schools surroundings were the most dangerous section of my commute. Lines of parents dropping their child's with gigantic SUVs ready to right hook my ass. I was having close calls almost every other days and this is in some of the wealthiest zip code in the US. I am sure there is some places where walking and biking is possible but this is the exception.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoI just spent a week in New Jersey. It was not possible to get anywhere without a car. I had to take a lot of Ubers from my hotel. Surrounded by large multi lane roads and car parks. No pavement to walk even if you wanted to. Every business needed a huge car park. Everything was incredibly spread out. Maybe this is normal for Americans, but for me it was a car hellscape. I don't own a car living in London, and there just isn't the same need.
- dublinben 3y agoThis is so normal for Americans that you'll see people in this thread vehemently defending this hellscape against any criticism, since they can't imagine an alternative. A resident of London who doesn't own a car is a prisoner in their own home, in the mind of the average American.
- rickydroll 3y agoIt is normal for urban and near urban America. Too many people without enough sense, crowded in too small a space. On darker days, I think we need a more effective plague to shrink the population. My "need" for a car is driven by things that make life worth living, none of which are found in a city. OTOH, I can appreciate that city life works for some people and I would never try to impose a rural or suburban life on them.