3 ms·
All five words are also common English words found in any major dictionary. If you're not actually doing anything stupid with the passwords, all you have to do
by kazinator 3y ago
All five words are also common English words found in any major dictionary. If you're not actually doing anything stupid with the passwords, all you have to do is use that same diagnostic for that situation: "password may not contain dictionary words". Then you don't have a diagnostic which raises red flags.
That the developer is not aware that their diagnostic raises a red flag itself raises a red flag. It doesn't occur to them that a system which issues this diagnostic will be suspected of doing stupid things. That tends to betray a lack of sophistication in the area of security.
- ylyn 3y agoThat's not a reasonable requirement at all. A common recommendation nowadays is to have passphrases..
- kazinator 3y agoYou're right; if the pass phrase has twenty random words, some of which are select or insert, then that's a bad diagnostic.
- nephanth 3y agoExcept this restriction effectively bans xkcd passes (4 random dictionary words)