3 ms·
I think one can argue with Wikipedia's statement that "we only host your content". If Wikipedia empowers editors with administrative privileges, including the a
by greenyoda 15y ago
I think one can argue with Wikipedia's statement that "we only host your content". If Wikipedia empowers editors with administrative privileges, including the ability to enforce rules like "no original research", lock and delete articles, block users, etc., they would seem to wield a lot of indirect power over what kind of content users can and can't post.
Contrast this with a web hosting provider like Rackspace or Amazon AWS who really "only hosts your content". They generally won't delete your content unless there are legal issues (e.g., alleged copyright infringement, court order, etc.).
- kijin 15y agoA disclaimer like that is probably necessary for them to stay out of trouble in case somebody uploads copyrighted content, etc. Under DMCA and similar laws, a company that "only hosts" other people's content enjoy broad immunities, whereas anything more complicated than that might be just enough to make someone think they could sue the Wikimedia Foundation. Unfortunately, the US of A is a country where being sued is almost as scary as being sued and losing.
- sold 15y agoThink what if YT automatically deleted videos with 90% dislikes. They would only "host your content" then, even though users would have some kind of "administrative privileges". On Wikipedia, it is not that automatic, yet administrators are expected to execute "community will" in the same way. Choosing administrators is also done by other editors, Wikimedia rarely influences this process.