3 ms·
For little green stuff for expensive restaurants, vertical/urban farming is probable economically viable. For marijuana (retail sale price >$100/pound), it cer
by bell-cot 3y ago
For little green stuff for expensive restaurants, vertical/urban farming is probable economically viable. For marijuana (retail sale price >$100/pound), it certainly is.
But if you imagine that you're going to feed an urban area from vertical/urban farms - well, the wholesale price of a bushel (60 pounds) of wheat has fluctuated between ~$4 and ~$12 over the last 15 years - so between 7 and 20 cents per pound.
How many orders of magnitude below vertical farming's best-case scenario is that? And how much waste heat would staple-growing vertical/urban farms need to get rid of, in global-warming cities, where the poor are already dying from the heat?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pydry 3y agoNobody is going to use vertical farming to grow bushels of wheat. I think the general idea is that it can be used to grow fresh produce with a short shelf life which require fragile and expensive just-in-time logistics to get to your plate before going bad. The fact that expensive restaurants are already using it to produce fresh produce is probably a sign that it can be made mass market if costs can be reduced. The produce is fresher and not spritzed with pesticides. Isn't that preferable? This is all quite plausible, especially as solar/wind is leading to more periods of very very cheap or even free energy, the automation is getting better and the tech is falling in price.
- bell-cot 3y ago> Nobody is going to use vertical farming to grow bushels of wheat. True. But re-read the first paragraph of the article, especially the "they wanted New York City to be able to feed its population entirely on crops grown within its own geographic limit." bit. The article seems to be built upon utterly delusional assumptions.
- euroderf 3y ago> And how much waste heat would staple-growing vertical/urban farms need to get rid of, in global-warming cities Alternatively, how 'bout in Scando ? If we assume that new nuclear power plants will not be located close enough to conurbations to supply district heating, then how else to effectively use the waste heat ?