4 ms·
They didn't give details but it might come across as rude to assume they didn't know anything. The guide is introduced as a director of engineering, IIRC. One r
by keepamovin 3y ago
They didn't give details but it might come across as rude to assume they didn't know anything. The guide is introduced as a director of engineering, IIRC. One rational and charitable interpretation based on that is that they know way more than you do.
Also, even without that introduction, I got the opposite impression. The lady seemed very knowledgeable and had that melding of professionalism, persona and super-smarts that is common is very high performers, in my experience.
Sure, it didn't cater to your exact technical expectations of what the video should have, but such an expectation could be considered somewhat narrow, and it may be difficult to argue that therefore it is without merit. Your point about it seeming to miss the point of its intended audience is well-taken but may result from an a super narrow understanding of the audience segment you mention, which is likely more diverse than suspected. Also, the context suggests it was designed as a mix of PR, marketing, and technical sneak peak / curio, which it seemed to achieve well.
Your self-awareness of how this could be the result of sexism or racism is commendable but by surfacing your awareness of it, it comes across as less likely to be the cause, so I'm going to assume it's some other reason for now! hahaha! :)
Overall your comment could come across as somewhat strident and narrowly focused dismissal of something, and someone, with lots of value! Perhaps you just missed that for whatever reason? That's ok! :)
- throwaway914 3y agoI watched this, and the commentary from the 2nd tour guide seems non-serious. I did think the "valley girl" accent is what threw me off, but I stopped watching at "super cool sled". I just don't understand who their audience is with this type of commentary.
- jbverschoor 3y agoI hope they're just frying vocals and not m1s
- altairprime 3y agoI have an impeccable valley girl accent and just shy of thirty years of production sysadmin experience. Debiasing is hard work, but it’s worth it.
- throwaway914 3y agoIf you sound disinterested and don't articulate your speech for the technical audience you have -> you deserve the perception you get. Biases exist for a reason. If I'm not hearing the detail I'm looking for or the sincerity I can trust, I know I'm not your audience.
- altairprime 3y agoIf, in a technical settings, someone consciously interprets the valley girl sound itself as an indication of inarticulate, insincere, and disinterested; then, then they’re perpetuating biases against a regional accent, which is completely unacceptable. The harder problem is getting people to notice when they’re unconsciously doing so, and then to compensate for their own bias when listening to – and judging – others. (Your comment makes sense otherwise, no argument here — I’m only here for the valley girl subthread.)
- throwaway914 3y agoHmm. I will say from past experiences I've only found the 'valley girl' accent to be in certain parts of California, and not representative of Californians. Growing up I remember when my sister and her friends adopted this style of speaking for a time. Usually at school, this was (from my perception) to project an air of being disinterested in bored in conversation toward authority figures. I also found it when someone wasn't capable of demonstrating a deep knowledge of something (where the bias comes into effect). I know it's incorrect, but I have many friends that think Californians don't have an innate accent and I've often thought this about how I sound when going elsewhere. I think your comment makes sense, and I appreciate the way you detailed this.