5 ms·
"If we want to be a society, that comes at a cost and somebody has to pick up the tab at the end of the night and the system to make that happen is called taxat
by jerf 15y ago
"If we want to be a society, that comes at a cost and somebody has to pick up the tab at the end of the night and the system to make that happen is called taxation."
Your own summary simply repeats the fallacy. That someone must pick up the tab does not imply that the tab must be larger than it is today, or that the tab must be paid for by this particular chunk of money. It does not follow. It is not a logical argument.
It isn't even about libertarianism. It doesn't even rise to the level of an argument against libertarianism, because it isn't well-formed enough to even be called a proper argument. "We need a thing" and "We need more of a thing" are two completely different arguments, and you shouldn't allow one argument to be substituted for another without noticing.
- skore 15y agoWell, that's another thing that nobody is arguing. Maybe that really is where you misunderstand Tim's position: He does not say we need more taxation, he says that there are actors in the game that do not pay their fair share. You're doing your own argument a disservice by trying to modify the position of your opponent. That's not how discussions work. The position that Tim (and I) argue is simple: There is X amount of money that it costs to run society. While, yes, we constantly have to figure out what that amount is, there is no question that it should be paid by everybody in that society. And that the stronger players (who both benefit most from a well funded society and who have the most to give) should be decent enough to step in appropriately.
- carbocation 15y agoWere you 'decent enough' to pay more in taxes than you owed this year? Of course not. Why should anyone else feel compelled to do so?
- skore 15y agoPhew, I'm not sure whether I even have to respond to that non sequitur. Obviously I'm not a big corporation and obviously we're talking about tax loopholes here, not paying extra taxes on top of what you owe.
- tedunangst 15y agoWhat is a loophole, if not something that reduces the amount of tax you owe? Concretely, how do you propose Apple calculate how much tax they owe if "the amount the law requires" is not the correct amount?
- vacri 15y agoI'm sure it was the intent of the framers of tax law that large corporations should funnel a third of their income to a different country as part of "the amount the law requires".
- skore 15y agoPrecisely. I really don't get how anybody can try to force a red herring on this about "let's nitpick down to the nickel whether or not taxes are cool as they are" when we're talking about corporations who literally employ people to figure out ways of being taxed in a completely different country.
- tedunangst 15y agoApple is a company, not a mind reader. How are they to know where to funnel the money except where the law tells them?
- vacri 15y agoI think you'll find the law does not say "US corporations should funnel their money to Ireland". Apple (and other corps) hire people to find edge conditions in law that they can exploit - they are not the doe-eyed innocents 'complying with the law' that you're painting them as. They are dodging tax laws using technical loopholes, not complying with the spirit of the tax laws. Stop being an apologist.
- tedunangst 15y agoHow hard would it be to write a law that says "don't funnel your money to Ireland"?