3 ms·
The issue is that if piracy were legal, the financial damage would become very real. Therefore it has to be made illegal. The fact that it’s not technically ste
by layer8 3y ago
The issue is that if piracy were legal, the financial damage would become very real. Therefore it has to be made illegal. The fact that it’s not technically stealing is a side issue.
- Levitz 3y agoIt's very much not a side issue, it's powerful players completely warping the discussion by abusing their power in order to emotionally load their argument. If consumers framed subscription services as literally rape that wouldn't be a side issue either.
- layer8 3y agoYeah, we’ve had this discussion for at least 30 years now. I don’t buy it, because everyone ought to know that piracy can’t be made legal without killing much of the products. All that’d be left would be Kickstarter- and Patreon-style projects.
- Levitz 3y agoI'm sorry but no, "We" as in "Us in society" haven't had this discussion, in fact literal billions have been spent towards preventing this discussion from happening. I'm not saying that every piece of data should be free to sell and distribute always, but the current state of intellectual property and DRM is nothing sort of a disgrace.
- dathinab 3y agoI agree that piracy being legal would be an issue (in general, in specific cases it probably should be legal). But a major question is what is acceptable (practically, legally) to prevent piracy. And by framing piracy as stealing it is much easier to convince law maker and the general public that very much not reasonable solutions are acceptable. So that it's not technically stealing is really important for proper law making.