4 ms·
Singapore's financial success is indisputable and truly impressive given the very short timeline going from developing to highly developed. For me, life is not
by andsoitis 3y ago
Singapore's financial success is indisputable and truly impressive given the very short timeline going from developing to highly developed.
For me, life is not just about money and financial success; without freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom of association, sexual liberty, etc. who cares about material riches?
- thriftwy 3y agoThe whole region was undergoing transition from developing to highly developed, Singapore just leads the way because it is a) very small and have nothing holding it back, and 2) has a great location and legacy. South Korea is way more impressive transition than Singapore. First of all, it is a large country with a local nation whose culture had to be preserved. Second, it was really poor, and after Korean war it was poorer than most of Africa.
- ergocoder 3y ago> The whole region was undergoing transition from developing to highly developed From the said region. This is objectively no. Singapore and Korea are the only twos. Korea is not even in the region. Other countries are rampant with corruptions, political problems, and incompetence. Think of Trump and multiply it by 10. My prediction is that Thailand, Vietnam, Philippines , Indonesia, Cambodia, Malaysia, and etc. will never become developed. These countries are too big to change and the legacy systems (that are insanely corrupted) are too powerful. Take Thailand for example. It's objectively bad to have military run the country. Apart from corruption, they are just incompentent; it's well known and blatant. Yet almost half of the country supports a military government.
- thriftwy 3y agoSingapore's population was mostly Chinese with some europeans, so it was way closer to South Korea culturally than to Cambodia.
- kawaiikouhai 3y agoUh... No. Singapore's second largest native population are Malays then Indians, which IIRC are 13% and 7% of the population as of 2024. I do not think this was much different historically. Europeans are not very present in Singaporean society.
- thriftwy 3y agoI believe that you are super wrong and Europeans were always present in Singapore in large numbers, even if they do not show up in citizenship numbers. They did before WWII and they certainly do now. Whereas these 20% non-Chinese cannot turn a Chinese culture country to something else, hence the South Korean / Taiwanese / Hong Kong trajectory.
- mistermann 3y agoIt's hard to say for sure, but imho LKY is one of the most impressive leaders and orators I've ever encountered. https://vm.tiktok.com/ZM64SAoG7/ https://vm.tiktok.com/ZM64SAoG7/ https://vm.tiktok.com/ZM64SycPu/ https://vm.tiktok.com/ZM64SycPu/ https://vm.tiktok.com/ZM64S6tBu/ https://vm.tiktok.com/ZM64S6tBu/
- mc32 3y agoAlso South Korea was a Japanese colony. Colonies are double edged swords: they benefit from the injection of foreign expertise (technology, administration, standardization, ties, etc.,) but suffer from lopsided resource extraction. I think overall there is a long-term benefit from this forced infusion, but for lots of people it’s problematic. It’s the age old complaint about the Romans by their conquered peoples as illustrated in the Life of Brian.
- boeingUH60 3y agoAs someone who comes from a third-world country (Nigeria), I’ll trade some liberty for safety, a stable society, and prosperous economy at any time. But I guess it’s different for Westerners that already have a lot of liberties and material success to begin with.
- realusername 3y agoOn the other hand, Singapore is the only developed dictatorship in the world so while this trade could work, it's much more likely to fail. Usually, dictatorships go in hand with poor prosperity.
- catlover76 3y agoWould you consider the Gulf Arab countries to exist along the same spectrum as Singapore, but "further down" in terms of oppressiveness?
- realusername 3y agoI would not consider them developed and I honestly doubt they will ever be, they are not going in this direction that's for sure.
- catlover76 3y agoI was asking because they are other dictatorships with high prosperity; even more prosperous, I think, but worse places to live overall. Not to mention that their prosperity is not sustainable, but that's kind of ancillary.
- rayiner 3y ago> without freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom of association, sexual liberty, etc. who cares about material riches? Who cares about them? Everyone who doesn’t have material prosperity? You think the Chinese would trade their last two decades of growing material prosperity for greater speech and sexual freedom? Wealthy societies are able to afford those vices. But when America was developing, for example, the scope of those freedoms were sharply narrower than the way you probably think of them today. The Americans who made the country wealthy and prosperous today are not the post-1960s libertines that now enjoy the fruits of those efforts.
- andsoitis 3y agoBut Singapore IS very wealthy, yet they have not gained any of those freedoms. That’s the issue.
- dchftcs 3y agoFor othes you may have a point, I'm not sure what you mean about sexual freedom in Singapore. Singapore is culturally not that sexually open, which is largely a choice of the people, but people who don't want to adhere to the cultural norms appear to have plenty of options to exercise their power/freedom without facing legal repercussions. Maybe you confused it with Dubai?
- pkd 3y agoI would hardly classify sexual and speech freedoms as vices.
- dchftcs 3y agoSexual freedom is a very weird point to make because many people, more men than women, cannot afford sex without material wealth. Sexual freedom for women also improves with material wealth because fewer women feel the need to trade off their freedom for money. It's definitely not a kind of "freedom" that is easier to exercise in the general absence of material riches.
- iisan7 3y agoHeirarchy of needs: baseline level of "Freedom from" poverty, conflict, instability comes before "freedom to" act liberally. I'd agree that making that transition in priorities is important, and that a government allow society to liberalize, but if you read his book, he lays out the reasons that he felt Singapore should be slow to socially liberalize (racial conflict being a major one, and deeper differences he sees between Asian and Western values, make of that what you will). IIRC, he also argued that their press is free, just not free to lie or embellish, so they would face consequences for exaggeration or libel. He thought that was necessary to prevent incitement to riot or political subversion.
- fuzztester 3y agoMaslow's pyramid, as we were taught about it in school: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow's_hierarchy_of_needs https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow's_hierarchy_of_needs
- aurareturn 3y ago>For me, life is not just about money and financial success; without freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom of association, sexual liberty, etc. who cares about material riches? Did you already have safety, career prospects, food to eat, and other niceties in life?