10 ms·
Lee Kuan Yew on Malta
- arbuge 3y agoFunny to see this on the first page of HN (I'm Maltese, although living in the US now). Lots of truth in what he said... Malta has not done badly at all since independence but Singapore is a tough one to compare to. Currently Malta's GDP per capita stands at $33k or so which is certainly nothing to sneeze at, but still around half of Singapore's. Interesting too that history repeats itself. Back then it was the Suez Canal crisis and now it's this: https://timesofmalta.com/articles/view/freeport-talks-clients-shipping-lines-avoid-red-sea-bypass-malta.1077153 https://timesofmalta.com/articles/view/freeport-talks-client...
- thriftwy 3y agoThen again, I don't think Malta has as many low paid temp workers as these ones Singapore imports from India, etc. Also the residences are likely not that tiny.
- throw_pm23 3y agoYea, I'd prefer living in Malta to Singapore every day. Though I'd probably prefer today's Singapore to the one before Yew's times.
- thriftwy 3y agoThe one before Yew's times was still a British colony port overlooking a critical shipping route. I'm not sure how such arrangement may not result in significant economic development. Hong Kong didn't have Yew but it had significant quality of development.
- rayiner 3y agoBangladesh is also on critical trade routes. The Port of Chittagong is one of the few things from Asia on Greek maps from the 2nd century: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Port_of_Chittagong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Port_of_Chittagong. Chalking up Singapore’s success to geography is probably missing the point.
- gamex79 3y agoSingaporean here. What would you say is the point? My own tldr is that we severely lacked in a number of areas:land mass, natural resources, a defensible position, a meaningful economy. Geography was pretty much the only thing we had going for us. That and amazing leadership.
- rayiner 3y agoI mean to say Singapore’s success isn’t some inevitability due to its geography (which is an idea that gets trotted around). Lots of countries have something going for it they could capitalize on—most of them fail to do so. I think Singapore could’ve stagnated without good leadership and also a populace that was ready to rise to the occasion.
- thriftwy 3y agoI would say the opposite - most of countries are more or less on the development level that their culture and geographic location permits, few countries are significantly below this level and fewer still are significantly above this level. Singapore is exactly where it should be, given its culture, legacy, location, and the fact that it is a city-state. It would still be Singapore under your average ruler (of Chinese culture, not African). It has awesome hand so it does not take much skill to play it. I could not repeat enough the argument of city-states being different, and usually very rich, so that's what I'm going to do. You should never compare Singapore's GDP growth with any country which has, well, countryside. Still, Taiwan will give Singapore a run on its money while not even being a recognized country.
- kawaiikouhai 3y agoThese are very broad generalizations you're claiming with no evidence. > Most of countries are more or less on the development level that their culture and geographic location permits. So, given this assertion, no developing country should ever hope to join the ranks of a developed nation? Unless they change cultural variables or conquer new lands. Yet we see this playing out in Europe and East Asia and now Africa and India. > Taiwan will give Singapore a run on its money Singapore's GDP per capita is $70,000 while Taiwan's capital city sits at $35,000. Please cite your sources
- boeingUH60 3y agoMany countries have key shipping routes and other geographical advantages, but corruption and stupid leaders/populace prevent them from succeeding.
- resolutebat 3y agoIn Chinese names the surname goes first, so it's Lee's times.
- eynsham 3y agoWell, Lee Kuan Yew’s surname is indeed Lee, but Chinese names are sometimes written with the surname at the end in other languages: thus C.K. Tang, Wen Ho Lee, and so on. And, indeed, if one were also discussing the times of Lee Hsien Loong, it would be perfectly reasonable to write of ‘Kuan Yew’s times’. But people writing of ‘Yew’s times[sic]’ do betray how little they’ve read about Singapore.
- delta_p_delta_x 3y ago> Chinese names are sometimes written with the surname at the end in other languages, thus C.K. Tang, Wen Ho Lee This is an Anglicisation through and through. In Mandarin Chinese and most Chinese dialects (and Korean, for the record), the surname comes first. XI Jinping MAO Tse-tung LEE Kuan Yew TSAI Ying-Wen HUANG Jen-Hsun KIM Jong-un BAN Ki-moon If the person has a European first name, then it comes before the surname—Lisa Su, for instance. Lee Kuan Yew himself went by 'Harry Lee Kuan Yew' before he went into politics and he dropped the 'Harry'.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Al-Khwarizmi 3y agoI haven't visited Malta but Singapore would be one of my top choices if I had to migrate somewhere (if not the top). Big city but you can go anywhere at any time and feel extremely safe. Impressive public transport. Amazing food, probably the best among countries I've visited. Everyone speaks English but you can enjoy a mix of Chinese, Malay, Indian cultures. The people tend to be quite nice. Good economy. Feeling of growth, rather than decadence like in much of the West, every time I go there seem to be several new MRT lines. Sane politics (see public housing, etc.) Plenty of places to visit, activities and things to do. It's not perfect, maybe a bit too hot and I don't like their long working hours and exploiting of maids, but in my view it's top notch. On March I'll go to Malta, let's see how I compares, but I doubt I'll like it more (no offense to Malta, as I said, the think is that I really have a good concept of Singapore).
- zarzavat 3y agoHaving to be completely obedient to the state wears on the soul. All migrants experience this to a certain extent in any country but in Singapore it’s turned up to 11. The fruits of capitalistic success might be enjoyable for a while, but it’s a shallow existence. I think that Singapore is enjoyable in small doses.
- shotnothing 3y ago> Having to be completely obedient to the state wears on the soul I think this is very overstated, people break laws and talk shit all the time. Just don't do drugs and be an asshole and you should be fine, many laws are not enforced
- refurb 3y agoWhile this is true - that many laws are broken, with the government looking the other way, or citizens just keeping their mouths shut - the statements made by Singapore's leadership sends a chill down my spine. Just recently they made unilateral (clearly, because PAP controls Parliament and has since the country's founding) changes to the law that police don't need a warrant to search someone if there is a "reasonable suspicion the person may destroy evidence prior to a warrant". Not to mention there is no "right to remain silent" or "right to lawyer" (before making a statement), etc, etc. But what really caught my notice was the quote from the Minister of Justice - “There is no downside to this amendment because if they search and they find the evidence, or if they do not find the evidence, no one is worse off." To me that is wild. Invasion of privacy of an innocent individual and "no one is worse off". There isn't even an attempt to talk about trade offs - "yes, this is in invasion of privacy, but we're carefully balancing it against the need for an effective police force". Just straight up "searching the private space of an innocent individual is insignificant". That said, there is overwhelming support for this kind of law in Singapore. There was a recent poll that asked something like "Do you agree with this statement: It is better that there is stability than democratic rights." and 70-80% of Singaporeans said "yes". So "meh?". I may recoil at the very premise of the system, but Singaporeans seem to like it.
- 55555 3y agoThey could import them from north Africa if they wanted.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 7734128 3y agoOr even without wanting to.
- kredd 3y ago~100k foreign temp workers in Malta to support the labour, about 20% of the population.
- maltesegirl 3y agoThe culture surrounding temp work couldn't be more different, however. Singapore is an extremely classist and racist place. Malta is probably the least racist country in the EU/Europe. I have toured the whole of Europe for work and it amazes me how accommodating we are to temp workers over here. Many of them speak neither of our two main languages (Maltese and English) and we employ them anyway. You can even get people in customer facing positions who can only communicate with hand gestures due to their lack of language skills and that's fine by us. That would be unthinkable in any other country that I have ever lived in. It's probably because we Maltese have a history of being temp workers ourselves all over the Anglo sphere. Moreover we are a very entrepreneurial people who value substance over trivialities. Also worth noting that despite having a huge proportion of foreigners we have not experienced any significant criminal elements stemming from these demographics. Probably because unlike in places like Germany and Sweden, we give our foreign residents hope in the form of jobs, instead of keeping them jailed in beurocracy limbo. And you won't find any Maltese bitching about foreigners not integrating, as you will find in all classes of society in places like Sweden and Germany. It's immaterial to us, and we are smart enough to realize that that is not the source of the trouble that those countries are facing. For all its problem this is one aspect where I believe my country shines in comparison to others.
- andsoitis 3y agoSingapore's financial success is indisputable and truly impressive given the very short timeline going from developing to highly developed. For me, life is not just about money and financial success; without freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom of association, sexual liberty, etc. who cares about material riches?
- thriftwy 3y agoThe whole region was undergoing transition from developing to highly developed, Singapore just leads the way because it is a) very small and have nothing holding it back, and 2) has a great location and legacy. South Korea is way more impressive transition than Singapore. First of all, it is a large country with a local nation whose culture had to be preserved. Second, it was really poor, and after Korean war it was poorer than most of Africa.
- ergocoder 3y ago> The whole region was undergoing transition from developing to highly developed From the said region. This is objectively no. Singapore and Korea are the only twos. Korea is not even in the region. Other countries are rampant with corruptions, political problems, and incompetence. Think of Trump and multiply it by 10. My prediction is that Thailand, Vietnam, Philippines , Indonesia, Cambodia, Malaysia, and etc. will never become developed. These countries are too big to change and the legacy systems (that are insanely corrupted) are too powerful. Take Thailand for example. It's objectively bad to have military run the country. Apart from corruption, they are just incompentent; it's well known and blatant. Yet almost half of the country supports a military government.
- thriftwy 3y agoSingapore's population was mostly Chinese with some europeans, so it was way closer to South Korea culturally than to Cambodia.
- kawaiikouhai 3y ago
- bediger4000 3y agoWeird article. Ends with a big quote from Yew, no concluding analysis. Is this AI generated?
- phantomathkg 3y agoWhat Singapore did best is sit between China and US and try to benefit from both ends.
- hcmacro 3y agoI'd say Japan (China followed Singapore in development).
- mytailorisrich 3y agoWell, Singapore is a Chinese city at the tip of Malaysia. This is also why they split from Malaysia.
- gamex79 3y agoSingaporean here. This is a technicality but we didn't voluntarily split from Malaysia, we got thrown out.
- rayiner 3y agoU.S.-China trade volume was negligible until well into the 1990s: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/05/more-than-30-years-of-us-trade-with-china-in-one-chart/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/05/more-than-30-years-of.... By 1995, Singapore’s GDP per capita had already overtaken the UK’s. Trade was obviously important to Singapore’s development. But the idea that it was just because Singapore happened to be Singapore’s location relative to China is anachronistic. Singapore’s annual GDP per capita growth was already over 15% by the time Nixon went to China in 1972. It actually started slowing down by the 1990s when China’s growth started picking up.
- pi-e-sigma 3y agoLook at a map. Singapore is not on China-US maritime shipping lane so US-China trade is not relevant to Singapore at all.
- Jun8 3y agoTangentially, I think Malta is a fascinating place. It’s the only country in the EU, AFAIK, with a Semitic language. it’s unique culture, the history with Hospitaller knights, ancient buildings, the fact that it’s and island … all are very interesting. I’d love to visit in this lifetime. HN’ers of Maltese origin: what are some interesting aspects of your country?
- mmahemoff 3y agoAlso interesting that English is one of their official languages, the other being Maltese, making Ireland and Malta the only EU countries with that status now. There's a big scene of English schools and young Europeans going there to learn English in summer, which translates to a lot of partying. I definitely recommend visiting if you get a chance. It packs so much in for a small country.
- arbuge 3y agoFor a long time we were pretty sure that we had the oldest free-standing structures (i.e. buildings) in the world: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Megalithic_Temples_of_Malta https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Megalithic_Temples_of_Malta Apparently there's an even older contender in Turkey now, but, anyway you slice it, this stuff is old. The most recent of them (2500 BC) roughly equate in age to the oldest pyramids of Egypt.
- gamex79 3y agoAny Americans here retired to Malta? It came up on some lists of best places in the world to retire. Would love to hear your experience.
- maltesegirl 3y agoYou might want to check on /r/malta or Facebook groups. There's honestly probably thousands of American citizens in Malta. Especially if you count Maltese ex-diaspora who returned back for retirement or their children or grandchildren.
- chx 3y agoI am not of Maltese origin but I am a resident now. How much Malta fucked up transit and transportation is really interesting. It's as bad as the United States despite unlike the US the distances are short and the population density is high (the whole thing is 17 mi x 9 mi, the density of the entire country compares to Bellevue, WA and the towns themselves are ten times more dense). Malta is #10 country in the world in cars owned per people leading to constant congestion https://i.redd.it/fnrrri2k1n8b1.png https://i.redd.it/fnrrri2k1n8b1.png, some sections of the roads are impossible to walk, some transit connections are near impossible to make because of the lack of crossings and sidewalks. Buses are infrequent and notoriously unreliable. And buses are all there are, not even a trolley bus much less a tram or something. And they are not fixing this, I tried to do public transit to the nearest Lidl and the road was freshly rebuilt (not even fully complete yet) and they didn't add a sidewalk. The public transit mobile app is useless. This is not just me grumbling check https://timesofmalta.com/articles/view/people-use-bus-reliable-service-consumers-say.1008627 https://timesofmalta.com/articles/view/people-use-bus-reliab... for more.
- rayiner 3y agoI don’t understand why political leaders don’t look to LKY for insight the way business leaders look to Jeff Bezos or Steve Jobs. Singapore is the closest thing to a deliberate, systematic experiment in developing a third world country into a first world country.
- throw_pm23 3y agoWasn't it an inspiration to China's development, in particular to Deng Xiaoping? If so, then it is a great example of developing a third world country following LKY's insights.
- thriftwy 3y agoSingapore as a British port city on a small island was never a third world country. Before WWII it was already known as a major leisure, high life spot (as evident by Verinsky's 1931 "Magnolia"). It was surrounded by 3rd world countries like an American base may be surrounded by middle eastern shacks, but it is very different from them. If that base was to gain independence it would retain the QoL.
- TMWNN 3y agoHow separate was British Singapore from British Malaya? My understanding is that Lee Kuan Yew wept when Singapore was thrown out of Malaysia. Neither he nor anyone else expected that Singapore would become a first-world economy and Malaysia would, well, not.
- gamex79 3y agoNot separate at all. You are right that he did weep.
- rayiner 3y agoLots of former British colonies have posh enclaves surrounded by poverty. Singapore’s GDP per capita in 1960 was similar to Guatemala: https://cepr.net/documents/publications/econ_growth_2005_11_27_table_1.htm https://cepr.net/documents/publications/econ_growth_2005_11_.... And as the article noted, 20% of that was British military spending which went away with independence in 1965. The UK’s per capita gdp was more than 5 times higher.
- screye 3y agoLots of places have managed to get rich. Very few have managed to secure a good life its citizens through its riches. Singapore's 99 year lease allows its people to be well housed. Conscription keeps them healthy and they have among the best trained special ops. Public transportation and expensive car registrations allow for convenient transportation for all. Crimes are unheard of and the base population is the most productive of any nation in the region. Education is the best in the world. All from a nation that was nothing more than Marshes a few decades ago. Many city states/ small nations have had a top tier draw. Norway, Botswana, Emirates, Venezuela, Panama, Canada (erstwhile), Brunei....are all good examples. None have capitalized on it as well as Singapore. Credit where it is due. (they could have better work conditions and fertility rates)
- ValentineC 3y ago> Conscription keeps them healthy and they have among the best trained special ops. Singaporean here. I don't know about conscription keeping people healthy. I got a slipped disc during full-time military service, and had a hard time continuing treatment or getting any sort of compensation for harm to my body developed in service of the country once I finished service. I know countless people who've developed injuries in their early 20s, only for their injuries to be written off if they weren't persistent in seeking medical help. Most "uninjured" people in our reserves need to keep fit until they reach 40 (for enlisted) or 55 (for officers), but it's also not difficult to be unfit and still pass through. And of course, there is zero regard for one's mental health, unless it's a major condition like severe depression or suicidal ideation. Going through Singapore's military service changed me from respecting its government for its efficiency (likely aided with all the propaganda I've had to listen to during my early schooling years) to severely disliking it for treating the large majority of citizens like cogs in a machine, appeasing them only when elections come around.
- 55555 3y agoHis book on developing Singapore is one of the most interesting books I've ever read. https://www.amazon.com/Third-World-First-Singapore-1965-2000/dp/0060197765 https://www.amazon.com/Third-World-First-Singapore-1965-2000... It's part (auto)biography, part business book (his country was a startup, and he had to do tremendous business deals, place winning bets on numerous trends, allocate scarce capital effectively, manage and lead and recruit and inspire a team, etc) part dictator/war/adventure book (he jumps from a page of business dealings to suddenly buying fighter jets and preparing for invasion, making alliances etc, then suddenly back to business), part travel/culture/life. You'd be hard pressed to find a man with a more eventful or interesting life. I highly recommend it. There's 3 books in total, but the one I linked takes you from the founding of the nation state to the modern era, and is the same book the linked excerpt is taken from.
- fuzztester 3y ago>His book on developing Singapore is one of the most interesting books I've ever read. Seconded, if we read the same book. Was it a really thick one, say a few inches thick? I remember taking it home from the company library, and reading it over several days.
- 55555 3y agoIt was only ~8 mm thick, but I read it on my iphone. The book is a few inches thick for sure. It's an amazing read.
- morganf 3y agoYea, I loved the book as well (without commenting on where I agreed or disagreed with him; agreeing or not, great read and full of insight.) And yes it is huge. It is a few inches thick. Maybe 2 or 3 inches thick. Then sibling post saying it is 8mm thick is misguided or confusing his units. He did say he read it on his phone so maybe that's the thickness of his phone ;) Coincidentally, I just bought two copies to gift to friends who are in serious leadership positions.
- purrcat259 3y agoOuch this hits home. Its still the case to today: many Maltese just depend on the government to figure it out for them. As a result: 1. The government is the biggest employer on the island. 2. There are mandatory cost of living allowance increases every year decided by the government. Its always too slow and slightly too low. For comparison, the last COLA increase had 5% of it shaved off within a few weeks because local milk prices rose as a result. 3. The government has been subsidising electricity since the start of the invasion of Ukraine to avoid rising bills (historically it was a political football). WTO, EC, and other institutions have repeatedly told the government to wind them down but its repeatedly ignored this because any government which does will likely collapse in a few months. Its a super frustrating cycle to see year after year and its not surprising to see that its been historically accurate too. Fwiw, I'm Maltese and in my early thirties.
- maltesegirl 3y agoI just want to address point 1. It's true that the government is a big employer, but most of those jobs have really low salaries and according few working hours. 99% of those people have a second or third job. I find it an interesting system. The government job is their safety net, and acts almost like a basic income, which allows people to be more entrepreneurial. It would be interesting to study the effect of such a system on economic growth. And I categorically disagree with you regarding your claim that the Maltese depend on the government to figure it out for them. The Maltese are in comparison to pretty much everyone in Europe, one of the most entrepreneurial and go-getter cultures who love to "do it themselves" and "figure it out". If you want to see governments babysitting their citizens, go visit pretty much any N.W.E country. What's true about the Maltese is that many have no qualms about bad mouthing their country in front of foreigners, which is also an almost unique trait compared to the rest of Europe. But I notice, it's mostly people who never left home who are the loudest bad mouthers. Let me just say one more thing. We have one of the most amazing healthcare systems in the whole world. I have lived in all the most modern countries and have in my more than a decade abroad never experienced anything better. I don't know why people don't talk about it more. Probably because it exposes health insurance for the scam industry that it is. For the curious: we have an NHS style system which is amazing by itself because healthcare is one of the things that Maltese people are well trained in and care deeply about, and it's supported by a fully private industry of healthcare providers, which, because they are competing with "free" have comparatively low pricing. Compared to the absolute nightmare that is healthcare in Germany for example, it's an amazing system. I pretty much end up flying home for any treatment because waiting lists are way shorter than anywhere else and the staff much more professional.
- brcmthrowaway 3y agoEveryone should try the national dish of Malta: pastizzi
- DrNosferatu 3y agoIsn’t life for the average non-millionaire citizen generally better in the Asian actual democracies than in Singapore?
- DrNosferatu 3y agoAs per here: https://asia.nikkei.com/Politics/Taiwan-leapfrogs-Japan-and-South-Korea-to-top-Asia-democracy-table https://asia.nikkei.com/Politics/Taiwan-leapfrogs-Japan-and-... [and Hong Kong in the past]