3 ms·
'Cozy' relationship between Boeing and the US draws scrutiny amid 737 MAX 9 mess
- russfink 3y agoAfter the Max 8 crashes and fixes, I believed the Max became the most scrutinized plane flying, and thus the safest. Now due to Alaska, I believe I am wrong. Airbus, I hope you’re better - or at least that you’re bad in non-critical ways.
- wkat4242 3y agoAirbus has many of the same flaws. Look at the pictures of the A350 paint from Qatar. It's not so much the paint flaking that bothers me, but the way Airbus went out of their way to dismiss Qatar airlines' concerns as irrelevant to safety. When there's this much flaking it can't be considered non safety critical anymore. In many cases a rough undersurface was exposed and an airplane hull is much more efficient when smooth. Also some of the flakes will end up in the engines or sensors. Really that was not a good show from airbus.
- aaomidi 3y agoEnshitification
- Glawen 3y agoWell, that's the Qatar side of the story. Only qatari regulators decided it was a safety issue, no other regulator deemed it a threat. The decision was coincidentally taken at the height of COVID when noone was flying (2021). It was obvious that Qatar Airways wanted Airbus to pay for it's non flying fleet while patiently waiting for the market to recover. Airbus couldn't allow such a precedent to happen.
- wkat4242 3y agoLook at the pics though. That's not ok however they spin it. Unless it's pure neglect but airbus didn't claim that either.
- Glawen 3y agoI saw the picture, I agree it is not nice, but other airlines facing the same issue simply sent their a350 to Toulouse to be repainted by Airbus under warranty. It seems Qatar Airways didn't accept this proposition. See https://simpleflying.com/qatar-airbus-a350-paint-conflict-timeline/ https://simpleflying.com/qatar-airbus-a350-paint-conflict-ti...
- delfinom 3y agoPersonal engineering experiences, Boeing accepts QA reports from vendors without reading them. Airbus reviews similar reports and challenges the tiniest thing. Tis one of the many reasons I fly Airbus.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dakial1 3y agoThe 2 first accidents made it clear that this version of the 737 prioritized time-to-market over design (that’s why it needed the MCAS solution, a software patch for a hardware shortcoming.) Now this new incident with the Max 9 shows that they might have prioritized time-to-market (or cost) over production quality. This version seems to be doomed to have problems and I will avoid it for sure
- Zigurd 3y agoIt wasn't just time to market. That impetus led to bad ideas chased the tails of other bad ideas in a spiral: You can't need pilot training, but you must have more efficient engines; a kludge for more efficient engines was applied, but it led to stall situations that would require pilot training; MCAS was added but could not be documented to pilots because they shouldn't need to know because that would undermine the claim no simulator time was needed for training, and because there are too few 737MAX simulators and too many pilots. Boeing is still benefiting from a cozy relationship because no hardware changes were employed in the fix, MCAS is still controlling trim, simulator training for AOA/MCAS issues isn't required and there are probably other ways in which safety did not come first before getting 737MAX deliveries back on line. If you are wondering how mighty Boeing had to have an expedient low-cost development project based on a 50 year old design when Boeing also sells a carbon fiber wonder-plane called Dreamliner, go down the Harry Stonecipher GE Jack Welch Six Sigma McDonnell Douglas outsource-everything rabbit hole. The 787 is a very nice plane to ride in, but it was tens of billions over budget, far more expensive to build than the aggressive outsourcing plan envisioned, doesn't fly as far as planned, and may not be profitable on a per unit basis yet. Boeing very badly needed a cash cow. And here's the internal doc that told then that's what would happen: https://techrights.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/2014130646.pdf https://techrights.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/2014130646...
- phendrenad2 3y agoAll of this squeezing through loopholes is unfortunately how a lot of big companies operate. Nothing a company with lots of lawyers loves more than complex laws that take out competition before they can pose a threat.
- piombisallow 3y agoI'm very sure Airbus has a very cozy relationship with France too.
- julienfr112 3y agoand in Germany. and in England. and in Spain.
- Bowes-Lyon 3y agoBut Airbus planes are not falling from the skies.