6 ms·
To be more fair: it is easy to check if they are alive or not. This is not rocket science.
by wslh 3y ago
To be more fair: it is easy to check if they are alive or not. This is not rocket science.
- userbinator 3y agoIn these times, it is only easy in-person.
- otikik 3y agoSo is to add an extra field “different deceased person with same name”
- gruez 3y agoHow is it easy? How do you make sure the old person in front of you is really the pensioner and not her 80 year old daughter?
- wslh 3y agoSorry, but we have not doing this for centuries if not milleniums for trillion of people before us?
- lazide 3y agoWe haven’t at this scale, no. For most of human existence, you would already know if Bob or Jane was dead, since you’d have gone to their funeral or knew someone who had.
- wslh 3y agoSorry, I am missing something. Are you saying that the people that are dying every day, in the developed world, is uncounted by a big margin? What is that margin?
- Macha 3y agoJapan estimated 5% in 2006, for one data point: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kodokushi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kodokushi
- wslh 3y agoJapan is Japan [1]. What is your data point for European and American countries? [1] https://hansondoremus.com/2014-4-28-there-are-four-kinds-of-countries-in-the-world/ https://hansondoremus.com/2014-4-28-there-are-four-kinds-of-...
- lazide 3y agoYou’re asking for the concrete number of people who are dead, but the folks in the system don’t know it? And where there is a financial incentive for recipients to hide this fact? That’s about as (actually) knowable as how many folks in LA are drug dealers. We know some are, clearly, since they’ve been caught. But that is not going to be even close to correct in real terms, because they are of course going to work very hard to not get caught. https://www.crfb.org/press-releases/fact-sheet-how-much-waste-fraud-and-abuse-there-social-security https://www.crfb.org/press-releases/fact-sheet-how-much-wast... States “ According to the Social Security Administration’s Inspector General, in 2013 just over 1,500 deceased individuals in all age ranges were still receiving benefits. They account for only $15 million in improper benefit payments.” And “According to the Social Security Administration, all improper payments, including payments to the deceased and the very old, are estimated at about $3 billion per year.” That is in the US. And the SSA is really aggressive in trying to track down these issues. Most other pensions don’t have their resources or the type of political pressure they get. I’ve personally overheard enough discussions among old folks to know that isn’t even the tip of the iceberg though, anymore than arresting Bob for possessing coke is ‘stopping drug trafficking’.
- jazzyjackson 3y agobureauracratized welfare and government identification is relatively new
- gruez 3y agoFor most of human history pensions and social security did not exist, so there was little incentive lie.
- rad_gruchalski 3y agoAnd how’s a photo with a newspaper better?
- m-p-3 3y agoHow do you reliably do it at a massive scale? Other than using some kind of biometrics, there's the possibility of impersonation.
- pjmorris 3y agoThey send pension checks out to specific addresses and accounts at exactly the same scale. Does it seem unreasonable to add 'attempt to call the pensioner' into the 'maybe they are deceased' part of the verification protocol?
- acdha 3y ago“Massive scale” is a distraction because society is even more massive. For example, if you’re talking about school pensions you have a school system with employees and that means you could do things like have someone check ID in person, and perhaps require a non-relative witness if there’s any question. Doctors offices could similarly be enlisted to certify that person X is the patient they’ve been seeing. The problem with this is simply that it’s not absolutely free, and the people promising savings through outsourcing need it to be free to make their promises happen. Cutting budgets everywhere removes the slack you need to deal with things like this.
- jacquesm 3y agoYou'd think if they are able to reliable set up a contribution scheme that works at scale that they could set up a system to ensure they only pay out to individuals that are still alive. The possibility of impersonation isn't limited to pension pay-outs but many other things as well. A once-per-year on-site visit would work and would just be a cost-of-business item, and that cost could be lowered substantially by collaborating with other entities who take an interest in such information (banks, governments etc).
- breezeTrowel 3y agoSimple. The article states they use the UK's death registry. The problem is they have no way to flag an erroneous match for longer than 12 months.