4 ms·
> Running wires through existing walls can be annoying, and they don't want to put that barrier to sale in front of them. It also makes it more convenient to c
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> Running wires through existing walls can be annoying, and they don't want to put that barrier to sale in front of them.
It also makes it more convenient to compromise the device from across the street (or across town with a directional antenna). Though of course that's not a problem if your security is up to par and the device continues to receive regular security updates, and we can only surmise that the author has discovered a rare outlier in this space where that is not the case.
- inetknght 3y ago> Though of course that's not a problem if your security is up to par and the device continues to receive regular security updates Just remember that the S in IoT stands for security :)
- injidup 3y agoSecure Home
- b112 3y agodevice continues to receive regular security updates Have to reply to this, and my response was covered a bit by your statement of "security up to par". Nothing should be considered secure. All those bug bounties are to entice black hats, into giving up juicy pre-0day vulnerabilities. So just because a device is up to date with security updates, we all must understand, there are countless bugs unknown, needing to be patched, and often, being discovered by those that will never tell, never disclose, never report, and only use them for nefarious purposes. This is why security is nothing without monitoring. And why nothing is ever "safe", only likely "more safe" due to a security update. Consider everything that is network connected as compromised. Everything.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Consider everything that is network connected as compromised. Everything. This doesn't seem like useful advice. If you know something is compromised, you're going to want to stop using it and build a clean system etc. You can't just do that continuously the instant you've built the new system. Likewise, how does monitoring even work? Every device and app wants to phone home to some random server. The connection will be encrypted and even if it wasn't it could be some arbitrary custom protocol you'd have to spend several hours to reverse engineer. You could just block them all but that will cause massive breakage and possibly impair security when the thing you're blocking is whatever thing's security update mechanism. What's a solution someone can actually use?
- b112 3y agoThis doesn't seem like useful advice. Understanding reality is always useful advice. Wishing reality isn't as it is, won't help. The mindset I have described, is how one must view all electronics. Unsecure.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoBut what does that mean in practice? Throw them all into the fire and go back to pen and paper?
- b112 3y agoIf that is your choice. You may also understand that your devices are not secure, take steps to reduce risk, and so on. Why do you think yubikeys are a useful thing? Or hardware crypto wallets? Devices that reduce risk, that are designed with the thought that connected computers aren't secure, can never be secure. Know where risk sits.
- mrmanner 3y agoI think this discussion mostly comes down to how we interpret the word “secure”. Do we mean “zero risk”, “nothing can go bad”, “no potential attack, ever”? Or do we mean “low enough risk for this thing , here, now”? I prefer the latter, even if that implies that statements like “this thing is secure” are somewhat useless due to the subjectivity.
- pmontra 3y agoSame thing as the security of the lock on our doors. We know that if somebody really want to get into our homes they will. In the case of IoT and computers add to it the automation of the attack. What do we do with our homes? Tradeoffs. We put some valuables in banks, we keep some at home. We insure precious items, if we do have them. We curse when burglars steal from us. We also install curtains so people outside cannot look at us and at what we are doing at home. There are several level of protections to do the same thing for networks and devices. Of course vulnerabilities mean that they are not perfect. Curtains are not perfect too. Add to that imaging through walls with WiFi or mobile network signals, but that's still fringe at best even if you should read https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37469920 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37469920 So, tradeoffs and be conscious of them.
- a2800276 3y ago> we can only surmise that the author has discovered a rare outlier in this space where that is not the case. Exactly what I was thinking! What luck that the author found the single IoT device out there that's a cobbled together piece of bodged electronics designed by a graduate from a webdev bootcamp with a Corel Draw focus. A device that, while only ~15 years old is not only hopelessly useless, but also obsolete and insecure. It's a good thing all other consumer IoT device manufacturers think about and prioritize security, longevity! Also, that customers nowadays are more focused on installing something fit-for-purpose and sustainable once than buying the cheapest shit possible with the blinkiest LEDs. I shudder to think about how long they tried to get the string-and-cups based telephone to work in my building until the 1930's when they installed the copper still used today for DSL. Or how terrible the paper-straw based water system must have been up to the 1890's when they realized investing in metal pipes has advantages. So glad the days of short-term thinking are behind us.
- eastbound 3y agoI’m passionate about the problem of software maintenance: - Can we solve this with some companies dedicated to maintaining simple code (1 probe, 2 charts for each IoT, or more if the IoT subscribed for more) multiplied by 10k different IoT objects over 30 years? - How would upgrading all of them look like? Can we batch the upgrade of NPM’s package.json? Can we define a minimum toolset, say NPM+Next+React, for long-term support? - How can we keep software engineers passionate for that software over dozens of years? Can the challenge of upgrading and migrating to newer frameworks and applying security upgrade be ever a trove of genius and a competiton of the best hacks? For the moment, when it’s done, it’s all GitHub Actions. Released in 2018. Well, not a good start. Plus everyone has a different pile of … in their actions, it’s all custom code, nothing is standardized, and each new IoT requires a new guy writing new ones. - Is this already done in some part of OSS (openWrt?) and how do they deal with the boredom of engineers?
- speed_spread 3y agoYou have exceeded your weekly sarcasm quota. Your internet license has been suspended pending review by the serious committee.
- kelnos 3y agoSure, but manufacturers -- as we should well know by now -- don't particularly care about that. And for a device like this -- a rare one where it seems they sold it without any kind of online subscription service -- their goal is to sell units, and telling people they'll have to cut holes in their walls and run wires (for most people this probably means hiring someone) is certainly going to sell fewer units.