5 ms·
Olympics 2012: A Bruce Schneier Moment
- hej 15y agoOh, look, it's a tabloid article. Not packaged that way and with more words, also more eloquent, but still a tabloid article. Why can't this sort of advocacy (which is important) not take the high ground for once? Fighting FUD with FUD is disgusting.
- phillmv 15y agoThis text field is your soapbox. Where is the FUD? He points out the ridiculousness of anti air missiles being installed in random flats: it is far more cost effective to be a shit head by triggering those missiles than it is to actually hijack a plane. To my mind, that is therefore a uselessly expensive security countermeasure that puts more lives in danger. To paraphrase Schneier, security is a trade off, and complete security is impossible at best and mandatory identification and cavity searches at every bus stop at worst. Given the casualties at previous terrorism incidents (Munich, Atlanta are the only ones that come to mind) we're lavishly wasting money. Where do you want it to stop?
- mseebach 15y ago> He points out the ridiculousness of anti air missiles being installed in random flats No, if that was his message, the post would be three words long ("Lunacy on stilts"). This is pure, unfiltered tabloid FUD: > If one of those things is ever fired, either in anger or by accident, it'll shower white-hot supersonic shrapnel across the extremely crowded residential heart of a city. As multiple comments courteously point out, that scenario has exactly zero grounding in reality.
- vilya 15y agoTell me, because I'm curious: what do you think will happen if the missiles are fired and hit their target? Will the target somehow vanish into thin air? If not, where do you think the pieces of it will go? Yes that's a sarcastic tone I'm taking. I live in London and the thought of missiles being deployed around my city frightens me a great deal more than the vague possibility of a terrorist attack.
- mseebach 15y agoAnd what might such a target be? As a comment on the article says: > The real damage comes from the thing you're trying to shoot down; all the missile is going to do is to prevent a lunatic from hitting a stadium, by making it have a near-miss. If that means scores die when a plane hits a tower block, instead of thousands dying when it hits the opening ceremony or 100m final, then it's done it's job. Now, that doesn't make it any less security theatre, the main component of which is announcing the presence of the missiles loudly, but Stross' article is still pure FUD.
- smacktoward 15y ago> anti air missiles being installed in random flats The reference to a "High Velocity Missile system" implies that the weapon in question is the Starstreak HVM system (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starstreak_%28missile%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starstreak_%28missile%29). Starstreak is a man-portable weapon, so nothing would need to be "installed" anywhere; it'd be a couple of guys standing on the roof with a Starstreak tube. > triggering those missiles As far as I can tell, the only way to "trigger" a Starstreak launch is by physically pressing a button on the launcher, so the risk of remotely triggered launch is pretty low. And even if a terrorist or group of terrorists managed to somehow neutralize the Starstreak operators, seize control of the weapon and launch it, the missile itself is so small it wouldn't really matter; the backblast from the launch is negligible (it has to be, for the missile to be safe to launch from the operator's shoulder), and the warhead is just three darts with around 16 ounces of explosive in each. The terrorists would do more damage if they stole bowling balls and dropped them on people from the roof. > uselessly expensive Presumably the Starstreak missiles in question have already been bought by the British army, so the only expense would be the cost of having the guys stand around on the roof all day. And since those guys are soldiers the British government is going to be paying them that day regardless of where they happen to be standing.
- yread 15y agoI am not a terrorist, but if I was and I would get hold of an anti-air missile I probably wouldn't use to shoot people on the ground. There's plenty of airliners over London at any time. The missile seems to have a service ceiling only 5km but it's still fairly big risk. Couple of guys with guns can't shoot down an airliner unless you give them a Starstreak
- smacktoward 15y agoYeah, but (1) presumably the airspace over London is going to be pretty thoroughly controlled during the Olympics, reducing the risk; and (2) if terrorists want to shoot down an airliner with a man-portable air defense system (MANPADS) like Starstreak, there's easier ways for them to get their hands on one than by infiltrating one of the most heavily secured areas in the world and wresting one out of the hands of professional soldiers -- MANPADS have proliferated widely, and can be acquired on the black arms market for a few thousand bucks (see http://www.fas.org/programs/ssp/asmp/MANPADS.html http://www.fas.org/programs/ssp/asmp/MANPADS.html).
- Deestan 15y agoFlagged for linkbait title. Bruce Schneier isn't even involved.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- gouranga 15y agoThe problem is that a lot of people think it's a good idea because they are ignorant fucktards and believe any spiel that comes out of the media terror promoters. this may sound horrible, but I genuinely hope someone innocent gets injured or killed by the security forces and everyone jumps on it. it's about time it all came to a head.
- AlexMuir 15y agoFirstly, that's a ridiculous thing to say. But when it happens (and it does - see Jean Charles de Menezes) it will be put down to insufficient budgets, manpower, equipment and training. So far from coming to a head, it is perpetuated - bigger budgets, more people and more kit.
- ranit8 15y agoAs long as security forces only aim their full strength at immigrants and other non-people, the governments won't give a rat's ass. I also wish they would make an embarassing mistake someday.
- dageshi 15y agoI've sadly decided to unsubscribe from Charlies rss feed today, I used to quite look forward to his posts but it seems like his blog has descended into an echo chamber filled full of dull and pretty predictable diatribes. If that's what he wants to do with his blog then that's his business, but I'm not interested any more.
- nkoren 15y agoI'm as big a critic of the "Security Theatre" as the next guy, but trying to fight bollocks with even higher-grade bollocks isn't really very helpful. And Charlie's "white-hot supersonic shrapnel" is bollocks of the purest sort. A surface-to-air missile -- after its fuel is burnt out and its payload is detonated -- is basically nothing more than a thin tube. The "shrapnel" would consist of lightweight scraps of carbon fibre and sheet metal, fluttering downward like ordinary carbon fibre and sheet metal. Definitely annoying to have it land on your roof -- but fairly inconsequential. Disappointed in Mr. Stross for this one.
- mortenjorck 15y agoWhat's most unfortunate is that he's drawing attention away from the real issue by whipping up this largely unfounded public safety concern. There aren't a lot of places on earth that put SAMs in residential areas apart from North Korea.
- femto 15y agoThe Olympics is all about sponsorship. One could see this as a sponsorship deal: British designed technology (Starstreak) built by a British company (British Aerospace) being promoted to the world via the Olympics. They've already got their money's worth in publicity. (Were you aware of Starstreak before reading it here?) If the Olympics can be used to sell a soft drink, why not a missile system?
- FrankBooth 15y agoWhere can I place my order? I can't wait to have a Starstreak in my home for three easy payments of $49.99 (plus shipping and handling).
- D_Alex 15y agoWhat, I wonder, is the chance of a passenger airliner being shot down by such missiles...? To what extent does this - small - chance counter the also small risk of airplanes being used by the terrorists? I agree with C. Stross that this is a daft idea.
- iamichi 15y ago> "the best solution would be to designate a permanent Olympic venue somewhere isolated — Diego Garcia would be a prime candidate" A better idea would be letting the Chagossians return to their homeland (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chagossians http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chagossians).
- LoonyPandora 15y agoI live in the complex where these missiles are supposed to be deployed. The part of this situation that upsets me the most is not the missiles, but what comes along with them - the heavily armed soldiers billeted for up to 2 months. We have no choice in this, and were informed by a leaflet through the door. This isn't war time and the Olympics only last for a few weeks. We shouldn't have to have soldiers and weapons in a residential complex!
- dugmartin 15y agoWe took care of this potential problem a while ago in America: "No soldier shall, in time of peace be quartered in any house, without the consent of the owner, nor in time of war, but in a manner to be prescribed by law.". I always thought that was one of the sillier amendments to our Constitution.
- ElliotH 15y agoUnarmed according to The Guardian, may be supported by armed police.
- nicholassmith 15y agoHang on, so the people guarding the incredibly dangerous surface to air missile aren't going to be armed? Wonder how long it'll be before you see a SAM in the local Cash Converters.
- Angostura 15y agoI live in Leytonstone, a little under 2 miles from the stadium. My thoughts on this when I heard it where (i) The communication with the block residents might have been better (ii) That seems like reasonable thing to, given the balance between shrapnel potentially hitting my house and an aircraft hitting the stadium. Moreover, if I were the authorities I would make sure that there was a big public kerfuffle about anti-aircraft missiles being stationed in London - whether they were actually going to be stationed or not. It may be security theatre, but not in the way that the blog author thinks. And it may be deeply unfashionable, but the family and I are pretty excited by the prospect of the Olympics.
- rhizome 15y agoDo you think it's a reasonable thing to do, in that it's a case of good risk analysis?
- Daniel_Newby 15y agoThis is not security theatre. Think of a few helicopters trucked in and loaded with ANFO and white phosphorus. Novelists just have to be plausible, but security analysts have to cover the whole threat surface. And anyway the British military does not want to be caught with its trousers around its ankles like the USAF on 9-11.