6 ms·
Nice. On paper, 22M acres is enough room for 1.78 TW annualised over a year[0], which is about 61% of current global electricity demand. I doubt they'll get c
by ben_w 3y ago
Nice.
On paper, 22M acres is enough room for 1.78 TW annualised over a year[0], which is about 61% of current global electricity demand.
I doubt they'll get close to filling this land up with PV, but perhaps at least making this much available will reduce the rate at which people ask how much land PV needs to take up.
[0] 10% capacity factor, 20% efficient: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=22+million+acres+*+10%25+*+20%25+*+1kW%2Fm%5E2 https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=22+million+acres+*+10%2...
- toomuchtodo 3y agoFor comparison: "Of the ~92 million acres of corn planted in the US each year, roughly 40 million acres (1.6% of the nation’s land) are primarily used to feed cars and raise the octane of gasoline. If this land were repurposed with solar power, it could provide around three and a half times the electricity needs of the United States, equivalent to nearly eight times the energy that would be needed to power all of the nation’s passenger vehicles were they electrified. However, if we were to transition this 40 million acres are of fuel to solar+food (agrivoltaics) – we could still meet 100% of our electricity needs, and power a nationwide fleet of electric vehicles." (solar panels produce roughly 200 times more energy per acre than corn) https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2022/03/10/solarfood-in-ethanol-fields-could-fully-power-the-united-states/ https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2022/03/10/solarfood-in-ethanol-...
- Faaak 3y agoBiofuels really are mind bogglingly inefficient, but I didn't realize this much
- jgeada 3y agoThey're pretty efficient at moving public money into private hands though, which why there are such persistent lobbies to continue these subsidies. Socialism for the rich, rugged individualism for the poor.
- SllX 3y agoThat land will get repurposed organically when electric cars overtake ICE cars and the demand for corn-derived ethanol drops. Hopefully for something that tastes better than corn.
- ben_w 3y agoBunch of farmers woke me up at 04:25 this morning with a drive-slow horn-honking parade past my apartment. If I understand right, this protest was in part due to an attempt by the (German) government to reduce the level at which farmers are being subsidised. Reason I bring this up, is that I have heard that the US only started using corn ethanol as an excuse to keep subsidising farmers, not because it was ever a good idea.
- thelastgallon 3y agoGovts can continue to subsidies farmers, harvest sunlight with solar panels and and get paid. Its a lot better than harvesting sunlight with plants, instead of farming 2 times/year, a solar panel will produce for 25+ years.
- tomjakubowski 3y agoYou see similar things in California, billboards posted by farmers wailing about the state government raising water prices, when they are the ones subsidizing (to the nth degree) agricultural water to begin with.
- specialist 3y agoYes and: Blaming govt for water shortage despite new proactive policies like paying farmers to let fields flood (to replenish acquifiers). No good deed goes unpunished.
- SllX 3y agoI can absolutely believe that the Federal government did it for that reason, but I think it was my own State (California) that gave them the political cover because our dumbasses thought it was a genuinely good idea 20 years ago and we mandated ethanol in gasoline first (California has corn farms, but we are not a big corn-growing State so much as a big almost-everything-else-growing State).
- Loughla 3y agoOther problem. When there is a need, that corn can be diverted from fuel to food.
- huytersd 3y agoThe type of corn grown for ethanol is basically inedible (maybe besides conversion into HFCS)
- ianburrell 3y agoDent corn is perfectly edible. The white variety is used in cornmeal, corn chips, and tortillas. Yellow is more used for animal feed and industrial use. But it is edible since it is pure starch. Also, except for emergencies, the corn wouldn't be diverted but the farmers would plant a different variety or different crop the next year.
- FriedPickles 3y agoIt's great for making moonshine.
- Loughla 3y agoEthanol
- Loughla 3y agoIt is starch at its base, and oils. These are used in food.
- dylan604 3y agofood for whom? not all corn is equal, and isn't just a switch from fuel/food for people.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- BurnGpuBurn 3y agoI agree 100% that corn is a very inefficient fuel source, but > If this land were repurposed with solar power, it could provide around three and a half times the electricity needs of the United States Isn't really accurate. It could never provide that, simply because solar is too intermittent. With (theoretically huuuuuge batteries) it could perhaps, but those don't exist. So it couldn't.
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://www.tesla.com/ns_videos/Tesla-Master-Plan-Part-3.pdf https://www.tesla.com/ns_videos/Tesla-Master-Plan-Part-3.pdf (page 30) The batteries exist of course. Tesla ships 40GWh a year of them, and they are scaling up the next Megapack manufacturing facility in China. https://www.tesla.com/megafactory https://www.tesla.com/megafactory
- GaggiX 3y agoTo be honest while 40GWh a year is a huge quantity of batteries it's not nearly enough for a country that consume 11TWh a day, maybe in a century (and ignoring battery degradation). US needs at least a magnitude more to reach the objective in a few decades.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoAbsolutey. Stayed tuned. Flywheels still coming up to speed. Just a short bit ago we were building 0 batteries for utility storage every year.
- ben_w 3y agoArguing that we can't solve problem X by growing tech Y, because that would require support from tech Z which would also need to grow, seems like putting the conclusion first and trying to find arguments to fit. So people get rich making battery factories. So what?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- GaggiX 3y agoWhy are you using meters with acres? EDIT: I just realized that Wolfram does the conversion automatically, that's really cool.
- mulmen 3y agoIt’s all just multiplying ratios.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- m101 3y agoThe problem with solar is that we will have destroyed the environment to create those solar panels. The return on energy invested (RoEI) on solar is less than 10x which, when you're dealing with an energy budget like climate change etc, makes it a non-solution. Nuclear RoEI is more like 100x
- matthewdgreen 3y agoFrom Wikipedia: "A 2015 review in Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews assessed the energy payback time and EROI of a variety of PV module technologies. In this study, which uses an insolation of 1700 kWh/m2/yr and a system lifetime of 30 years, mean harmonized EROIs between 8.7 and 34.2 were found." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_return_on_investment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_return_on_investment Seems like the lower numbers come from older, obsolete PV technologies. Lots of improvement since even 2015.
- zdragnar 3y agoI'm a little skeptical of these numbers. At the area of land we're talking about (and the location of the land), dust (or cleaning), abrasive sand, lightning and hail are all going to be an issue for the panel lifetimes, if not their efficiency. They're mostly not in areas with tornadoes, which is nice, but I think 30 years is pretty optimistic.
- xp84 3y agoYeah, it's too bad that we make our decisions based on emotion, a problem affecting the "eco" side as well as the "right wing reactionary" side. The "eco" side pushes solar and wind for everything and thinks nuclear plants inevitably explode. The "right wing" side pushes coal exclusively because it's sad that the few thousand coal miners left could lose their jobs. Nobody's weighing these things with fair metrics.
- tstrimple 3y agoThe "eco" side aren't the ones making decisions about nuclear power investment. That would be the for-profit energy companies. Maybe think a little more about why an executive whose purpose is to generate profit doesn't want to invest *billions* of dollars and *over a decade* of construction time at a minimum and would rather put money into a wind turbine that turns a profit in under a year. The economics of nuclear power makes absolutely no sense. Literally every study into the subject confirms this. If you really want substantial nuclear power, you've got to take capitalism out of the equation. Nationalize the energy sector and remove representative democracy then you can build nuke plants like China.
- profsummergig 3y agoIMHO, we also need to bring more focus on 2nd and 3rd order effects of solar panels. They've been found to: - improve soil conditions under them - reduce water evaporation when installed over canals etc. - provide habitat for certain kinds of farm and wild animals (much like sunken ships provide habitat for certain marine animals) - provide insulation for structures that have them installed on the roofs
- ericbarrett 3y agoThis is really not true in natural Southwestern US desert, because the worst thing you can do is trample the biotic crust, which takes years (even decades) to regenerate. It is an established biosystem, with its own birds and insects and arthropods and mammals. Trucks driving on it and earth movers leveling it will do nothing good. TBH I’d rather see us put panels on existing buildings before we trample some of the last undeveloped space in North America.