2 ms·
Lots of references to the term "progress" but no mention that "AI" seems to freeze it at a moment in time. It is only backward-looking. (People make jokes abo
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago
Lots of references to the term "progress" but no mention that "AI" seems to freeze it at a moment in time. It is only backward-looking. (People make jokes about asking ChatGPTx questions about events that happened after 20xx.) Predicting the next token is based on patterns that have come before, found in the material upon which a model has been trained. There is an ability to create new (re)combinations of past material, and this is quite useful, but there is no ability to create truly new material, something that has never been seen before. Creating new material is the essence of "progress", IMO. It is an amazing thing that people do, not computers. Originality. Of course, people might use computers to help them do it.
From a recent NewYorker article that reached HN front page:
"This has been mocked as simply an advanced form of autofill. But, when I write a sentence, I, too, am trying to guess the best next word. It just doesn't feel especially "auto." One big difference is that, since I fancy myself a writer, I am trying to avoid, wherever possible, the statistically most common solution."
https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2024/01/22/who-owns-this-sentence-a-history-of-copyrights-and-wrongs-david-bellos-alexandre-montagu-book-review https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2024/01/22/who-owns-this-...