3 ms·
"Opinion 185: David Jackson and Bruce Richmond Should Retract Their Erroneous Attempted Proof of the Four-Color-Theorem [Written Dec. 30, 2022]" Of course the
by paulpauper 3y ago
"Opinion 185: David Jackson and Bruce Richmond Should Retract Their Erroneous Attempted Proof of the Four-Color-Theorem [Written Dec. 30, 2022]"
Of course the arxiv is full of claimed proofs of Collatz and other major open problems, but there is a special section for them called GM (General Mathematics).
It really damages the credibility of the arxiv if a non-GM department, in this case CO (combinatorics) has a false proof of a long-standing open problem. I am talking about the recent Erroneous computer-less proof of the Four Color Theorem posted by distinguished and accomplished combinatorialists David Jackson and Bruce Richmond, who hail from the Mecca of combinatorics, University of Waterloo. Their proof is definitely flawed in its current form, and very unlikely to be fixable. (See here).
And before that:
"appendix:Why ArXiv Moderators (including Victor Reiner) Seriously Erred in Rejecting a One Page Gem Entitled "Five More Proofs of the Cosine Addition Formula (Inspired by Mark Levi's Perpetuum Mobile Proof)"
He wanted arxiv to reject or reclassify the flawed four-color proof, but mad that arxiv rejected his paper. In the first instance, the pre-print processes worked as it was intended to. The paper was uploaded , critiqued, and then retracted. it would seem like he wants to be the arbiter of which papers get rejected/reclassified on arXiv.
- throw_pm23 3y agoI think he is generally consistent here: he wants papers with flawed proofs to be retracted, and he does not want papers to be rejected for not being sufficiently significant (if they are otherwise correct).