3 ms·
As usual, This article has very little exploration of causation. Profits are not a cause. A drive for profits are not new. What changed? 1) Why do consumers to
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
As usual, This article has very little exploration of causation. Profits are not a cause. A drive for profits are not new. What changed?
1) Why do consumers tolerate higher prices, when previously they did not?
2) Why aren't new competitors undercutting all these profitable firms?
3) Some propose industry consolidation and monopoly as a cause. Do so many industries truly have conditions that favorable monopoly?
4) Lastly, if new competitors cant compete on price with high margin monopolies, are consumers really better served by more and smaller firms?
I don't have all the answers, but it would be interesting to see an intelligent expiration of them for once.
- diputsmonro 3y ago"Tolerate" is a funny word, as though consumers actually have a choice about what price they pay and/or can forego buying groceries until prices fall, if ever. I can't simply choose not to eat for an undetermined period of time. Consumers do broadly seem to be upset, but they don't realistically have power to change anything.
- legitster 3y agoConsumers making substitutions is how an economy functions. I do not eat caviar toast at every meal, sometimes I have to settle for potatoes. But we are not seeing massive consumer shifts to lower priced options - if anything luxury products and segments are the fastest growing right now.
- iinnPP 3y agoBecause a lot of the people who were wealthy before the pandemic are now even more wealthy.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThere has to be a better explanation than extra spending by the wealthy is replacing spending by the poor in such a diverse set of consumer goods and services. I don't think Bezos and Musk are eating all the eggs and butter, driving up the price.
- iinnPP 3y agoIm talking about the people who are not struggling right now. All of them.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoOK, so you agree that most consumers have more money and therefore are willing to tolerate higher prices. This seems like the only explanation given that a minority of consumers cant eat all the eggs, beans, and produce to drive the market.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI would accept that if the prices were only confided to necessary foods and good, but it seems to cover most consumption; new cars, luxury items, luxury services, ect. E.g. profits aren't just coming form raising the price of subsistence rice and beans, but also fillet minion.
- hackerlight 3y agoYou didn't have that choice before the inflation happened, either. So we're back at the original point, which is the question of what exactly changed in the world to allow more profits.
- riversflow 3y agoNothing changed. Prices in a consolidated market are sticky. Once manufactureres realize they can charge more and make more money, they are going to do that until market forces make them correct.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThats a contradiction. prices were sticky until they weren't. Something changed if they can charge more in 2023 than in 2003.
- riversflow 3y agoSticky doesn’t imply permanent. They went up legitimately during the covid/supply chain debacle. They haven’t returned because prices are sticky.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThe contradiction I was wasn't with sticky, but the statement that "nothing changed". It seems clear that at least one thing changed, namely consumer expectation during the debacle. The person you were responding to was arguing that that something has changed in the world. It seems you agree and think it is consumer expectation
- riversflow 3y agoPeople are complaining, loudly, about pricing. Demand for staples is just inelastic. Every person I know who isn't making a comfortable salary (6 figs+ in California) constantly complains about having no money and taking a significant QoL hit because of CoL prices.
- chriskanan 3y agoRegarding new competitors, I assume the upfront capital expenditure for many of the areas would be prohibitive for raising enough money from typical sources, especially since the existing industry could just lower costs once a new competitor got going. The large companies are probably much more efficient in terms of supply chains simply because they are larger and better established.
- s1artibartfast 3y agothat leads to question 4. If economies of scale result in lower prices, even with profit, what exactly is the consumer advantage of the alternative with more competition?
- iinnPP 3y agoBecause the competition becomes about efficiency first instead of money.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI have no idea what you mean. Can you clarify?
- linhns 3y agoAgree. It’s from The Guardian so don’t expect to learn much from it.
- antisthenes 3y ago1. There was no convenient "just-so" story to push onto consumers to justify the prices. Now there suddenly was (COVID + Supply bottlenecks, which media gladly regurgitated every week for 3 years) 2. Barriers to entry, high startup capital costs (due to high prices of everything), having to compete against implicitly colluding incumbent market players. 3. Under capitalism, ALL industries have conditions that favor monopoly. It arises from regulatory capture and economies of scale naturally. It is the end state of any industry. 4. They aren't. More & smaller firms are a market with perfect competition, but perfect competition also means there's no profit, because revenue = costs. Under this scenario, there will be very little innovation. All these questions are trivially answered by any Econ undergrad who was actually paying attention during lectures.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoIm going to ignore your unnecessary snark and engage with your points. 1) I think your answer for 1 seems most supported and I dont disagree. 2) If incumbents have sufficiently high margins, eventually there will be enough incentive to overcome startup costs, and compete against collusion. 3) I agree that reg capture and economies of scale favor large incumbents. 4) I think this is the interesting part. are you agreeing that consumer prices are lowest under a monopoly with high margins, but not high enough to enable competition from firms at lower scale ( setting aside issues regulatory capture)? Do you think this is the scenario we are living in? I'm pretty skeptical myself, because in my experience, many industries also have inverse efficiencies of scale that kick in. This means small firms can compete on the margin, and are often bought out by larger but less efficient firms. I don't think that perfect no-profit competition is realistic model for the world because markets arent static and competition doesn't adjust instantly. That said, you seem to think that perfect competition has little innovation. Are you implying that monopolized markets have more innovation?
- gottorf 3y ago> Under capitalism, ALL industries have conditions that favor monopoly. It arises from regulatory capture and economies of scale naturally. It is the end state of any industry. Regulatory capture is orthogonal to capitalism. In fact, many of the loudest cheerleaders for capitalism also advocate for fewer regulations, in large part to avoid that exact problem. Diseconomies of scale are real. There's no evidence to suggest that the terminal state of any industry is a monopoly.