6 ms·
My Prime Factorization Sweater
- chrisacky 15y agoI really wish that I could remember the article/movie/show which I read/watched but it was talking about creating a universal language. This would be not just for people living on Earth but also life outside of our Solar System. It would make sense that if there was a universal language that it would be based around some mathematical form. At least something which should be constant through the universe.
- shalmanese 15y agoContact?
- sp332 15y agoWas it the video of Richard Feynman explaining to a general TV audience how to communicate what "counter-clockwise" meant to aliens?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- lubutu 15y agoThe problem is that such a language may have a mathematical basis but that alone wouldn't be able to convey anything besides mathematics. It can demonstrate intelligence, as used in Carl Sagan's novel Contact by broadcasting a sequence of prime numbers — but that doesn't exactly constitute a language.
- Retric 15y agoYou could probably move from math to chemistry/physics. Of course all the 'constants' are arbitrary numbers based on the measuring system used, but going from elements to DNA to cloning to emotion should at least in theory be possible if you had enough time and intelligence.
- palmtree3000 15y agoThis is, in fact, solvable; you can use plank units, which result from setting universal constants to 1. As an example, setting the speed of light to 1 means that time can now be measured in meters. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_units https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_units
- trout 15y agoYou still have the challenge of choosing a base system. Remember we are base 10 simply because of biology. Our alien friends may be on a different number base because they have 7 fingers.
- simcop2387 15y agoIt ought to be possible to deal with that by enumerating each possible digit. And then showing a representation of some kind of fundamental concept like PI/TAU that's easy to make a diagram of. Each side shows their digits and their representation and at that point we can determine conversions between the bases.
- etrain 15y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pioneer_plaque http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pioneer_plaque Was it in regard to this?
- pavel_lishin 15y agoI misread that as "Pioneer Plague", and envisioned a universe dominated by von Neumann probes launched by intelligences who want to contact someone, but die off before their probes can report back.
- ben0x539 15y agoDo people often walk up to the OP and start trying to identify country flags?
- Sondy 15y agoNo, but when people say, "Nice Sweater," and I ask, with a sparkle in my eye, "Do you want to hear about it?" they often say, "I thought they were flags."
- reinhardt 15y agoA perfect gift for Sheldon Cooper.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- merraksh 15y agoThat's an excellent idea for a T-shirt.
- mkopinsky 15y agoWAY more geeky/cool to have knitted this yourself than to have just bought it as a T-shirt. That said, with varying definitions of hacker, I'd bet she's the least hacker-y person to make the HN homepage.
- daeken 15y agoNot by a long shot. At least once a week we have people talking about how they "hacked" their focus, or their working hours, or other drivel. This is genuinely neat.
- mkopinsky 15y ago30 year old developer hacks work week, hits HN homepage: common. 50 year old librarian hacks sweater, hits HN homepage: somewhat less common. But yes, the principle is still the same.
- scott_s 15y agoNo. This woman demonstrated intellectual curiosity and real creativity. Most of the "life hacker" type posts I see are self-congratulatory pop-psychology.
- Sondy 15y agoI am NOT 50!!!! (for a few more years, anyway.)
- mkopinsky 15y agoYour age isn't on your website, but my calculation (got Master's degree in 1986 at likely approximate age of 24) couldn't have been TOO far off, right? I guess age is just one of those topics..... :-)
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoI'd start with zero. Bugs me that the right-hand side is 10 not 9
- JadeNB 15y ago0 does not admit a prime factorisation.
- eps 15y agoShe could've knitted a bit of white noise then :)
- Sondy 15y agoI thought about putting in zero, but I'm thinking of this in the mathematical group Z sub n, the natural numbers. That ring does not include zero, and it's as if it doesn't exist. One, on the other hand, is the multiplicative identity, so it is the background color, a factor of all the other numbers.
- JadeNB 15y agoCertainly the ring `Z/nZ` has 0, meaning an additive identity (the image under the natural homomorphism `Z \to Z/nZ` of the 'true' `0 \in Z`). Do you mean that the group `(Z/nZ)^\times` of units of `Z/nZ` doesn't contain 0? (I think that it's also confusing to call `Z/nZ`, or `Z_n` or whatever you like, the group of natural numbers; rather, it is a quotient of the semigroup (or semiring) of natural numbers by a normal subsemigroup (or semiideal).)
- Sondy 15y agoOkay, you passed me. I knew I should have pulled out my very old Modern Algebra book. I was thinking in terms of modulo groups. You can show lots of number theory with the sweater, granted that the number on the end is the equivalent of zero. I want a group under multiplication. Is that making any sense?
- muyuu 15y ago2, 3, 5, 7, 11, 13, 17, 19, 23, 29, 31, 37, 41, 43, 47, 53, 59, 61, 67, 71, 73, 79, 83, 89, 97 After just 5 or 6 different colours or so, which happens very soon, it becomes hard to distinguish them without context. But this is not a big problem thanks to order consistency. For instance, check 57 and 58, just next to each other with the tone of 19 (second factor of 57 = 319) looking very similar to the first factor of 58 (229). The converse is also true: 3 is a similar tone to 29. But thanks to order consistency it's easy to tell which is which. I'd say the only problem with this is not being obvious, and also the ordering being somewhat confusing, as I'd expect normal writing order for numbers.
- Sondy 15y agoI have spent so much time looking at graphs, I wanted smaller to be on the bottom and to the left, as in Cartesian coordinates. Though I know it's a bit weak. The color differentiation is even worse in the photo than it is with just the yarn. And it's tricky to find a yarn with enough distinct shades.
- muyuu 15y agoThat's interesting, because in CompSci screen coordinates (and vector coordinates when programming graphics) are usually rooted at the top-left, so we have a more "consistent" natural perception of it - those of us using mainly left-to-right language scripts. Anyway, I really don't see graphs as sequences. I have my perception of cartesian graphs and sequenced lists completely separated. But the important thing here is the idea :-)
- paduc 15y agoI'm wondering. Could this be considered a meta-explanation of what a prime number is?
- martininmelb 15y agoI showed this to my 9-year old daughter. After explaining it to her, her first question was 'Can I have one?'. I told her that it was a one-off. She then asked me to bookmark the page for her.
- Sondy 15y agoI am trying to get the graphics I made for the children's book I wrote with this concept (not yet published, but now it's time to try) uploaded in a decent form onto cafepress. I'll post if it comes out okay and I can sell t-shirts.