3 ms·
I will quite happily say that I also think utilitarianism is bad, but not because of the founder. I think it's bad because it comes across as someone discoveri
by ben_w 3y ago
I will quite happily say that I also think utilitarianism is bad, but not because of the founder.
I think it's bad because it comes across as someone discovering basic numeracy as an adult and going "what happens if we treat happiness as a countable object and do basic adding up on it?", and then never gets past either of two major stumbling blocks: (1) how do you compare the happiness of two different people, and (2) there's a lot more to maths than adding things up, important maths at that, such as "when is it OK to treat discrete things as continuums and when is this a bad idea?" and "do you really want to say that m people who are n happy is the same value as one person who is m*n happy, or is there some kind of discounting for bigger values like there seems to be with the utility of money going down as people get richer?"
> *Everybody* understands that when the founder of a Thing does something as daffy as Having Themselves Mummified in Victorian England the rest of their thinking is automatically suspect.
The main thing with Rationalists is that they recognise everyone's thinking is suspect.
> It's the kind of informal heuristic which is almost never wrong. We should not ignore it.
I grew up in the UK, with a prime minister who promoted what she thought were "Victorian Values". Amongst other various things, when she went to see Peter Shaffer's play Amadeus, she was informed of Mozart's scatological humour and is reported to have responded thusly:
"""She was not pleased. In her best headmistress style, she gave me a severe wigging for putting on a play that depicted Mozart as a scatological imp with a love of four-letter words. It was inconceivable, she said, that a man who wrote such exquisite and elegant music could be so foul-mouthed. I said that Mozart's letters proved he was just that: he had an extraordinarily infantile sense of humour ... "I don't think you heard what I said", replied the Prime Minister. "He couldn't have been like that". I offered (and sent) a copy of Mozart's letters to Number Ten the next day; I was even thanked by the appropriate Private Secretary. But it was useless: the Prime Minister said I was wrong, so wrong I was.""" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozart_and_scatology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozart_and_scatology
Lord Byron is also famous both for his poetry and for bringing a pet bear to his university accommodation to spite the rules about no dogs.
There's weird anecdotes about virtually every famous figure, 'cause humans are weird.
- leashless 3y agoBentham's mummification is a Brown M&Ms story. Once you see that in his life the result of Utilitarianism was mummification in an era where that was batshit there's kind of a long pause and a "recheck everything" and oooh look its full of utility monsters and all sorts of other naive garbage which somehow we are expected to take seriously. Point and laugh is the right response. Not 600 page rebuttals.
- ben_w 3y ago> utility monsters are specifically a criticism of utilitarianism, the people taking them seriously are doing so to say "and therefore utilitarianism is wrong". Also, did you… fail to notice that I was also describing utilitarianism as naive, just without using that specific word? Because I was. > mummification in an era where that was batshit It was also an era when being gay or an atheist or supporting equal rights for women or ending slavery was "batshit". And today we have Elon Musk, who many regard as batshit, but hey, SpaceX exists and probably wouldn't have gotten this far without him (it's not like the other billionaires in the new space race did any better than the old rocket companies they're trying to displace). "Batshit" is a trivial, playground, insult. Even when it's true, it doesn't count for much, because it's so broad.
- leashless 3y agoMummification. On a bet. With the motivation being to demonstrate utility. That is seriously enough to recheck everything because it seems to have blown up the founder. And if it does this to him, what's it gonna do to us? It does not need to be more complicated than this.
- gqcwwjtg 3y agoSeems like the main negative utility it created is people like you deciding it’s more important than the concept of comparing potential outcomes for how good they are. > And if it does this to him, what’s it going to do to us? Is this serious? It did him no harm.
- Turing_Machine 3y ago> Lord Byron is also famous both for his poetry and for bringing a pet bear to his university accommodation to spite the rules about no dogs. Having sex with his sister also raised an eyebrow or two.