3 ms·
I'm 39. I guess that extra year makes a difference? 15 years ago is 2009. CNET's recommended laptop of that year runs at less than 1/10th the performance of cu
by adastra22 3y ago
I'm 39. I guess that extra year makes a difference?
15 years ago is 2009. CNET's recommended laptop of that year runs at less than 1/10th the performance of current MacBook Air, with an integrated GPU that is 1/100th the speed of a current generation discrete laptop GPU. Oh, and it has almost double the wattage, and probably atrocious battery life by now. A raspberry pi is twice as fast, at a fraction of the energy usage.
The cheapest, throwaway windows netbook you can buy today would give you better performance and better energy usage, not to mention increased RAM and storage, and the energy savings would pay for the device in less than a year.
So no, I really don't see why we need continued software support for 15-year old hardware.
- anthk 3y agoBecause the cost of building a new device uses far more resources than just keeping an old laptop alive with a lightweight distro. My GF's ~14yo laptop (Celeron, 2GB, GL 2.1 Intel iGPU) with an SSD still works really fast with Ungoogled Chromium, a deblobbed Slackware and XFCE, even faster than her friends Windows 11 modern laptop with a much better processor and RAM.
- adastra22 3y ago"Resources" is quite broad. Objectively the cost of consumed resources is baked into the price, which as I've mentioned is paid back over a few years in energy savings, without even considering offsets due to recycling the old device. But I assume you mean externalities, which are harder to quantify. I'll use CO2 as a stand-in. Your average laptop generates ~300 kg of CO2 during its full-lifecycle production. That includes refining of materials, electricity used in manufacturing, etc. As mentioned, in 15 years laptop energy usage has gone down about 1/2 to 1/3 of its prior levels, due to a lower baseline power usage and better standby modes. Assuming 8 hours of use per day of a 100W laptop (for round numbers), that ends up being about 300 kWh per year. Which in the USA on average ends up being about 300 lbs of CO2. So in 4 years its lower energy usage has saved more CO2 than was emitted in the manufacture of the new laptop. Replacing old hardware is good for the environment.
- legacynl 3y agoyou're making a logical error. The CO2 is cumulative. So in case of replacing an inefficient laptop with a more efficient one: manufacturing: 300kg use 4 years: 400kg manufacturing new laptop: 300kg new laptop 4 years: 300kg That's 2 laptops, 8 years of use: 1300kg only using the inefficient laptop: manufacturing: 300kg 4 years of use: 400kg 4 years of use: 400kg one inefficient laptop after 8 years: 1100kg. Even if both examples would have the same co2 output, it would still be more environmental to keep using the inefficient laptop, because the act of buying stuff and throwing away old stuff carries costs too. An obvious example is that if people would replace their laptops twice as often, then the world would need twice the amount of laptop factories, twice the amount of resources, twice the amount of laptop recycling stations, twice the amount of space in landfills for laptops, etc. Maintaining and reusing old hardware is good for the environment
- donatj 3y ago> less than 1/10th the performance of current MacBook Air, Citation needed. Single core CPU performance has basically not improved since 2004
- adastra22 3y agoSingle core CPU clock speeds haven't improved, but performance per core has still improved due to micro architectural improvements: more cache, better pipelining, more execution units, etc. Source: google any cpu benchmark. Seriously.