3 ms·
With Safari, and Safari’s ability to run sites like apps (assuming this will make it to VisionOS), I don’t see this as that big of an issue. Not like it was for
by al_borland 3y ago
With Safari, and Safari’s ability to run sites like apps (assuming this will make it to VisionOS), I don’t see this as that big of an issue. Not like it was for Windows phone.
Spotify isn’t something that should need a dedicated app to play music in the background, it could run in the browser just fine. I think the same
Is true for YouTube. It may not have VisionOS specific features, but watching videos shouldn’t be a problem.
I removed the YouTube app from my phone a few months ago, because I thought I was using it too much. I still load it up in the browser all the time and it works fine. I don’t have background audio anymore, but that should not be an issue on VisionOS, and is a premium phone feature that most users don’t have.
- sofixa 3y ago> With Safari, and Safari’s ability to run sites like apps (assuming this will make it to VisionOS), I don’t see this as that big of an issue. Not like it was for Windows phone. It's not like Windows Phone didn't have a browser too (IE). And it's not like Apple aren't the ones making sure Safari doesn't support everything for Progressive Web Apps which could have come handy here. > Spotify isn’t something that should need a dedicated app to play music in the background, it could run in the browser just fine. Maybe. Would it work if your browser is on the background while you're reading something from another app on the Vision Pro?
- mananaysiempre 3y ago> Would [Spotify] work if your browser is on the background while you're reading something from another app Not sure about Spotify, but the only thing that stops YouTube’s mobile website from working in the background is its own code. On Android, with the Firefox addon disabling the Page Visibility API for it, it plays perfectly in the background.
- al_borland 3y agoOnly time will tell. From what we’ve seen so far, VisionOS seems more like macOS, where a user will be multitasking across multiple applications in front of them at once. I’d be shocked if a user can’t watch a video or listen to music in one window, while doing something else in another. It would be DOA without that basic function.
- nailer 3y ago> With Safari, and Safari’s ability to run sites like apps (assuming this will make it to VisionOS), I don’t see this as that big of an issue. Not like it was for Windows phone. That’s exactly what Windows Phone strategy was. And web browsers still can’t run websites like apps no matter what the PWA advocates say.
- al_borland 3y agoThings have changed a lot since Windows Phone. Electron has become huge for desktop applications, and many mobile apps are simply wrappers for a web app. The apps we’re talking about in this case aren’t very resource intensive, and both have very capable web experiences.
- whywhywhywhy 3y ago> Electron has become huge for desktop applications Electron isn't the same as PWA and runs in Chrome for starters and also has an underbelly you can control and extend with native code. Apple intentionally limits Safari's multimedia capabilities to push you towards making apps.
- wappieslurkz 3y ago> With Safari, and Safari’s ability to run sites like apps (assuming this will make it to VisionOS), I don’t see this as that big of an issue. I do see a big issue: not having the ability to use Netflix' and YouTube's (app only) download feature, to allow you to watch videos offline (on a plane for instance).
- alphabettsy 3y agoBack to pirating.