4 ms·
Why does "street view" need to "collect data", much less sanitize it? How could this possibly be a error of judgment? Take pictures, fine. Snoop on people's W
by eternalban 15y ago
Why does "street view" need to "collect data", much less sanitize it?
How could this possibly be a error of judgment? Take pictures, fine. Snoop on people's WIFI? What possible purpose could that serve in context of Google Maps?
> Just come clean about what really happened, sincerely apologize, and then take serious steps to ensure that it doesn't happen again.
I do not understand this attitude. They were spying on people. It is that simple.
- wetherbeei 15y agoEver heard of Skyhook [1]? Not that I know what it was used for, but generating statistics on the types/coverage of wireless networks could prove useful in the future. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skyhook_Wireless http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skyhook_Wireless
- tjoff 15y agoBecause they want to triangulate all the wifi access points. This helps you to fast and with low power determine your position using wifi on your android phone. This is valuable data and I think both google and apple used a third party for this before but have since build up their own database of wifi networks. The payload is used to help and triangulate the accesspoints more precisely (according to the article).
- jcdavis 15y agoIts more than just Android/iOS- their location data also works for computers with wifi as well (eg when I press the "share my location" button on Google Maps from my MBP, they pin my location down to within 50 feet) They certainly did not need to keep full packet contents though, just IP/Macs of nearby address to map to an approximate lat/long
- RandallBrown 15y agoI don't understand how the actual data being streamed through the WIFI could be useful for anything other than spying. How does knowing what's in the packets change anything about how they use it for location?
- bdonlan 15y agoIt's easier to just collect every packet that passes through your antenna and batch-process it later than to sanitize it in real-time - there's handy off-the-shelf software to do the former.
- Karunamon 15y agoThat's probably exactly what happened. Every time the privacy chicken littles start up, remind them that Google has precisely no use for the random data passing through each hotspot. None. Nada. It's completely useless to their organization. Junk data to be deleted later.
- mcguire 15y agoThen why store the data? And why would Google refuse to release the data to regulators because "it might break privacy and wiretapping laws if it shared the material?"
- Karunamon 15y agoBecause it's automatically stored? Google is still comprised of humans who make mistakes, sometimes horrible ones. Because they were in a pretty bad position once they found out what was happening? I can see an "Oh sh-, we broke the law" moment happening at the highest levels of the organization.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoThe answer to this specific question is two replies directly above your comment...
- mryan 15y ago> It's completely useless to their organization. Junk data to be deleted later. At least one person at Google thought it could be potentially useful: > The report, quoting the engineer’s original proposal, gives a somewhat different impression. The data, the engineer wrote, would “be analyzed offline for use in other initiatives.” Google says this was never done. I think Google is guilty of arrogance wrt privacy, rather than a fiendish plan to spy on people.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoYou're right that collecting these fragments is useless for the purpose of street view or Google maps. But it's also completely useless as a method of spying on people's personal affairs. You can't build personal profiles based on that data, but that is what Google does for a living. They have an incredibly dense set of personal information from gmail, adsense, doubleclick, search, etc. What's the additional information they could possibly gain from arbitrary street view payload fragments? I'm usually very concerned about the impact of Google's information collection on my privacy, but in this case I just don't see how it fits in with any kind of goal they might have. My diagnosis would be one of institutionalized compulsive hoarding. Maybe Googlers just don't have it in their genes to let go of any information they got, regardless of how useless it may be. Or maybe we need a new term: BBDR - Blind Big Data Rage :-)
- 23david 15y agoMy feeling is that your diagnosis is spot-on. But I don't know enough about organizational psychology to know whether such a thing is really possible. I suppose that logically if one of the google founders had a similar approach to dealing with privacy and data collection, naturally they would hire and attract people with similar attitudes. I've seen from google employees a general sense of emotional detachment and even contempt of their own customers that I haven't seen in other successful tech companies... it's as if they're not really dealing with fellow human beings. It's no wonder that they haven't been successful with creating meaningful social services. On an institutional level, they just don't get or even respect how normal people think. Too bad for them...