26 ms·
There's also the very real and reasonable question of where capital might be used more efficiently. Having seen first-hand how government agencies make spendin
by robomartin 15y ago
There's also the very real and reasonable question of where capital might be used more efficiently. Having seen first-hand how government agencies make spending decisions it is my opinion that a huge percentage of tax dollars is wasted. Private industry is almost always far more efficient in allocating resources out of necessity. I have seen cases where government agencies pay double --or more-- what a private entity would pay for exactly the same product or service.
- pgisadickyup 15y agohttp://bastiat.org/en/the_law.html http://bastiat.org/en/the_law.html
- ashconnor 15y agoIt's a valid point. I think that there are a few reasons why this occurs. 1. Tax payers aren't as resilient as shareholders: 2. There's a psychological tendency to think that "this is not my money" leading to excessive spending. 3. The accountability isn't there. If a politician wastes taxpayer money then he's still a politician for the time being. But it's not always valid. Many government projects are carried out by private firms that aren't efficient. You just have to look at the NHS IT project here in the UK to see how £12 billion can be wasted by private firms.
- ImprovedSilence 15y agoIn private industry, you promoted and seen a valuable if you make money for the company. In the government, you are promoted and seen as a power player if you spend more money. There are lots of super-competitive A-types in govt work who will spend a million dollars just to get another feather in their programs hat.
- notJim 15y agoThis seems like you have an idealized vision of private industry. From what I've seen, politics and being friends with the right people is the determining factor in both fields.
- chernevik 15y agoPrivate industry is ultimately disciplined by a marketplace. It can take a while, but managements seeking goals other than returns ultimately lead their companies into losses. The companies either improve or are bankrupted and their assets transferred to more capable managements. U.S. auto companies are an edifying exception.
- kalleboo 15y agoWasteful empire-building and waste-what's-left-of-my-budget-so-I-don't-lose-it-next-quarter is so common in private businesses it's even a recurring joke in Dilbert http://dilbert.com/fast/2012-04-07/ http://dilbert.com/fast/2012-04-07/
- notJim 15y agoI'm not really convinced that private industry is any better at avoiding waste than government. I must admit I haven't worked in government, but when I worked at large companies, I was shocked and appalled by how incredibly inefficient and wasteful their internal affairs were. Furthermore, many of us [of course, you may disagree] would like for the government to provide more services, and that money has to come from somewhere. Even if it's ultimately private companies administering these services, they would need to at least be subsidized by the government to be accessible to the people who need them most.
- temphn 15y agoThere is something called "career status" in the federal government that is worth taking into account: http://www.aphis.usda.gov/mrpbs/hr/job_opportunities/fed_emp_appointment_definitions.shtml#cc http://www.aphis.usda.gov/mrpbs/hr/job_opportunities/fed_emp... Permanent – Career status as a federal employee is achieved by fulfilling 3 years of substantially continuous service as a career-conditional employee in the competitive service. http://ohmygov.com/blogs/general_news/archive/2010/08/18/dear-bureau-pat-what-happens-to-my-federal-status-if-i-have-a-break-in-service.aspx http://ohmygov.com/blogs/general_news/archive/2010/08/18/dea... The service requirement for Career Tenure is 3 years of substantially continuous creditable service to become a career employee, i.e. obtain career tenure...Obtaining Career status is crucial for federal employees, especially, during times of instability and economic downturn like we are in today. In short, after just three years in the federal government, you effectively cannot be fired except for gross malfeasance. This radically distorts the cost structure of the federal government. There are many additional checks and balances on private companies. Perhaps the most important is that a poorly managed company will eventually go bankrupt, while the federal government can defer that for decades via quantitative easing.
- notJim 15y ago> Perhaps the most important is that a poorly managed company will eventually go bankrupt, while the federal government can defer that for decades via quantitative easing. This would be true in an idealized capitalist society, but many companies are one or more of the following: - propped up by the government (automotive companies, financial institutions) - in industries with incredibly high startup costs and difficult to obtain special knowledge (defense companies like boeing and lockheed) - have effective monopolies or oligopolies (utilities in some places, telcos) Of course these are all far from immune to disruption, but they operate at such a scale that even when disrupted, the competition is often available only for small projects/few customers. The result is while yes they will eventually fail if they are poorly managed, it is unlikely that will be in our lifetime. Personally, I'd rather not wait that long. Additionally, as I mentioned before, there are some services that I would like to have made available that can't be operated for a profit without government intervention. I am willing to tolerate inefficiency to achieve those goals. (Just as we as a society are apparently willing to tolerate governments other inefficiencies.) Regarding your point about career tenure, I've often thought that one of the most effective reforms government jobs could get would be making it easier to fire ineffective employees just like a well-run company would.