9 ms·
Study: Field Drug Tests Generate Nearly 30k Bogus Arrests a Year
- Euphorbium 3y agoAll drug arrests are bogus, tests or no tests. Unless they are aresting for nonpurity of drugs.
- buro9 3y agothen they would arrest you for selling cocaine that is 100% impure (it's bird poop from your car bonnet)
- InCityDreams 3y agoReasonable suspicion: unknown white substance....
- dylan604 3y agoYou can absolutely be arrested and convicted and serve time on attempt to sell/distribute even if the thing is 100% not a real drug.
- dekken_ 3y agoany form of unjust parasitism is basically slavery
- pelagicAustral 3y agoI think this Conor McGregor's take on the issue...
- giantg2 3y agoThe real root of this sort of issue is how the courts treat the standard of probable cause. It's supposed to be that the evidence presented is proof of a crime (but not as far as beyond reasonable doubt, but just that the 1 sided evidence supports it). Instead they often use the lower standard of reasonable suspicion. As an example, a bag of white powder cannot meet the standard of probable cause by itself. Maybe if the person holding it had a record of trafficking, or something like that. If the instant tests have a 90%+ accuracy rate, then that should be enough for a warrant to seize and test the substance with an high accuracy test. But I would contend that without other evidence it shouldn't be enough for a custodial arrest. But none of this really matters because the judges are not impartial. They want to think of themselves as good guys, and they think of the cops as good guys. So of course they automatically side with the cops. Or as we in civil things like red flag laws, they generally ignore the "more likely than not" standard to "err on the side of caution" by issuing them almost by default. Absolutely insane that they get away with this, especially the ones who admit it.
- pixl97 3y ago>But none of this really matters because the judges are not impartial. Of course they are not impartial, in the US they are elected. If you're not "tough on crime" you're getting replaced next election.
- devilbunny 3y agoVaries by jurisdiction, and not true in any federal court.
- giantg2 3y agoAppointed ones aren't really any better. They all have biases. The system is just built in a way that they are untouchable. How do you control someone who you have no recourse against? Perhaps the elected ones have the most accountability, even if it forces those biases to be more present. Even things like judicial conduct complaints are considered so secret that you can't subpoena them even if they contain exculpatory evidence. Judges are able to be sued (at the state level anyways) and investigated on civil rights and color of law violations. It just doesn't seem to happen. Even something like admitting in a red flag hearing that they are erring on the side of caution is a violation. Yet nobody cares to investigate or pursue it.
- TuringNYC 3y agoWhy hasnt this triggerred a Class Action Lawsuit?
- ta988 3y agoBecause it mostly targets poor people.
- boringuser2 3y agoThat doesn't even make any sense. Lawyers make money on these lawsuits. There have been massive class action lawsuits that don't even target people per se, such as the oil spill payout.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tehwebguy 3y agoOnly if they win!
- ceejayoz 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity
- dmoy 3y agoWhat's the class? A class action lawsuit might be possible to bring if the class is everyone affected by a single manufacturer's field drug test, if there aren't many manufacturers. But if the lawyers think that the manufacturer won't end up losing that case, then your class is reduced to the people affected by each individual police department, separately, no? That might not be as enticing for local lawyers if it's say, a class of a thousand people. If the lawyers don't think there's a significant chance of winning (say, because of qualified immunity), a small class action likely won't get taken up, especially if it's a small class action representing poor people and the lawyers foot the bill on their own time. Really feels like something that should be picked apart by federal prosecutors. But the feds also largely dgaf about poor people, so here we are. At best I think you might get local legislative changes to eliminate that type of testing, on a piecemeal basis, only in a few cities.
- SubiculumCode 3y agoI am not denying that there are major problems with the tools used by police and that juries fail to understand their limits, however, I take issue with 30k bogus arrests as indicative of a bad test without further context. For example, how many tests were given? What is the false positive rate, false negative rate, etc. i.e. the ROC characteristics. The tests may be quite accurate, we do not know from just that number. The question of whether the tests should favor reducing false positives of false negatives is a policy decision that must take into account public safety risk (false negative) vs harm to the individual (false positive and arrest) vs lasting harm from the false arrest (imprisonment). A moderate false positive rate might be good for public safety if used as an initial screener, but once arrested, further tests should be used that emphasize reduction of false positives. Then the harm would be limited to the disruption of an evening, not a life.
- yieldcrv 3y agoThe article said 4%, and contends that 4% is too high and goes further to notice that convictions are mostly plea deals, and that prosecutors in many places don’t have to verify if the plea deal is based on any lab based evidence and further finds a bunch of departments that arrest people no matter what the test result is, making your standard about “bad tests” completely moot its a system based on total apathy and the article is saying thats the problem that should be fixed
- godelski 3y ago> The tests may be quite accurate, we do not know from just that number. Be careful as this might go against exactly what your prior concern was. It's the Bayesian Trap. FWIW, the article says there's 773k arrests each year and gives around a 4% bogus rate. I'd say that's too high for something we all can admit comes at a great cost. > The question of whether the tests should favor reducing false positives [or] false negatives is a policy decision that must take into account public safety risk We have a written code that says innocent until proven guilty. Clearly false positive rates is of grave concern. There are many references to Blackstone's Ratio[0] by the founders and the premise is that it is better to err on the side that a guilty person go free than a free man lose his freedom. But Bayes is critical here too. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio
- standardUser 3y agoOur obsession with pretending we can stop the sale and use of drugs has been the primary force suppressing civil liberties in this nation for a generation at least. Everything form asset forfeiture to mandatory minimums to letting some dog provide probable cause - the list of violations we allow when it comes to drugs is long and embarrassing. Aside from terrorism or child abuse, where else do Americans so eagerly and willingly forfeit basic rights? And at least those crimes have victims.
- libraryatnight 3y agoAnd it's a very different situation for different income brackets. Celebrity or wealthy person is on drugs and manages to get to rehab - because they have the means to dip in and out of rehab - and they're a heart warming story, if you're poor you're not a person, you're just a drug addict. Nothing drove that home for me more than hearing someone, during the George Floyd trial, cut someone off who referred to him as a man with "He was a drug addict"
- exoverito 3y agoThe whole social phenomenon surrounding George Floyd's veneration and martyrdom is very interesting. He was literally a convicted felon for multiple crimes, one of which was home invasion where he held a gun up to a pregnant woman's stomach. The day of the incident he was passing counterfeit bills and acting erratic which prompted the call. The toxicology report showed he had fentanyl and meth in his system. The body cam footage started with him in the driver's seat of an SUV without ID, acting erratic and resisting arrest, and when first put into the back seat of the police car Floyd said he couldn't breath. Odds are he was probably already having a heart attack from the drugs, and then Chauvin's maximum restraint technique pushed him over the edge. Objectively speaking, Floyd was a miscreant at best and almost certainly a net-negative in terms of benefiting society. A fair trial would have classified the incident as manslaughter, but since cities were literally burning and the jurors were publicly known, they were not at liberty to judge the case impartially. The transformation of Floyd into a martyr and the violent quasi-religious movement that followed will be a good case study for future historians.
- dukeofdoom 3y agoI fail to believe that these judges did not know this. Just remember that judges where the ones that allowed the Nazis to rise to power, and rubber stamped everything. And then were also some of the people that they later hanged for their crimes against humanity. Judges are not people to be trusted with justice. Very often they're the worst of people, totally deferential to authority. They have proven to be easily corrupted and tools of a totalitarian state many times over and over. Currently sending grandma's to long prison sentences for protesting somewhere. Even the Bible warned us ....when Pontius just caved to the mob and Romans. Who judges the judges in our system...doesn't seem like they have faced scrutiny for a long time.
- worik 3y agoThe root of this problem is vice law Criminalising life style choice is evil