3 ms·
Not quite disagreeing, but from his (an end-user's) point of view, how is Google search different than Alta Vista or Lycos before it?
by protomyth 15y ago
Not quite disagreeing, but from his (an end-user's) point of view, how is Google search different than Alta Vista or Lycos before it?
- andrewflnr 15y agoMore stuff indexed, for one thing, paper books and videos included. And hopefully, more intelligent interpretation of queries, though that's more debatable.
- k-mcgrady 15y agoThis is a very good point. Google is more accurate, and faster, but in the end it does the same thing. It helps the user find information on the web. It's not a great new idea, it's an improvement on an existing idea.
- pyrhho 15y agoSometimes a quantitative difference becomes a qualitative difference. For example, motorcycles are just faster horses (in some ways worse, like for off-roading), but you could hardly argue they are the same thing. I would argue that google is substantially more useful than altavista, or dogpile, ever were.
- rory096 15y agoAnd ultimately Altavista and Dogpile are irrelevant, because neither existed just a few years before Google. Web search is revolutionary; search engines before Google were just halting steps on the way. That is, the contention isn't that Google revolutionized web search, but that web search revolutionized the world.
- kiba 15y agoAn extreme change in accuracy and speed might as well be...a revolution.
- retube 15y agowhoa! http://www.lycos.co.uk/ http://www.lycos.co.uk/
- philipithomas 15y agoAre they just running Google search on there?
- unconed 15y agoThe thing that made Google unique is that they ranked pages according to the links between them (i.e. PageRank), as opposed to more traditional document ranking methods that are keyword based. As a result, Google found showed you content that people liked (and linked to). From the end-user's perspective, Google search was noticeably better and more relevant. As far as I know, it was the first massive application of data mining graphs, which now drives social networking, content recommendations and more.
- philipithomas 15y agoThe algorithm is quite fascinating (from what we can infer). Using things like a markov chain to model results in Google shows a big jump from human-compiled results in early search engines - it's a new application of theoretical knowledge that has greatly enhanced society, and frankly shows a degree of automation that could be a basis machine intelligence.