4 ms·
Battery swap would be a reverse Gresham's law: bad batteries would get withdrawn from service and repacked to maximise range profit. EV should be redesigned ar
by ggm 3y ago
Battery swap would be a reverse Gresham's law: bad batteries would get withdrawn from service and repacked to maximise range profit.
EV should be redesigned around a common core swappable battery technology. As new battery chemistry comes online make it form factor and plug compatible.
- penjelly 3y agoswappable batteries is something NIO does, but agreed it not widespread. Tesla wanted to this at one point but they cancelled the idea. not sure why
- ggm 3y agoIt wasn't going to make tesla a competitive advantage the way integrated battery has.
- penjelly 3y agoi dont follow, how would it be different? would you mind helping me understand why a swappable battery is different? My impression was they would be the same in actual function
- ggm 3y agoIt would sell competitor product to conform. It's build a bigger market logic, but despite Musk patent stance he actually does want to own the business as well as grow the business. It would have eroded his competitive advantage since he had a car which had 2x the range of his competitors. It would have set logistic constraints and limit his innovation. You can't build cells into the structural frame if you go with a removable pack. It would have meant building an economy around pack recharge which is a large initial capital cost. It would have meant developing and commercialising robotics beyond the capabilities of the time to do autoswap.
- magicalhippo 3y ago> EV should be redesigned around a common core swappable battery technology. I don't think this is very feasible. Different battery chemistries inherently have different voltages and densities. So switching battery chemistry might require electronics with a higher voltage rating. And you can't swap in a battery with a very different weight, not just due to suspension but also structure and breaks if the battery is much heavier. This is the case for the BMW i3 where the 94Ah model can get upgraded to the new 120Ah battery because it was designed with a sturdier frame, but the pre-94Ah models can't because they lack the sturdy frame. And there might be additional concerns like different cooling requirements etc.