3 ms·
The point is obviously that the app developer should be able to host the app themselves, or have some other third party do it who charges lower fees, not that A
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
The point is obviously that the app developer should be able to host the app themselves, or have some other third party do it who charges lower fees, not that Apple should have to do it for free.
"Use Apple's store or those customers can't buy your app" is forcing people to sell on Apple.
- robertlagrant 3y agoNo it's not. If Apple didn't exist, people wouldn't suddenly be freer. Developing for Apple, and the job of "mobile developer" they invented, are both choices.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoEverything is a choice. If a mugger has a knife on you, you can choose to let them stab you instead of giving them your money, but we still say they forced you to give them your money. Because the choice has to be a reasonable alternative. Which in this context is an alternate provider of the product or service that reasonably allows you to reach the same set of your customers.
- robertlagrant 3y agoThere's no point making bad analogies. Thinking mobile developers have the choice of "being stabbed or robbed" is not going to help us understand this economic situation better. Those instincts will definitely result in bad conclusions. > an alternate provider of the product or service that reasonably allows you to reach the same set of your customers If you target one company's customers, you can't complain about a lack of competition. If I only service BMWs, I need to do whatever certifications BMW say I need to do, and get a diagnostic tool that talks to BMWs. If I service cars in general, I don't. But then I won't make as big a profit from an easier to target set of potential customers.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> There's no point making bad analogies. The point is that "you have a choice" doesn't mean anything when the choice is between something you don't want and some impractical alternative which is even less of a solution than the thing you don't want. > If you target one company's customers, you can't complain about a lack of competition. But you're not -- you're doing the opposite. You want to sell your app to everyone no matter what platform they use. Which doesn't allow you to choose between Apple and Google or use them as leverage to get a better deal from the other, because you need both. > If I only service BMWs, I need to do whatever certifications BMW say I need to do, and get a diagnostic tool that talks to BMWs. If you want to make and sell brake pads for BMWs, you can just do it. You don't need BMW's permission, and shouldn't, and if they try to stop you, you have the right to complain about it. > If I service cars in general, I don't. How are you supposed to do that? If BMW is allowed to get away with it then so will Volkswagen and no matter what kind of car you want to work on, you're still getting held up by whoever made it. This is why Right to Repair is a thing, and it's weird that your analogy to something you think should happen is a thing widely regarded as deserving of scorn and opposition.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> How are you supposed to do that? By doing the tasks that don't require as much specialism, across more vendors. You can target who you like on a spectrum of niche but expensive jobs to mass-market but cheaper jobs. I would only object to people choosing niche but expensive, and then complaining about the niche. > This is why Right to Repair is a thing, and it's weird that your analogy to something you think should happen is a thing widely regarded as deserving of scorn and opposition Scornful people have always existed, but that doesn't mean they should be especially listened to. We aren't talking about right to repair. Anyone can repair a BMW, but they need more training and tools to do the harder jobs.
- smoldesu 3y ago> Scornful people have always existed, but that doesn't mean they should be especially listened to. Are you describing consumer lobbyists or Apple, with these words?