4 ms·
> When you take samples of ocean water at various depths and locations and they all come back with having microplastics, you can go ahead and say we've crossed
by bluGill 3y ago
> When you take samples of ocean water at various depths and locations and they all come back with having microplastics, you can go ahead and say we've crossed a boundary.
Until you can show that these are harmful though who cares? Are all micro plastics harmful, or are some worse than others? These details are important. If there is no harm then I don't care. Most people shouting "microplastics" or "chemicals" are yelling about a symptom that might or might not be harmful.
- specialist 3y agoIIRC many human made chemicals interrupt the reproduction of critters. esp Amphibians, reptiles, birds, fish. That's bad, right? Like compounds which act like hormones (estrogens?) and mess up all sorts of stuff and causes tumors and so forth. Further IIRC, studies of these harmful chemicals more often than not indicate they also adversely impact primates. Enough evidence to merit further study. But we don't. Why not? Humans somehow managed without forever chemicals and face cream with micro beads for millennias. Why not hit "pause" on any questionables? Let the science catch up, to better inform policy. What's few more years delay, in the grand scheme of things? As a big fan of the precautionary principle, I'm always mystified by denial of potential risks. esp When those profiteering from the risks won't face any consequences. If we were discussing finance, we'd blather about "principle agents" and "uncollaterized debt", and the game theory would be obvious and uncontroversial. To honest players.
- dylan604 3y agoI find it depressing that you do not feel that these microplastics or chemicals (not sure of your use of quotes) showing up in our food and water sources is not a red flag for you. We're seeing more and more studies showing that these things accumulate. That doesn't seem like something we should take note of to you?
- dubcanada 3y agoLet's pose a hypothetical, let's say they are bad, but it takes us 25 years to figure that out. Take asbestos for example. What exactly do we do when it's suddenly too late? Is preventative action for a possibility not worth it? We do tons of stuff to prevent extremely rare possibilities from happening, why is doing something for "microplastics" suddenly not a big deal?
- gowld 3y agoThe world is full of dirt, and it's not healthy to drink it. But we can, should, and do filter it out of our drinks.
- dylan604 3y agobut not all dirt is equal. some dirt is laden with forever chemicals or other toxic pollutants from industrial processes. some dirt is full of microplastics. if i were to offer you two glasses of a clear liquid and said one is clean water and the other is full of microplastics and forever chemicals, would you drink either one? what if we passed both glasses through a Brita, would you drink either of them then? what level of processing would you be comfortable with before drinking either of them? or, more to your point, what if i said that both glasses were the results of filtering out all of the dirt. one glass from dirt from a farm, and the other was from a local dump with a nearby 3M PFAS plant. how would you feel about the water then?