3 ms·
> But how could you say when this has crossed a "boundary" When you take samples of ocean water at various depths and locations and they all come back with hav
by dylan604 3y ago
> But how could you say when this has crossed a "boundary"
When you take samples of ocean water at various depths and locations and they all come back with having microplastics, you can go ahead and say we've crossed a boundary.
When you have factories producing "forever" chemicals that have high concentrations feeding into water table and soil that can be detected large distances away from the source, you can consider a boundary crossed.
You don't have to be obtuse about admitting we've fucked up, we continue to fuck up, and we are very hesitant to stop fucking up. To me, trying to put these definitions of what is a "boundary" seems rather small minded. We know we're causing things. We know we don't have to do these things, but we're lazy and comfortable with what these things allow us to do. Until we can fix human nature, I don't see us fixing mother nature.
- nullstyle 3y ago> We know we don't have to do these things, but we're lazy and comfortable with what these things allow us to do. That's absurdly reductive.
- dylan604 3y agoIs it? The source for these things tends to be from the waste of the things society throws away after using once. If we weren't comfortable with it, we'd make changes to make the discomfort go away. If we feel some discomfort but choose to ignore it, we're lazy.
- nullstyle 3y agoYes, your opinion here is absurdly reductive. Open your eyes, my dude. Get out there and live a little; It shouldn't hard to see that the situation is more complex than "We're lazy sinners." Here's just one perspective on the complicated situation we find ourselves in: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OW8vkUY93i8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OW8vkUY93i8. There are many perspectives on this _historic global issue_ if you are open to them.
- gausswho 3y agoI'm interested in your summary of the video's content.
- nullstyle 3y agoI’m not offering it; IMO stuff at this scale should be ruminated upon. Summaries and snap judgements will be wrong.
- gausswho 3y agoThen your contribution is noise. This is HN. You don't make your case by dropping a video link.
- nullstyle 3y agoHi kettle
- dylan604 3y agothat's pretty lame. you were not asked for your opinion. you provided a link to a 2.5+ hour video. you were asked to summarize it. if you can't summarize something without including your opinion and snap judgement, then this isn't really someone worth having a conversation. you can't come at someone with a video saying "here's why i think your wrong" and not be able to explain what the video is about and expect people to take you seriously
- nullstyle 3y agoI sort of expected as much out of someone who characterizes the issue as you do, so I'll offer you a contradiction: Why is climate change "our" fault when the number one, single biggest emitter of greenhouse gas in the world is the US Military. Where does my personal responsibility factor into the motions of Arleigh Burke-class destroyers? Is there a letter I can send to make a difference? If you believe so, I've got a bridge to sell you. The reality by my reckoning is that my choices and actions exist almost entirely separate from the goings on of geopolitics, and that's why the situation is more complicated than "We are just too lazy." That's just one face of the shit die we are rolling. The video I mentioned is a deep dive on another face of this poopy-d20: The face that says "Climate change wouldn't be an issue if we just had fewer people to deal with." I won't summarize the two and a half hour long video because it deserves to be watched and commented on directly, rather than given the internet hot-take you request. And for the record, I think your attitude is lame too. I wasn't saying anything about my snap judgement, I was saying the documentary doesn't deserve _your_ snap judgement. My judgement is that the video challenges people who think personal responsibility is _the_ driving factor in climate change. Furthermore, I'm not looking for a conversation, but rather I'm hoping you stop talking and start gaining some better perspective on that which you comment. But you do you... I'm not trying to tell you how to internet. P.S. Rate limits on posting in this space is one more reason why we can't have a conversation here.
- bluGill 3y ago> When you take samples of ocean water at various depths and locations and they all come back with having microplastics, you can go ahead and say we've crossed a boundary. Until you can show that these are harmful though who cares? Are all micro plastics harmful, or are some worse than others? These details are important. If there is no harm then I don't care. Most people shouting "microplastics" or "chemicals" are yelling about a symptom that might or might not be harmful.
- specialist 3y agoIIRC many human made chemicals interrupt the reproduction of critters. esp Amphibians, reptiles, birds, fish. That's bad, right? Like compounds which act like hormones (estrogens?) and mess up all sorts of stuff and causes tumors and so forth. Further IIRC, studies of these harmful chemicals more often than not indicate they also adversely impact primates. Enough evidence to merit further study. But we don't. Why not? Humans somehow managed without forever chemicals and face cream with micro beads for millennias. Why not hit "pause" on any questionables? Let the science catch up, to better inform policy. What's few more years delay, in the grand scheme of things? As a big fan of the precautionary principle, I'm always mystified by denial of potential risks. esp When those profiteering from the risks won't face any consequences. If we were discussing finance, we'd blather about "principle agents" and "uncollaterized debt", and the game theory would be obvious and uncontroversial. To honest players.
- dylan604 3y agoI find it depressing that you do not feel that these microplastics or chemicals (not sure of your use of quotes) showing up in our food and water sources is not a red flag for you. We're seeing more and more studies showing that these things accumulate. That doesn't seem like something we should take note of to you?
- dubcanada 3y agoLet's pose a hypothetical, let's say they are bad, but it takes us 25 years to figure that out. Take asbestos for example. What exactly do we do when it's suddenly too late? Is preventative action for a possibility not worth it? We do tons of stuff to prevent extremely rare possibilities from happening, why is doing something for "microplastics" suddenly not a big deal?