3 ms·
I don't know what previous commenter you're referring to. I worry that you're confusing heritability with genetic determination, failing to account for the way
by tptacek 3y ago
I don't know what previous commenter you're referring to.
I worry that you're confusing heritability with genetic determination, failing to account for the ways in which environments are inherited along with genetics, tacitly claiming that IQ is fixed at birth by genetics, ignoring epigenetics, and, of course, working under the assumption that IQ testing is statistically meaningful to the point where the kinds of comparisons you're trying to make are valid.
Your argument seems to condense down to "tall people have tall kids, so smart people have smart kids, so any demographic IQ pattern we see must primarily be fixed by genetics". That argument --- I'm paraphrasing it and apologize to the extent it doesn't capture what you're saying --- is weak in a bunch of places that you're not acknowledging, let alone rebutting. But more importantly, it's not a scientific argument; it's just a subjective, intuitive claim. Your intuitions are different from mine.
- seec 3y agoI don't know what previous commenter you're referring to. You wrote this, to the parent I replied to. tptacek 14 days ago | parent | prev | next [–] Every time someone here mentions the heritability of IQ, I wonder what they think that term means, because it clearly does not mean what most people intuitively think it does. The "issue" you are talking about has already been addressed ; it is not something that has an effect large enough to be relevant, at least for a small number of generations. We could talk about the very long-term effects, and the necessity of territory/environment control but that's an even more politically loaded subject and it doesn't change what I say. You seemed even more confused about probability than you think I am about genetics, even if you lack that intuition, it does not make its effect go away. Then again, since you seemd to have "forgotten" a previous comment of yours, I am inclined to think that you are either arguing in bad faith or don't really understand what you are saying. I would be happy to argue those things with a trained geneticist but since my argument is probabilistic it wouldn't even matter that much. Research seems to say the same thing I do, abeit with a lot more politicaly correct wrapping.
- tptacek 3y agoWhat effect size are you talking about? The heritability effect size? What is the "effect size" of a simple ratio of genetic variance to trait variance? What confounding effect do you think I'm suggesting to you?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]