3 ms·
My only real gripe with Bluetooth is an implementation detail that many audio sink devices (headphones, speakers etc.) consistently get wrong: Almost all audio
by lxgr 3y ago
My only real gripe with Bluetooth is an implementation detail that many audio sink devices (headphones, speakers etc.) consistently get wrong:
Almost all audio sink devices will connect to the last connected source upon starting up. So far, so good – often that's exactly what I want, and it saves me from having to go into the source device's BT or sound menu to select the target device manually. This is great in cars, for example (unless you share a car).
But what many devices don't allow is "kicking out an existing source device" from a new connecting source device. This means that in order to use the sink, I'll need to chase down the currently connected source in my house and manually disconnect it (since sinks usually don't have any UI affordances to disconnect the current source without shutting down the sink).
Some newer Bluetooth sinks, including Apple's AirPods, do support that behavior, and it's been an absolute game changer for me. I really wish Bose would adopt it too; their "connect to two devices simultaneously" hack usually does way more harm than good, especially when some of these devices are shared in a household.
- philomath_mn 3y agoThis used to drive me nuts as well but I was able to find a fix on Android: if you put your phone into developer mode you get an option to only ever connect to one device at a time. I flipped this on and it works perfectly. The current device never gets booted and switching manually is easy in the rare case I want to use the other device.
- lxgr 3y agoMy problem isn’t the phone (i.e. the source device), but rather some sink devices not allowing new inbound connections while they’re already connected to something (i.e. the wrong thing). I can live with sometimes having audio focus stolen by some other Bluetooth device, since that's usually my desired behavior; I just want there to be a remedy for me that does not require walking through the apartment and hunting down potential source devices hogging my desired sink device.
- ttoinou 3y agoVery annoying indeed. And closing the lid on a macbook doesnt change anything to this behavior !
- lxgr 3y agoYep. There used to be a setting that changed this behavior, "allow Bluetooth connections even when in standby" or something to that extent, but that seems to be gone since the switch to Apple's own CPUs, just like "Power Nap" – presumably the efficiency cores use so little power that it's not even worth offering a switch to deactivate that behavior anymore.
- tommiegannert 3y agoOnly one? BT in my car: Spotify on the phone starts to auto-play as soon as it connects. Because car = music, apparently. I still haven't been able to figure out if this is Spotify, Android or Mercedes being dumb. Similar to your issue, my laptop and I are often exactly far enough apart that my Bose headphones start an infinite connect/disconnect cycle, with a tediously long "Connected to laptop" message every 30 seconds. For that scenario, it would have been enough if it just stopped trying after a few short connections. My conclusion is that we've had wireless devices for >20 years, but have barely scratched the surface of the implications in terms of UX.
- lxgr 3y ago> BT in my car: Spotify on the phone starts to auto-play as soon as it connects. Because car = music, apparently. I still haven't been able to figure out if this is Spotify, Android or Mercedes being dumb. It's your car. Some automatically send the "play/resume" control signal whenever they start up, which causes Android to resume playing on the most recently active audio app. No idea who thought that that was a reasonable default... > Similar to your issue, my laptop and I are often exactly far enough apart that my Bose headphones start an infinite connect/disconnect cycle, with a tediously long "Connected to laptop" message every 30 seconds. For that scenario, it would have been enough if it just stopped trying after a few short connections. It's not a real solution in any way, but if you're usually confident what device you're connected to, you can disable voice output via the Bose Connect app.