3 ms·
That would make "one-time pad" a British term, which is consistent with the non-existence of this term in the early American documents. Even if "one-time pad"
by adrian_b 3y ago
That would make "one-time pad" a British term, which is consistent with the non-existence of this term in the early American documents.
Even if "one-time pad" had been used by the British during WWII, that would still make its use in Cryptonomicon inappropriate, because there it was used by an American.
Thanks for pointing to Leo Marks' book. I have just browsed it and it is weird how unfamiliar he was with the previous cryptographic literature, despite being a trained cryptographer.
According to his memoirs, Leo Marks had great difficulties in rediscovering the "letter one-time pads", in order to replace the "digit one-time pads", which were inconvenient for Morse transmission.
Not only the solution to his problem was clearly explained in Vernam's article from 1926, which had been published in both the Transactions of the A.I.E.E and in the Journal of the A.I.E.E, which were journals important enough to be available in various British libraries, but the solution searched by him was also explained in various popular publications, even in one of the novels written by Jules Verne almost a century earlier.
Anyone familiar with the history of cryptography and with the various kinds of ciphers used in the past would have thought instantaneously to the correct solution for implementing the desired "letter one-time pad" (i.e. by addition modulo 26 of the numerical positions of the letters in the alphabet). Also, had they been well aware that good one-time pads are unbreakable, they should have easily realized that the double encryption with a codebook followed by a one-time pad is useless.
From his memoirs, it appears that his knowledge of cryptography, at least in the initial part of WWII, was much inferior to the content of the manuals written by Friedman, which were used for training the American cryptographers, although it appears that in time, after gaining experience, he has become good enough.
- MeImCounting 3y agoI would like to point out that much of Lawrence's work during the war was done in Bletchley Park and with a British crypto-related detachment.
- mandevil 3y agoAs he presents himself in the book, at least, he was basically a dilettante, one of many who got sent to the GC&CS at Bletchley (the people who get described in Kahn 1991 or Winterbotham or Calvorcessi in their explanations of who worked at Hut 6 or 8 as 'linguists, mathematicians, people who wrote crossword puzzles' types). He flunked out of GC&CS, however, and only got the job with SOE by the skin of his teeth (the general in charge of SOE wanted him to decrypt an actual operational message but forgot to give him the key- the general wanted to see how fast he was at doing the double transposition cipher compared to a clerk, but instead Marks over the course of a day's work cracked the actually sent operational message without the key, which impressed/scared the general far more and got him the job). But he had just rapid wartime training of learning by doing, and he was largely by himself as the only cryptographer in SOE, at least as he depicts it, so it highly plausible to me that he missed a lot of things that were widely known in the broader cryptography community. (It was because he was so isolated from the rest of the British crypto community that he ended up allowed to write public memoirs, I suspect. Wiki says he wrote it in the early 1980's and wasn't allowed to publish until 1998.)