4 ms·
Bees have an internal sense of time (2022)
- piinbinary 3y ago"Bees get jet lag" That seems like a much simpler experiment than the previous ones!
- beders 3y agoWell, in 1929 they couldn't really get on a red-eye to New York ;)
- bisRepetita 3y agoAnd one still cannot in 2024 ;). Almost all red-eye flights go from east to west. There are none from Paris to NYC. There are some from America's west coast to Asia though, because those are super long flights. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red-eye_flight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red-eye_flight
- vlovich123 3y agoOn the other hand, the totality of experiments should have suggested that they likely can. You can keep trying to find better experiments, but if bees are defeating each one, your prior should be changing
- ct0 3y agoDid you see this on reddit? Pretty cool story though.
- dmurray 3y agoOysters are thought to have the opposite behaviour, per a famous experiment by Brown in 1954. If you transport them several hours of longitude away and keep them in a dark lab, they don't suffer jetlag, but instead they mysteriously adjust to the local lunar cycle. At least, that's what I thought, but this criticism of the methodology [0] doesn't make it look conclusive, and presumably it would have been replicated if it was any good. [0] https://cdn.centerforinquiry.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/29/1993/01/22165150/p83.pdf https://cdn.centerforinquiry.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/29...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dvh 3y agoDo humans perceive time?
- sctb 3y agoYou could certainly argue that we do not. Perceptions are not instantaneous, and if they can be said to "take time" then they cannot have time as their object of perception directly. And even if they "take time", perceptions are ending simultaneously as they are beginning. Being aware of the passage of time does not require perception, as anyone can report when they have an understanding of how long they slept as soon as they wake. Not sure how all that relates to bees, though. Anyway, no abstract musing about time is complete without a word from Dōgen: "You may suppose that time is only passing away, and not understand that time never arrives."
- nickpsecurity 3y agoWe seem to perceive time indirectly. Examples of how include our feelings, seeing changes in environment with temporal associations, and even counting the seconds that we generate. We are perceiving the passage of time in these cases as observed change in the perceptible state of the universe. If time itself is change, then we are directly observing it. If time is something else, and it causes change, then we can’t observe it but can observe the effects. We’ll probably perceive it similarly either way.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> We seem to perceive time indirectly From all indications, time is an emergent property of causality. And we directly perceive causality.
- eszed 3y agoThis is totally anecdotal, but I suspect this is a skill that varies across the population. A buddy in high school was uncannily accurate when guessing the time without access to a watch or clock. His error bar would increase with the amount of time past between "experiments", but was never more than ~5 minutes out, at a three or four hour interval. Inside an hour he was always +/- 1 minute. He thought it was unremarkable, and that we were weirdos for always quizzing him about the time. Feinman writes somewhere about training himself to accurately perceive a minute, with some success. I'm curious whether there are any human studies about this.
- utdiscant 3y agoI am currently reading "What Would Animals Say If We Asked the Right Questions?" by Vinciane Despret, which is full of interesting stories like this and questions how we perceive the intelligence (and other aspects) of animals. Might be an interesting read for people who find this story interesting.
- ryanblakeley 3y agoThanks for the recommendation. I write about animal intelligence and will be keen to pick that one up. The molecular basis of circadian rhythm has been studied in fruit flies. Every cell has a chemical clock which adjusts for a range of temperatures. They found that calorie restriction and cold temperature extends the life span of fruit flies. But if you alter the DNA of their circadian clock those lifespan increases do not happen.
- gehwartzen 3y agoFunny little cartoon I enjoyed wrt this subject: https://falseknees.com/comics/405.html https://falseknees.com/comics/405.html
- max_ 3y agoThanks for the recommendation!
- FergusArgyll 3y agoTyler Cowen often asks guests: What will you ask the whales once we can speak to them? I still don't feel like I have a good answer
- solarengineer 3y agoWhat is your view of humans? How much are you impacted by the sounds from our boats? Which areas do you no longer visit due to the absence of plankton? Tell us about the harms that we do to the oceans - we may know some, but we'd like to know if there are any more. How are you impacted by our plastic pollution? Teach us to speak to Orcas and Dolphins
- 3y ago
- s1artibartfast 3y agoDoes a line of candles "perceive" time? Does a wave in a pond "perceive" time? Does my alarm clock "perceive" time? I think a less hyperbolic statement is that bees can measure time. perception has the connotation of conscious awareness.
- faitswulff 3y agoAt what point do you consider living organisms to be conscious? Any threshold is essentially arbitrary.
- yreg 3y agoWe don't know, but the title makes it sound like we do know.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI personally think self-awareness is a pre-requisite for consciousness. >ar·bi·trar·y, adjective based on random choice or personal whim, rather than any reason or system. I don't think this threshold is arbitrary. I think it is part of a set of word definitions that and are logically compatible, coherent, and useful. Similarly, I dont think it arbitrary to say the bee is a living organism, but the alarm clock is not. Would you argue that the any definition of "living" is similarly arbitrary?
- Jensson 3y agoWhat is self-awareness? Do you think dogs are self aware? I think dogs are conscious at least even if they fail to recognize themselves in a mirror. Being aware that you are a consciousness requires intelligence, not just consciousness.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI think dogs can be self aware. I think self-awareness is the ability to comprehend the "Self" as distinct from the "environment" and then compute and weigh the likely outcomes of different actions. It is high level thinking with many pre-requisites. An alarm clock is not self aware, because it doesn't model the world, and select between actions. Similarly, a bee, (which I believe to act on pre-programed instinct, not in the moment reason), is not self aware. This is because it selects between actions, but can not logically model the world. A dog, on the other hand, can build logical models of the world, and then take actions based on that. It can that begging from one person results in treats, while begging from another results in discipline. It can update this logic and behavior based on new information.
- dang 3y agoRelated: How we learned that bees can tell time (2021) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36177030 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36177030 - June 2023 (12 comments)
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoFrom what I understand, the timekeeping ability helps them to communicate the locations of points of interest (nectar sources and hive locations). Bees are pretty awesome. Here's a cool Cosmos episode, that discusses them: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubE9hjrsHmI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubE9hjrsHmI
- adr1an 3y agoThat was my very first thought after reading the title! "Of course, or they would dance without rhythm!" ;)
- TibbityFlanders 3y ago[dead]