3 ms·
This is a great example of how Hacker News comment section preferences do not represent the general population’s preferences. If you’ve ever worked in purchasi
by Aurornis 3y ago
This is a great example of how Hacker News comment section preferences do not represent the general population’s preferences.
If you’ve ever worked in purchasing or IT, you see how much people who travel or move around value thin, small, and light notebooks.
If you’ve used modern thin, light notebooks, you’ve seen how little it matters for performance and battery life. A modern Apple laptop is tiny and performs extremely well.
Upgradeable RAM is a very niche demand. If your goals are simultaneously to keep a machine forever while minimizing upfront cost, then compromising form to make RAM upgradeable is a reasonable decision. However, most people just want an all-new laptop come upgrade time because CPUs and GPUs are advancing rapidly. People who know they’re going to keep the laptop forever will spend an extra couple hundred on RAM up front.
I think HN has also lost sight of how the average laptop user operates. Even I had an 8GB RAM secondary Apple laptop for testing and it worked completely fine for a mix of day to day tasks and coding. I wasn’t going to be doing Chromium compiles in the background while cycling through 100 background tabs in Chrome, but for even moderate usage with Chrome and Electron apps and an IDE it was fine.
> I had a Panasonic CF-Y5 which was a 14" 1.5kg laptop and yet it included a DVD burner. It was not thin for sure. This thin craze is only making worse laptops because you have no space for cooling, ports and keyboard travel.
I suspect a lot of these perspectives are anchored to past realities: Laptops from 5-10 years ago where carrying a jumbo laptop did actually have significant advantages. Times have changed and all of the anecdotes from ancient laptops or even 2010-era laptops just don’t apply.
- chx 3y ago> where carrying a jumbo laptop did actually have significant advantages. it's bewildering to call the engineering marvel those Panasonic and Sony laptops me and a few others talk about here "jumbo". It's been more than 17 years and the only physical advantage of the Macbook M3 Pro 14" over the CF-Y5 is the thickness change. That's it. Near two decades of advancement, the laptop is the same weight except it went from 1.3"-1.9" to 0.61" thickness. It's been 3.7 lbs then, 3.4 pounds now with the Max being 3.6 lbs and I bet merely dropping the DVD writer would've been enough bring these to par. Jumbo...? The Dell XPS M2010 was a jumbo, that's not in question but these? > move around value thin, small, and light notebooks. We are on the same page about light. Let me tell you, I was not happy how much heavier my next laptop, the ThinkPad T420 was at 4.9lbs. That's a full third heavier. No, it's the demand for insane thinness that I argue was manufactured artificially. If you want smaller laptops, there were, back then, both from Panasonic and Sony as they used to call them, subnotebooks, at 11" and 12" size with the exact same argument possible.
- akagusu 3y ago> Upgradeable RAM is a very niche demand. If your goals are simultaneously to keep a machine forever while minimizing upfront cost, then compromising form to make RAM upgradeable is a reasonable decision. However, most people just want an all-new laptop come upgrade time because CPUs and GPUs are advancing rapidly. People who know they’re going to keep the laptop forever will spend an extra couple hundred on RAM up front. I work with IT support and I can tell you upgradeable RAM is NOT a very niche demand. Upgrade RAM is the 1st thing users ask when their computer are becoming slow and believe me, they always get very upset when they find out their laptops don't have an expansion slot.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThin is sexy, light is useful. People who don't stop and think about it generally associate thin with light simply because small things are lighter as a general rule. But for laptops, it could well be an inverse relationship: a light laptop may require a stronger, heavier material. And thinness is pretty useless. a 1" thick laptop takes roughly the same amount of space in your bag as a 0.6" thin macbook air, but weight you notice on your shoulder after lugging it through airports for a few hours. It's a pick 2 of 3 situation: 2 of thin, light and expandable. Only 2 of those 3 are useful features. It's the same issue with material: a high quality plastic can have exactly the right amount of plasticity so that it's neither too brittle nor too flexible so that it provides maximum protection when dropped, while still being light. But plastic isn't sexy.
- hulitu 3y ago> light is useful Except when it is not. Laptops with a dvd drive or an ethernet port or more than 2 USB A ports have become very rare.
- screye 3y agoI genuinely wonder why HN people care so much about laptop upgradeability. It is your primary and likely only tool in a profession where everyone makes 6 figures. Spending an extra 3000$ every 3 years doesn't sound all that bad, as far as professional spending goes. Consultants spend more on suits every year.
- screye 3y agoThat being said, upgradeable RAM is an easy request to meet, so there isn't a single good reason to omit it. (The first slot can be soldered on, but leave another empty) Same cam be said for 1 UsbA port and a micro SD card slot.