2 ms·
Chinese language unification has been a massive, longstanding, incomplete project for basically all the history of China. https://www.globalasia.org/v12no2/feat
by pjc50 3y ago
Chinese language unification has been a massive, longstanding, incomplete project for basically all the history of China. https://www.globalasia.org/v12no2/feature/chinas-long-struggle-for-linguistic-unification_samuel-s-kim https://www.globalasia.org/v12no2/feature/chinas-long-strugg...
Quoting this para because it's so good as a statement of requirements:
“What we need today is a readable, audible, singable, speakable, dictatable language which we can read aloud without the need to translate into the spoken language, with the help of which we can take notes without the need to translate into the literary language, which we can [use] at the speaker’s desk as well as on the stage, and which even village grannies, women and children can understand if we read it to them. Any language that does not meet these requirements is not a living language, and can under no circumstances become the national language of our country.”
- gumby 3y agoThough the languages of China were quite diverse well beyond the Chinese Revolution.
- samus 3y agoThis seems like a "see three, pick two" problem. Compulsory education in the standard language will eventually solve most of these concerns. Ready understandability by elders seems quite hard to achieve, and might only possible if the new standard is quite similar to an already widespread register. And that's not even addressing the issue that daily life of some ethnic subgroups might happen in a completely different language, who might also be actively resistant of assimilating into the national culture.