3 ms·
I think that assumption is why Yudkowsky suggested an international binding agreement to not develop a "too smart" AI (the terms AGI and ASI mean different thin
by ben_w 3y ago
I think that assumption is why Yudkowsky suggested an international binding agreement to not develop a "too smart" AI (the terms AGI and ASI mean different things to different people) wouldn't be worth the paper it was written on unless everyone was prepared to enforce it with air strikes on any sufficiently large computer cluster.
- trevyn 3y agoI think it would help the discussion to understand what the world is like outside of the US and Europe (and… Japan?). There are no rules out here. There is no law. It is a fucking free-for-all. Might makes right. Do there exist GPUs? Shit will get trained.
- ben_w 3y agoSure. And is the US responding to attacks on shipping south of Yemen by saying: """There are no rules out here. There is no law. It is a fucking free-for-all. Might makes right. We can't do anything.""" or is that last sentence instead "Oh hey, that's us, we are the mighty."
- trevyn 3y agoHeh. Well played, even if you put words in my mouth. (A surprisingly effective LLM technique, btw) We’ll see if the west has the will to deny GPUs to the entire rest of the world. I will say that Yudkowsky’s clusters aren’t relevant anymore. You can do this in your basement. Man, shit is moving fast. Edit: wait, that cat is out of the bag too, RTW already has GPUs. The techniques matter way more than absolute cutting-edge silicon. Much to the chagrin of the hardware engineers and anyone who wants to gate on hardware capability.
- ben_w 3y ago> Heh. Well played, even if you put words in my mouth. (A surprisingly effective LLM technique, btw) Thanks :) > Edit: wait, that cat is out of the bag too, RTW already has GPUs. The techniques matter way more than absolute cutting-edge silicon. Much to the chagrin of the hardware engineers and anyone who wants to gate on hardware capability. Depends on how advanced an AI has to be to count as "a threat worth caring about". To borrow a cliché, if you ask 10 people where to draw that particular line, you get 20 different answers.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- visarga 3y agoI think not even Sam and Satya agree on the definition of AGI with so much money at stake. Everyone with their own definitions, and hidden interests.
- ben_w 3y agoWithout knowing them, I can easily believe that. Even without reference to money.