3 ms·
if the 'devalustion' of human creative output and replacing real humans with cheap ai solutions funneling wealth to the rich is in fact the 'by far biggest harm
by kragen 3y ago
if the 'devalustion' of human creative output and replacing real humans with cheap ai solutions funneling wealth to the rich is in fact the 'by far biggest harm' then basically there's nothing to worry about. no government would ban or even restrict ai on those grounds
even the 'terrists can figure out how to build an a-bomb' problem is relatively inconsequential
what ai safety people are worried about, by contrast, is that on april 22 of next year, at 7:07:33 utc, every person in the world will keel over dead at once, because the ai doesn't need them and they pose a risk to its objectives. or worse things than that
i don't think that's going to happen, but that's what they're concerned about
- visarga 3y agoFirst the AI need to self replicate, GPUs are hard to make. So postpone this scenario until AI is fully standing on its own.
- ben_w 3y agoOTOH, GPUs are made by machines, not by greasy fingers hand-knitting them like back in the late 1960s. And an AI can just be wrong, which happens a lot; an AI wrongly thinking it should kill everyone may still succeed at that, though I doubt the capability would be as early as next year.
- kridsdale1 3y agoAnd machines are operated by people using materials brought by hand off of trucks driven by hand that come from other facilities where many humans are required going back to raw ore.
- ben_w 3y ago> trucks driven by hand Good thing nobody's working on automating that and nobody has any real world experience of such systems on public roads :P (And the :P applies to basically all the supply chain, including the manufacturing of the equipment used to supply or manufacture the other equipment). The comment I replied to wrote: > So postpone this scenario until AI is fully standing on its own. This is closer than I think you think.
- visarga 3y agoThe IP behind advanced chips is protected fiercely.
- ben_w 3y agoDo you think humans design these chips by hand, or do they perhaps use a computer to help them because it's a bit tricky to make sure the electrons don't accidentally tunnel from an adjacent transistor if you're placing a few billion of them on the circuit diagram by hand given the scale they're at now?
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoDo you think intentionally quoting typos makes your argument stronger?
- kragen 3y agothere's no argument
- kridsdale1 3y agoSavage.
- Llamamoe 3y agoI'll take every person keeling over dead in pursuit of paperclip maximization over a corporation effectively enslaving the entirety of humanity to farm "value" out of them as though they're livestock, a threat that is already happening faster and faster thanks to sub-AGI models.