4 ms·
Castles were terribly expensive and time consuming to build. Yet they dot the landscape. The only way that could happen is if they were effective.
by WalterBright 3y ago
Castles were terribly expensive and time consuming to build. Yet they dot the landscape. The only way that could happen is if they were effective.
- consp 3y agoThey also have survivorship bias. Wooden palisades are effective but tend not to survive time.
- Tomte 3y agoThat argument only works in one direction: if castles had been ineffective, they wouldn't have been built so much. Yet every castle surviving is a castle that has been built. There are no castle at present that have never been built.
- mcv 3y agoThere are castles that have never played a role in a war, though. One of the most interesting castles in France, Bonaguil, is an almost perfectly designed castle with brilliantly designed defensive systems, but it was built in an area that never saw any major military campaigns. A theory is that the builder built it as a demonstration of his own skill in castle design.
- willvarfar 3y agoIt'd be a bit late to build the castle after the major military campaign, so the lack of campaigns doesn't mean the castles wouldn't get built in case of the future eventuality. It might go so far that perhaps the reason the area never saw major military campaigns is because of the defensibility of it's castles?
- mcv 3y agoI think most castles are still in the areas that saw the most fighting, although I don't have any good data on that. I know the Dordogne saw a lot of fighting, and it has a lot of castles that got upgraded regularly.
- WalterBright 3y agoCastles line both banks of the river Rhein. They were built to extract tolls from the river traffic.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- neilkk 3y agoEgyptians built pyramids in order that their kings would live forever. The pyramids were not effective at allowing their kings to live forever so why did they build so many? Stone Age people painted the animals they were going to hunt on rocks so that the pictures would entrap the animals' spirit and they would be easier to catch. This method of ensuring a good hunt was not effective so why did they do so many paintings?
- lupusreal 3y agoThe Egyptians believed their pyramids were effective. The nature of that belief made it difficult to challenge (who is to say those Pharaohs aren't still alive in their afterlife?) Military technology has to prove itself in this life, not the next. That's a more stringent test.
- neilkk 3y agoThe Great Wall of China is military technology, would you consider that its effectiveness is proven?
- samus 3y agoIt was primarily built to create a geographical barrier where otherwise there was none. Even though all such barriers can in principle be crossed or bypassed, they can still cause considerable tactical and logistical issues for any attacker. Without the wall, raiding bands of any size could just slip through and cause havoc. Only large and well-organized forces had siege equipment to break through wherever they wanted. Similarly, traffic and migration of peoples could be controlled and tolls and customs could be enforced. It also acted as an infrastructure for fast transmission of messages. In those ways, like the Roman Limes and the European castle networks, it was mostly an infrastructure for peaceful times. But even in war, it was preferred to bypass it or to capture a gateway fortress, otherwise these forces could cause enormous problems for the attackers. For example, only allying with the Ming garrison at Liaoning made it possible for the Manchus to crush the short-lived Shun dynasty and establish the Qing dynasty.
- 3y ago
- foofie 3y ago> The only way that could happen is if they were effective. I think most castles were built mainly as status symbols, and not the result of a regional or national defense strategy. Castles are imposing buildings in places that dominate the landscape, built by local leaders to project their power and influence. You see a few castles being built in the US in non-feudal times for similar reasons. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_castles_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_castles_in_the_United_... Afterwards the defensive purpose of these structures started to gave way to the more opulent side. Some manor houses featured defensive structures mainly for show, although they served the same purpose.
- samus 3y agoYou're contradicting yourself. Building them to protect local leader's power and influence and national defense are very much the same thing in feudal societies.
- foofie 3y ago> You're contradicting yourself. Building them to protect local leader's power and influence and national defense are very much the same thing in feudal societies. I said "project", not "protect". Meaning, one is a kin to peacocking, while the other is literally building moats and draw bridges to keep the enemy at bay.
- samus 3y agoProject vs. protect actually doesn't make a difference here. It's a fortified base from where sorties can be sent out into the surrounding area, projecting the noble's power. To stop that from happening, one has to capture the castle or be friendly with the garrison. This creates problems for anyone passing through, be they farmers, merchants, unfriendly neighbors of the noble, or an army passing through. Peacocking might have happened, but castles would be a useful form of peacocking. Be as that may, they were still mostly uncomfy money drains, barely earning back their running costs via tolls, and usually funded by major nobles who then sent their underlings to actually man the place. If at all possible, one would rather build two castle in useful locations than a single redundant one.