4 ms·
> That was dangerous enough, but at 200-400C carbon [tetrachloride] also reacts with water to form phosgene gas, which was used as a chemical weapon in World Wa
by hinkley 3y ago
> That was dangerous enough, but at 200-400C carbon [tetrachloride] also reacts with water to form phosgene gas, which was used as a chemical weapon in World War One. It is said that 85% of the 900,000 deaths attributed to gas were from phosgene so it was a pretty dangerous substance to have in your home or factory.
How much of modern longevity is sanitation, sterilization, and medicine, and how much is just not doing really, really dumb things anymore?
- pardoned_turkey 3y agoIn private life, we probably do more "dumb things" than we used to. The number of people dying in car accidents or due to drug overdoses is absolutely staggering and is a fairly recent phenomenon. The gains from banning lawn darts and no longer using fire grenades are inconsequential in comparison. To be fair, workplace safety has improved quite a bit - some of it thanks to regulation, some due to economic shifts (less mining, more office work). This improved the life expectancy of lower-class men. But that aside, a lot of the gains in life expectancy have to do with very basic things - like flush toilets, along with generally improved standards of living.
- a_gnostic 3y agoCan't have workplace accidents, if your factory moved to China…
- lettergram 3y ago> In private life, we probably do more "dumb things" than we used to. The number of people dying in car accidents or due to drug overdoses is absolutely staggering and is a fairly recent phenomenon. The gains from banning lawn darts and no longer using fire grenades are inconsequential in comparison. I would consider drug overdoses dramatically different than car accidents. To the point, "dumb things" where you put deadly chemical in jar (fire extinguisher) is not the same as purposely injecting yourself or accidentally losing control of your vehicle. For what it's worth, while drug fatalities are increasing (arguably there was an intentional act to start drugs, granted addition is less so): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_drug_overdose_death_rates_and_totals_over_time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_drug_overdose_de... Vehicle fatalities are actually going down per year (and have been, on average, since the inception of the car) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in_U.S._by_year https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in... > But that aside, a lot of the gains in life expectancy have to do with very basic things - like flush toilets, along with generally improved standards of living. I agree with you there, lots of minor things like vitamins, clean water, improved environmental controls, etc add up dramatically
- pksebben 3y agoSo like, here's the thing with the overdose crisis - it is in fact just like the dangerous chemicals being put in a jar. It's actually specifically that. The recent spike in drug overdoses has nearly nothing to do with people going out and making bad decisions (at least, not more than they've made over the last 50 years), but the fact that doctors and pharma companies, who ought to know better, keep putting fentanyl out into the world and making it as accessible as any other schedule 1 controlled substance. You know, like weed is a schedule 1 controlled substance (1). According to NIDA (who are the don't-do-drugs-mmkay folks, responsible for gems like the egg ad and DARE), the lion's share of the spike in drug-related fatalities is due to instances where the drugs taken were "in combination with synthetic opioids other than methadone" (2). That's fentanyl, folks. As cheap and easy to get as it is lethal, and here we are putting it in hospitals because anesthesiologists think it's just the bee's knees. So like, we're putting little microscopic landmines out there AND creating the circumstances for an unregulated black market that benefits from mixing said landmines into people's cocaine, which ostensibly they want because they have a really great business pitch they just gotta get out at 3am at the club (rather than a crippling addiction that's leading them to OD). IMHO, kinda similar to the fire grenades. No way bad shit ain't gonna happen and it's on us if we're surprised. 1 - https://www.dea.gov/drug-information/drug-scheduling https://www.dea.gov/drug-information/drug-scheduling 2 - https://nida.nih.gov/research-topics/trends-statistics/overdose-death-rates https://nida.nih.gov/research-topics/trends-statistics/overd...
- wegfawefgawefg 3y agoThank you for the information, I appreciate it. But for me your vernacular is a bit offputting. I had to force myself to finish reading your comment. "So like," in a written context takes away from the information. Or I could be wrong and people with similar speech will synchronize with you. I'm not attacking you, so I hope you don't feel that way, but it is something to consider.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoDidn't this construct recently become, like, accepted English grammar or something? Or was it the "because <noun>" thing?
- jayd16 3y agoDrug use is a modern thing? Opium, tobacco and alcohol are quite old.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ponector 3y agoDrug use is not a modern thing. Drug overdose is. It is much harder to overdose while smoking opium than swallowing pills or receiving a fentanyl injection.
- lostlogin 3y agoAnd drinking oneself to death has been a constant. Edit: it isn’t constant, but has held surprisingly steady. https://ourworldindata.org/alcohol-consumption https://ourworldindata.org/alcohol-consumption
- lostlogin 3y ago> The number of people dying in car accidents or due to drug overdoses is absolutely staggering and is a fairly recent phenomenon. If you don’t call alcohol poisoning a drug overdose, the stats get skewed to make the past look better.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Snow_Falls 3y agoAlways seemed strange to me how we've decided alcohol is different somehow.
- hilbert42 3y agoLogically you're right alcohol ought to be treated the same but culturally it's very different in that it's been a part of partaking of food—eating and drinking since before the beginning of recorded time. Alcohol is intrinsically ingrained in many if not most cultures.
- Retric 3y agoAlcohol poisoning was and is quite rare. Plenty of long term health issues from drinking and smoking, but we don’t consider diseases from shared needles as an overdose either. ~140,000 people die from excessive alcohol use in the U.S. each year, only ~2,000 of those are alcohol poisoning.
- idontwantthis 3y agoThe numbers cited on that within wikipedia are all over the place. > about 85% of the 90,000 deaths https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_weapons_in_World_War_I?wprov=sfti1#1915:_More_deadly_gases https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_weapons_in_World_War_... > where it was responsible for 85,000 deaths https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phosgene?wprov=sfti1# https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phosgene?wprov=sfti1# The second links to the first which makes a completely different claim with similar looking numbers but cites no source.
- cyberax 3y ago> That was dangerous enough, but at 200-400C carbon [tetrachloride] also reacts with water to form phosgene gas It sounds scary and serves as a good clickbait, but in reality it was not a big deal. This reaction is not quick, and if you have a fire that can burn at 300C while there's a significant amount of water vapor, then phosgene is not your biggest worry. And of course, liquid water from firefighting won't be hot enough. Now, don't try to weld stuff that has been recently cleaned with brake cleaner fluid. That WILL produce enough phosgene to poison you.
- hilbert42 3y ago"...brake cleaner fluid. ...enough phosgene to poison you." What's the solvent in brake cleaner fluid that breaks down to produce COCl2?
- awestley 3y agoTetrachloroethylene
- gilleain 3y agoI was curious, so looked this up, but I have no prior knowledge of this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brake_cleaner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brake_cleaner > Chlorinated brake cleaner containing tetrachloroethylene will, on exposure to high temperatures (above 500 °F (260 °C)) or strong UV light, decompose into phosgene and hydrogen chloride, both of which are extremely dangerous if inhaled So C2Cl4 - https://www.chemspider.com/Chemical-Structure.13837281.html https://www.chemspider.com/Chemical-Structure.13837281.html Oh, and this answer suggests that the reaction occurs with 'singlet' oxygen - https://chemistry.stackexchange.com/questions/76185/what-is-the-mechanism-behind-the-formation-of-phosgene-from-tetrachloroethylene https://chemistry.stackexchange.com/questions/76185/what-is-... (very pretty picture of the intermediates!)
- hilbert42 3y agoThanks for that. Yeah, upon thinking it stands to reason that tetrachloroethylene aka PERC is used as a brake cleaner—once the cleaner would have contained carbon tet. PERC has replaced CCl4 in drycleaning too as it's safer. Note it too has a similar odor to CCl4 — note my previous comment to kragen. My opinion nowadays is to avoid inhaling the vapors of or exposing one's skin to any of these volatile cleaners, paint thinners etc. whether they're chlorinated hydrocarbons or not. Just assume them all to be dangerous. Incidentally, the problem with chlorinated hydrocarbons turning into phosgene has been known for a century or more. I find it very strange that this info isn't an essential part of all trades training where such chemicals are likely to be encountered. (I've been whingeing on HN previously about the inadequate and inappropriate training of the GP in chemistry. Yes, we teach chemistry at highschool as if everyone was going to progress to a degree in chemistry—such training is quickly forgotten if one doesn't become a chemist. We need to teach everyone about chemistry and how to handle chemicals they encounter in daily life and the likely dangers they pose.)
- kragen 3y agothis is clueless pearl-clutching carbon tet used daily for cleaning things was probably a significant cause of morbidity and mortality, for the reasons explained in the article, though its acute toxicity is quite low carbon tet being thrown on a fire never was. if your house is on fire and you start breathing the combustion products, you are having a bad problem and will not go to the park today. you are about to die. you are still about to die even if you do not throw carbon tet on the fire in fact, the ammonia gas from modern monoammonium phosphate fire extinguishers (once the powder gets on an actual fire and starts actually extinguishing things) will kill you quicker than carbon tet vapor
- hilbert42 3y ago> though its acute toxicity is quite low That's the key problem, which encouraged its use in cleaning (especially drycleaning). Its effects come much later, prolonged use rots the liver and kidneys and it's understood to be a carcinogen. It's a damn good solvent though, I used to use it before the ban although I always avoided its vapors (as soon as I got the slightest whiff of its sweetish smell I'd move away or take evasive action).
- kragen 3y agoi'm too young to have used it for cleaning myself, but i've always heard it was amazing at cleaning things
- hilbert42 3y agoIt is. When I was a kid you could walk down a street full of shops and you didn't even have to look up to know you were near a drycleaning shop because of the characteristic odor CCl4. Once the drycleaning industry almost exclusively ran on the stuff. Tragically, many people like its sweetish odor or at least they don't find it objectionable. No doubt its 'pleasantness' cost many lives. Edit: incidentally, chloroalkanes such as trichloroethylene, C2HCl3, and 1,1,1-trichloroethane, CH3CCl3, and 1,1,2-Trichloroethane, CH2Cl—CHCl2, are also excellent solvents/cleaners and have similar sweetish smelling odors and can easily be confused with CCl4. They are all toxic in varying degrees (generally the fewer the hydrogen atoms the more toxic they are). Trichloroethylene (aka trichlor, Trilene) also used to be used as a volatile anesthetic as well as a cleaner. It's much safer than CCl4 and that was known even when I was using it as solvent/cleaner. I thus took less precautions with it than with CCl4. I recall once cleaning some electronic equipment in a confined space and when I got up to exit my legs collapsed under me. In 30 sec or so I was back to normal.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- YeGoblynQueenne 3y ago>> How much of modern longevity is sanitation, sterilization, and medicine, and how much is just not doing really, really dumb things anymore? What you mean things like absestos, chlorofluorocarbons, or unleaded gasoline, for example? Those are very modern and "really, really dumb".
- dghughes 3y ago>chlorofluorocarbons, or unleaded gasoline I think you meant leaded gasoline? Both were inventions of one man Thomas Midgley, Jr. He contracted polio and made a harness to assist himself to get out of bed and ended up accidentally strangling himself. What a guy.
- YeGoblynQueenne 3y agoYes indeed: _leaded_ gasoline. Thanks for the correction.