4 ms·
The point, as always, is that intelligent people find other intelligent people to hire by asking questions that aren't uniform or one-size-fits-all, or which on
by noduerme 15y ago
The point, as always, is that intelligent people find other intelligent people to hire by asking questions that aren't uniform or one-size-fits-all, or which only require regurgitation of facts, but rather by probing how and why a candidate thinks a certain way.
This should be obvious by now. Standard CV reviews, colleges and references say nothing about how efficiently a candidate is able to think through new problems or how elegant their solutions will be. Nor does that mean that formal training and real-world skill exist in an inverse relationship as a lot of self-taught coders (myself included) like to pretend it does. They simply aren't co-related, at least not as far as we can tell from most leading posts about hiring on HN.
So if the goal is efficiency, why not just hire people based on their IQ? What else is there that qualifies people for positions where their bosses 2 levels up have no idea how they're actually executing the work that's put in front of them, and rely completely on them to come to the best logical solutions to new problems creatively, quickly and every single time? The only other standard you might want to look for is trustworthiness, but you can't measure that in an interview.
Anyway, it doesn't matter if someone with 140+ IQ has ever coded before. It's probably worth paying to train them. So let's just cut to the chase. You need people with brains and integrity, and the rest of it is just huff and puff nonsense from HR people who don't have a clue, and couldn't do the job their hirees do.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- npc 15y agofirstly, there's legal issues with IQ tests in job interviews in the US at least secondly, IQ testing covers a number of areas, many of which are not necessarily related to the kind of thinking needed for programming. i think most of the verbal stuff in IQ tests wouldn't relate that much thirdly, even if someone aces the IQ test, there's still no indication that they would actually enjoy programming if they've never done it before. It's kind of pointless to train someone to code if they're just going to get sick of it and quit in 6 months. and fourth, an IQ test doesn't say anything about a person's ability to work with other people or prioritize things properly. an IQ test provides no protection against ending up with a prima donna who obsesses over brace style at the expense of getting useful things done. really, i think the best way to find out if someone can code is to look at something they've coded
- noduerme 15y agoIs it actually illegal to hire in the US based on IQ? I mean how is that discriminatory more than any other test for employment? Race, religion, political affiliation, disability are obviously all irrelevant in an IQ test... so in a way, isn't it more equitable? You make a good point about primadonnas and other potentially toxic personality types with high IQs, but you can screen that too. And I mean, I don't care about IQ. To me, pretty much anybody with talent should be able to come in with something awesome and say "look what I did", and if it's great, then who cares? Hire them. Obviously this isn't an argument for creating a new narrow-minded structure to replace the current one; I'm just talking about prioritizing along the essential lines instead of dancing around the real question. Isn't someone who codes and who can give you a fibonacci sequence in realtime more valuable than someone who codes, but can't? I can't do it, but I'd hire that guy.
- redthrowaway 15y agoRace, religion, political association, and the like are all socioeconomic factors which have been shown to have an effect on an individual's score on an IQ test. The classic example goes as follows: The testee is shown four pictures: a teapot; a saucer; a table, and a water pump. They are then shown a teacup, and asked to match it with the appropriate picture. The upper-class testee, for whom tea was always served in a cup on a saucer, selects the saucer. The middle-class testee selects the teapot, as the tea obviously goes in the cup. The child in sub-Saharan Africa recognizes the teacup as a cup, a so selects the water pump, as water goes in cups. This is obviously a contrived example, but it shows how the biases of the test-makers can conflict with those of the test-takers, leading those from different backgrounds to score worse on the test.
- MartinCron 15y agoA real example I heard of a few years ago was with children putting picture story panels in order. The "correct sequence" was: Get Up, Eat Breakfast, Go To School while many of these children were getting subsidized breakfasts at school.
- msutherl 15y agoMy IQ is lower than it should be because I have what you might call "ADD". The final IQ score is an average of scores from a few different tests. I score high on some tests and average (which is actually well below average for college graduates) on others. The resulting score, then, hides my strengths and weaknesses. Suffice it to say that I would have a hard time getting a job based on my IQ score because I can't do repetitive arithmetic operations as fast as other people.
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoYes, my family has ADD in spades. Actually a help in programming jobs - the focus part is great. The intuitive jumping around can be just the thing when chasing a bug. 6 ADD kids from a farming community. One Entrepreneur :), an environmental researcher, a Nursing research specialist, two software directors (Case pumps, Intel) and one IT head.
- moron 15y agoHave you taken an IQ test? I have. It didn't strike me as a way of finding out much about a person, except perhaps whether they are able to do difficult arithmetic quickly. Also, people with lots of raw intelligence often find ways to misapply that intelligence in awesomely terrible ways. Smart in the little way, dumb in the big way.
- mgkimsal 15y agoI took a couple a few years ago, and the results roughly matched the test results from 30 years earlier. They weren't exactly the same tests, so the raw score numbers weren't the same, but the percentile number hadn't budged a bit one way or the other. One of the tests had a lot of memorization - given a list of 9 numbers, repeat them backwards. Or 9 letters. Or a combination. Getting read "q9dh73b1wm6" and then having someone expect to hear you say back "6mw1b37hd9q" was quite nerve-wracking. Another test was "say as many names as you can in 30 seconds" (or something like that). Some of the tests appeared really odd, but the test-giver explained the thinking behind some of the questions later, and it was interesting.
- aswanson 15y agoYou don't even need an explicit test. Just ask for their SAT and divide by 10. If post-1995, divide by 10 then multiply by 2/3. I still wouldn't hire purely on IQ though. An intelligent adult with no coding skill isn't that way for no reason. You cannot make someone into something they haven't much interest in being.
- jaredsohn 15y agoYour math for comparing SAT scores is off (what is the point of dividing everyone's score by ten?) There have been two main changes in scoring: in 1995 they recentered the scores which in effect increased many peoples' score on the order of 50 points or so (one can convert old scores here: http://2-bit.com/misc/satcalc.html http://2-bit.com/misc/satcalc.html). In 2005, they added a writing section so now your score is out of 2400 instead of 1600. Also, I think you'd want to compare peoples scores based on the current scale which would mean adjusting scores prior to 1995 so that they are recentered and either multiplying by 3/2 for scores before 2005 or discarding the writing portion for everyone. But many people don't even take the SAT. At least when I was in high school (and likely still today), midwest universities tended to prefer the ACT. Thus, you're essentially looking for people who hit some percentile on national tests, similar to what one would do when applying for MENSA. Also, as you and others have stated, this isn't really the best way to evaluate people for programming jobs.
- aswanson 15y agoThe divide by 10 works as a gross estimated iq score (within 5 points) on the old sat.
- xsmasher 15y agoIQ is a terrible metric because "raw" intelligence is only one skill required to be a developer. It discounts creativity, people skills, personality, drive, domain knowledge, style, and learning speed. If I got a candidate with a 140 IQ who was unpleasant, derisive, and had only coded in Pascal, I'd send them packing. It speaks to their drive, personality, and people skills. A winning team is not built on intelligence alone.
- codeonfire 15y agoUnfortunately, unless you also have a similar iq, the candidate will naturally seem unpleasant to you. Anyone would agree that they would not like to be around someone with an 80 iq. however for the same reason, namely differing values, attitudes, and thought processes those same people will not enjoy working with a 140 iq coworker.