4 ms·
Yes, this is exactly on point. Moroun clearly tried to not only protect his investment but did so by disadvantaging the general public. "Manuel Moroun, owner o
by jacquesm 3y ago
Yes, this is exactly on point. Moroun clearly tried to not only protect his investment but did so by disadvantaging the general public.
"Manuel Moroun, owner of the Ambassador Bridge until his death in 2020, spoke out against this proposal. He sued the governments of Canada and Michigan to stop its construction, and released a proposal to build a second span of the Ambassador Bridge (which he would own) instead.[38] Critics suggest that Moroun's opposition was fueled by the prospect of lost profits from duty-free gasoline sales, which are exempt from about 60 cents per gallon in taxes even though the pump price to consumers is only a few cents lower.[11] On May 5, 2011, a judge dismissed the case, citing a lack of reasoning for it to proceed.[39] Moroun and his Detroit International Bridge Company contended that the new bridge would affect its proposal for a second span which would be built next to the Ambassador Bridge. "
The idea that a private individual, no matter how wealthy is able to literally exact a toll on society is ridiculous. In Europe we also still have a few toll bridges and tunnels, as well as many toll roads (for instance: in Poland and France). Most of these, but not all, are in the hands of various governments. I can't wait until this particular form of highway robbery disappears. Oh, and Germany re-enacted something similar but only for tourists. They first got slapped down in court then reduced the German road tax to be able to apply the tax on 'everybody' but in practice that means that it is just a levy on foreign traffic.
- bombcar 3y agoIt's really only because "we don't care enough" - when the rubber hits the road (literally) things like that get steamrolled and nationalized quite quickly. But we're "so rich" that a few billionaire parasites doesn't amount to much, and so we let the legal fiction continue.
- tomrod 3y agoMeanwhile, in an effort to control traffic congestion, certain US states are building privately owned toll roads, which siphon away maintenance taxes that could benefit local road repair.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoWe've had this in Ontario for over a couple decades in the form of the 407, which has eye watering tolls that I don't think any Americans can understand (certainly Google maps doesn't, as it suggests navigation routes on it just to save 2 or 3 minutes, but which cost $40, $50 CAD). It's owned by Spanish consortium, and was sold by a previous conservative gov't for a fraction of what it's made in profit, since.
- btbuildem 3y agoIt boggles the mind that the crooks that sold it walk free today.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoThe current premier's dad was in that gov't. Ontario don't care, it seems. Canadians just bend over and take it. Around here (Flamborough, outside of Hamilton/Burlington) there's a whole layer of people who rant and rant and rant about being amalgamated into Hamilton. Except those same people who rant about it, are almost all conservative voters. And it was the conservatives under Harris who forced that amalgamation. It boggles the mind, the short memory people have.
- jacquesm 3y agoWhat's pretty wild is that even though you can later uncover the corruption the deals are allowed to stand. When in fact all of the participants should end up in jail with their assets forfeited.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoIn general this is never spoken of as corruption here. Not in mainstream discourse anyways. It's spoken of as a "bad deal", but the "C" word isn't really deployed. In the early/mid-90s recessionary period when this was inked, the justification was excessively high debts incurred by the previous provincial gov't. Austerity was the name of the game, and decisions like these were seen as "wise fiscal management." Those debts now look minor compared to the present, and we'd have been in much better fiscal situation keeping the toll road public and letting that money flow back.
- rapnie 3y agoI don't know the extent of this practice, and maybe someone from Italy can provide more info, but last summer there was a news item on Dutch TV how residents in a south-Italian town on the coast could only afford to seek solace from the heat wave by swimming in the polluted harbour area, because all of the beaches were privately-owned and charging beyond their means. And it was suggested in the news item that that holds true for large chunks of the Italian coastline.
- giansegato 3y agothat's correct. most beaches in Italy are privately held, with decades-long contracts it's a huge scandal and yet very hard to solve because of the same dynamics of the bridge above: special interests, and hideous lobbying
- Teever 3y agoI think a vicious PR campaign against the people doing the lobbying and the people being lobbied is a good first step in situations like this. THe public should know the names and faces of the people involved and they should associate negative and petty emotions with them. Most Canadians hve no clue about this bridge or the people like Moroun and his lawyers who are involved. These should be names that people spit on the ground when heard, there should be political cartoons and memes that satirize their faces everywhere. There should be boycotts against his businesses and the businesses of his lawyers and accountants.
- jorvi 3y ago> In Europe we also still have a few toll bridges and tunnels, as well as many toll roads (for instance: in Poland and France). Most of these, but not all, are in the hands of various governments. I can't wait until this particular form of highway robbery disappears. Uhm, what? Toll roads are about as fair as it gets. The alternative is spreading the cost over all (national) drivers. I hate toll roads too when I encounter them, but making non-users pick up the tab for users is the actual highway robbery.
- vetinari 3y agoThere is also a middle ground: vignettes. Basically, only a car with a valid vignette can get on such a road, but unlike tolls, the fee is not per-trip, but valid for some time period (week, two, month, year). So in the result, only those who use (or intend to use) the toll road pay, but without the toll booths that slow everything down. The price also happens to be more reasonable.
- hgomersall 3y agoI don't think toll booths are necessary anymore. Certainly the Dartford crossing doesn't use them.
- taway_6PplYu5 3y agoHow do you define "users"? Say something you ordered or bought in a store was shipped along that road, did you "use" it? If one of the employees of that company had to use that road to get to work, did you "use" it? one of their family members, without whose job they wouldn't have theirs? Should the owner of a toll road have to pay money back to subsidize the costs of the roads which give access to their toll road? Vehicles need to be able to get on/off the road before tolls can be collected. Or, if we apply your logic, then it is impossible for people to live in rural areas, because the cost of the roads is more than the local economy can bear. Road networks are an infrastructure investment. Since they are networks, the value comes from the entire network. What is the value of a road with no on or off ramps? Because the value is so diffisive over both space and time, the only effective way to account for and recoup the cost is through a mechanism that can take a share of the economic growth resulting from the network. i.e. taxes.
- LeifCarrotson 3y ago> The idea that a private individual, no matter how wealthy is able to literally exact a toll on society is ridiculous. How else do you think that individuals are able to become billionaires? They're not ten thousand times smarter or stronger or harder-working than the rest of us. Bezos is worth $180B because he's paying his warehouse drones $13.60 an hour while they run from shelf to shelf and pee in bottles, contributing value to society far in excess of the pay they're receiving. The difference is pocketed by Jeff.
- fallingknife 3y agoEveryone else is also paying their warehouse drones $13.60 per hour and have. been doing that for decades before Amazon, and none of them are billionaires.
- nerdbert 3y agoBezos optimized the peeing-in-bottles aspect.
- taway_6PplYu5 3y ago> The idea that a private individual, no matter how wealthy is able to literally exact a toll on society is ridiculous. Key recent articles on how the US government is dependent on Elon Musk; how Ukraine depends on Starlink for communications, and how Elon is talking DIRECTLY AND IN PERSON to Putin, while watching Ukrainian troop movements live by monitoring Starlink usage. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2023/08/28/elon-musks-shadow-rule https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2023/08/28/elon-musks-sha... https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/elon-musk-putin-colin-kahl-pentagon-ukraine-starlink-b2397109.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/elon-musk-pu... Elon Musk is “wired for war.” At least, that’s what Musk has told Walter Isaacson, https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2023/09/elon-musk-walter-isaacson-biography/675277/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2023/09/elon-...
- boeingUH60 3y agoYou're frankly spreading nonsense...Starlink remained active in Ukraine at all times. Musk only refused to activate it in Crimea, where it was never activated before because of sanctions [1]. After that, the U.S. military signed a formal contract and now decides whether to activate it or not. Musk admitted to talking to Putin a few times. But you've somehow cooked up a conspiracy of him actively monitoring Ukrainian troop movements and feeding the info back to Putin...seriously? 1- https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-66752264 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-66752264
- inemesitaffia 3y agoHas he admitted to talking to Putin?
- inemesitaffia 3y agoDirectly and in person?
- gnfargbl 3y agoI really struggle to understand the mindset of people like Manuel. He was already obscenely rich, to the level where gaining additional resources must have been useless to him. He had surely already discharged any responsibility he might have to provide for his future descendants. What did he gain by attempting to protect his investment in this way? He made the world a bit worse, and in doing so gained... absolutely nothing of any practical utility. Why bother?
- boeingUH60 3y ago> He was already obscenely rich, to the level where gaining additional resources must have been useless to him. You could have said the same thing when he was worth $50 million instead of a billionaire. For people like that, the mindset is endless growth at all costs...that's why they still turn up to work despite having money to live like kings for multiple lifetimes.
- pcthrowaway 3y ago$50 million is enough for you and maybe a few descendants to live comfortably for the rest of your lives, but certainly not an amount of money where you'll be able to do anything you want for perpetuity. You probably won't even be able to buy a superyacht comfortably, and a megayacht is absolutely out of your reach. For that you need to be a billionaire
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoI’m not being hyperbolic here, in my experience with the super rich there area few common things: 1. They don’t have to do anything they don’t want to so generally have a relative lack of empathy 2. just a few notches above average intelligence but are rarely “genius” 3. They live in mental/emotional bubbles and almost never spend time with “regular” people doing things like shopping, cooking, sitting in traffic or using the infrastructure that unwashed use That means they can think far enough in the future about “macro“ trends (which don’t really exist), while also fucking over everybody in the process because they don’t have to even experience any of the “externalities” that their actions take. They see themselves as kings and better educated, more traveled, more cosmopolitan etc… so it’s purely ego
- mistermo 3y agoIn France those are built by the government, then loaned to their friends...