5 ms·
Is software ever going to become more responsive? I'm tired of Slack constantly fucking up its UI because I'm faster than it is, and that's on an M2.
by stavros 3y ago
Is software ever going to become more responsive? I'm tired of Slack constantly fucking up its UI because I'm faster than it is, and that's on an M2.
- KingLancelot 3y ago[dead]
- DeathArrow 3y agoAre people going to be less lazy and use a compiled language like C, C++, Rust instead of Javascript for desktop and mobile apps? Are companies going to pay for that development?
- trevyn 3y agoNobody really cares. I’m not usually the type to complain about input lag; most modern apps on a recent machine are snappy enough for me. But I’ve been messing around with egui lately, and it just feels… fast. It’s weird. But nobody really cares.
- icemelt8 3y agounlikely
- poisonborz 3y agoWho will develop a cross-platform UI system as capable, flexible and well-embedded as HTML/CSS and as responsive as native UI? Google did its shot with Flutter, it's not exactly eating the world. The performance issue will long be solved before somebody comes up with a capable contender.
- bandergirl 3y ago> The performance issue will long be solved before somebody comes up with a capable contender. I wish I had such a positive outlook. New highways are built and they are quickly filled with traffic.
- ogoffart 3y agoTrying to do that with Slint: https://slint.dev https://slint.dev No need to use compiled language like C++, still possible to use a language like JavaScript/TypeScript, just no need to bring a browser.
- mamcx 3y agoFlutter suffer, badly, to be tied to a specific lang. If it where an API directly usable by any lang, then it could fly further.
- folago 3y agoThere is https://gioui.org/ https://gioui.org/ for Go.
- pc86 3y agoThis doesn't seem to cover a single point in the comment you're replying to.
- CharlesW 3y ago> Who will develop a cross-platform UI system as capable, flexible and well-embedded as HTML/CSS and as responsive as native UI? History shows that you can only choose one. If you're not using the platform's native UI stack, you're going to end up with a slower, less capable solution that will look and feel foreign and clumsy in comparison. What the industry really needs is a React Native-type solution that isn't tied specifically to React.
- gcanko 3y agoIsn't this what WebAssembly or Rust is used for? IIRC Figma's web app uses WebAssembly and I prefer that way more than the native app.
- novagameco 3y agoMaybe when native languages manage to come up with a single good UI framework
- olliej 3y agoMacs have Cocoa which is a good UI framework. There's your single good UI framework for them. iOS has UIKit, which is a good UI framework. There's your single good UI framework for them. Linux has GTK and Qt, though I'm not sure which one is in vogue these days, but both of which seemed fine when I used them in the past. etc But it sounds like what you're actually saying is "I only want one OS to exist". Every OS has its own UI API, because every perform has different UI design language, UI interaction, and UI behavior. You cannot make one UI that is good on every platform because every platform is different and those differences are what make people prefer one over the others, but a single UI is (as Java and Chrome wrappers demonstrate) going to produce a bunch of exceedingly mediocre apps that fail numerous basic UI tools on their respective platforms. If you want a cross platform apps you have cross platform core logic, and per platform UI. If you want a single UI framework across platforms, it cannot be good, and it will inherently at best produce the kind of mediocrity we get with chrome apps, or you only have a single platform and have the same UI toolkit across all of them: desktop, phone, tablet, etc. I'm going to guess that's going to produce a fairly terrible UX on at least one of the options if it's good on others, or maybe it will just be mediocre across the board.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- novagameco 3y agoThen nobody will go back to making native apps
- olliej 3y agoYes, the problem is easy crappy apps are cheaper for developers even if they're worse for users. The alternative "single UI framework" is "everyone must run the same OS". As long as people keep buying/using crapware apps that's all that will happen. The fact that so many people are ok with that mediocrity is depressing, but that they do so while then complaining about things being slow is actively annoying.
- jorvi 3y agoGnome is 120FPS butter on Javascript. As far as I know, Gnome profiled a bunch of their biggest UI slowdowns and none of them would have been (much) improved on native. Bad code is bad, JavaScript isn’t the main culprit here.
- moralestapia 3y agoThis. I've wrote plenty of (very) high performance code using a Javascript/WebGL combo. Most people bitching about JS are not even good coders to start with.
- beebeepka 3y agoTruth to be told, there's a lot of terrible js out there, and some of it is mine.
- taftster 3y agoAt least you're honest about it. I don't have any JS out there period, so your terrible JS is much better than I could have done.
- beebeepka 3y agosometimes I do think about my first contributions. how i could have done this and that completely differently. kind of like going to first grade again with what you know (and are) as an adult.
- redeeman 3y agoyeah but look at freaking chromium, 3.2GB compressed archive. That is absolutely insane, and cannot be defended in ANY WAY. look at what they started with with webkit? chromium is an abomination the likes of which definitively proves there is no god, or that god HATES humanity, as god would have 100% for sure schmited us all down for the atrocity that is chromium.
- 3y ago
- jwells89 3y agoOne doesn’t even need to go as far as C++ or Rust… many best in class Mac apps were written in Objective-C (which is notably slower than either) and were plenty responsive on single core PowerPC G3s, G4s, and G5s. I think a great deal of the issue comes down to bloated frameworks, bad application code, and a prevalent attitude of nonchalance towards optimization that compounds with dev machines being powerful enough to mask most performance problems.
- jbclements 3y agoI think it's probably more productive to think of this in economic terms; "nonchalance toward optimization" <-> "I can write this code in an hour instead of three hours". And, from a company's perspective: "I can get this code running acceptably at 1/3 the dev cost".
- jwells89 3y agoSurely we’ve crossed a threshold of diminishing returns on this by now though? There has to be a point where the gains in convenience/DX/speed are too tiny for the costs involved and the weight of the average app ceases to grow.
- eru 3y agoIRC clients have been around for ages, and are typically more responsive.
- stavros 3y agoYes, but this seems fairly off topic when my complaint is about Slack and general software bloat. I know there exists responsive software, but much of it isn't.
- emmet 3y agoNah, my company full of people who can't even open an excel file are definitely going to be magically able to use an IRC client as their main form of communication.
- zozbot234 3y agoUse Matrix? It's a lot closer to Slack UX and you can self host it.
- rcxdude 3y agoI don't think it has a particularly snappy client, though it wouldn't be hard to beat Slack.
- redeeman 3y agoif you are suggesting you have employees who are unable to be using an irc client, perhaps you should suggest to management that a round of layoffs are in order? how hard can it be? spend 5 minutes and anyone thats worth keeping can figure it out.
- bee_rider 3y agoThere will always exist (always have) bloated and non-bloated programs. I don’t think anyone here knows anything about Slack’s particular future, but I bet it will not be getting any better.
- rubymamis 3y agoThis is what I'm trying to achieve. I'm going to build a cross-platform ecosystem of high quality apps (in terms of UX and performance) based on Qt C++ and QML. Starting with an alternative to the resource-hag Electron app: Notion, I'm building Plume[1]. Got some plans for what will come next. [1] https://www.get-plume.com/ https://www.get-plume.com/
- sys_64738 3y agoMaybe if AI can code a native interface quickly on whatever platform you are on today. The problem with human programming is it takes time so these cross-platform abominations are the current solution. We need a hands-off, useable conversion amongst native platform toolkits.
- stavros 3y agoWhy though? If JS execution is wasteful, maybe there's another way to find the waste and eliminate it.
- PeterisP 3y agoWhy would it? People are voting with their wallets that this is okay, that they'd rather have Slack and all that it has instead of some competing solution that's more responsive but lags in other areas, so there is no market pressure to improve this.
- olliej 3y agoStop accepting these BS "apps" that are just web pages being loaded in a full copy of chrome. It's mind blowing to me that so many people accept these "cross platform" apps that are just as bad today as java "cross platform" apps were a few decades ago (if not actually worse). Just a plethora of enshittified apps developed to be cheap rather than good.