8 ms·
Obama: "It is unacceptable that the U.S. ranks 15th in the world in broadband adoption"
- Xichekolas 18y ago"They estimated that each billion dollars spent would create up to 40,000 jobs." Not sure who is doing the math here, but if you divide a billion by 40k, you get $25k per person... and nothing left over to spend on materials. So the workers will either get significantly less than $25k a year for these jobs, or the concrete and bulldozers will be free. Far more likely, I'd guess, is that the 40k jobs figure was pulled out of somebody's backside.
- jcl 18y agoNot that I necessarily agree with their logic, but presumably they are estimating that the net economic benefit of the things created with the billion dollars exceeds a billion dollars.
- Xichekolas 18y agoAh good point. For some reason I was reading as "a billion dollars will fund 40k people".
- Goronmon 18y agoI think it would be good for the government to take the initiative in improving connectivity across the country. At the moment, media companies seem more concerned with limiting the download capacities of users rather than improving the infrastructure.
- qqq 18y agoSometimes getting Government involved in areas makes thing worse.
- pchristensen 18y agoAnd sometimes it makes it better.
- qqq 18y agoGovernment in general is really inefficient. Way less efficient than, say, Comcast, Microsoft, or Fedex. So unless there is some good reason it must be Government solving a problem, why not have someone (anyone) else do it? Having Government do our broadband is very dangerous. Besides "fiber optic cables to nowhere", and outages and delays in major cities, there is the possibility of "packet shaping", blocking access to certain websites (e.g. The Pirate Bay), listening to our conversations (in case we're terrorists), requiring the installation of DRM software to go with internet access, and not allowing the use of cryptographic protocols granting anonymity or privacy. Why should we trust the Government to do those things less than companies that at least need paying customers and have less power?
- Retric 18y agoWay less efficient than [citation needed] The US government on average is not as bad as you might assume. Granted they tend to get burned when outsourcing work but bringing in third party's often increases costs or decreases quality. EX: Public school lunch programs managed by 3rd parties.
- qqq 18y ago_The Machinery of Freedom_ has some citations.
- noonespecial 18y agoAs inefficient as is might be, there are still some things that only government can build. There are plenty of places even today that the US mail goes to that FedEx does not. (I lived in one of them). Sometimes you've just got to suck it up and swing that sledge hammer at that gnat, because there's just no private incentive to make a fly swatter.
- gibsonf1 18y agoHopefully lessons about the first Great Depression, such as how the policies of the New Deal actually lengthened the depression, will be learned this time. http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/GreatDepression.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/GreatDepression.html
- netcan 18y agoI've heard this so many times recently. The exact same argument used for exactly conflicting points of view. And every time it's brought up it is presented as an uncontroversial example of how X (or Y the exact opposite of X) works: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_deal#Conflicting_interpretation_of_the_New_Deal_economic_policies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_deal#Conflicting_interpreta... The New Deal is a Hung Jury.
- sheats 18y ago"Mr. Bush and other Republicans have resisted such an approach in part out of concern for the already soaring federal budget deficit, which could easily hit $1 trillion this year. Borrowing hundreds of billions of dollars today to try to fix the economy, they argue, will leave a huge bill for the next generation." Anyone besides me find that paragraph a little ironic?
- robg 18y agoHere's what change is about: Knowing that infrastructure includes not just roads and bridges, and mass transit, but laying fiber too.
- jmtame 18y agoAmen!
- mdasen 18y agoWhile I'm all for improving the state of broadband and internet access in general, I think 15th out of 190-odd countries is decent. It's certainly in the top 10%. In fact, according to international studies, it's better than we do in education. I think the internet is wonderful, but the US will lag in broadband over densely populated, urban nations. The US has a huge rural population and I really do hope that wireless broadband improves our ability to serve them, but sometimes there are limitations. Plus, I don't actually think the statistics show the US as having a bad adoption rate. (http://www.internetworldstats.com/dsl.htm http://www.internetworldstats.com/dsl.htm) That's what I found quickly searching. The US comes out on top of Germany and Japan (both countries that are very urban and densely populated). I think one of the keys is also that we are decently close to the leadership. It's not like the leaders (1-12) have 70% adoption and then there's a steep drop off to us at 20% adoption. I'd bet that this is more of a state by state issue. Densely populated states like NJ, RI, and MA probably have broadband adoption rates that would be much better than the country as a whole - and seeing as though many of the countries doing better than the US are the geographic size of (or have a populated center the geographic size of) one of our smaller states, that might make for a better comparison. Out of the 18 countries beating the US, only Canada, the UK and France are of any size. Comparing the US to a country like Denmark isn't really fair. We're talking about comparing 31 people per km^2 to 127 people per km^2. And the countries that have lower population densities often have the majority of their population in a few urban centers. Lastly, there's a methodology problem. We're comparing broadband connections to the number of people. That doesn't tell us what percentage of people have broadband. I live with several other people and we have one broadband connection for the house. We all have access, but it will look like we have a 25% adoption rate. As European families usually have fewer children, that might create a bias in tabulating. With a US family averaging over 25% more children than a Swedish family, there might be an uncorrected bias that skews results against the US. Of course, if the US has more split families, that could skew in the US' favor. I just think this is one of those cases where a politician is grandstanding without facts being behind them. OMG IT'S UNACCEPTABLE!!! No, it's pretty acceptable. Yeah, we should improve, but you can't expect the US as a whole to be able to match a country with a much denser population and a much smaller geographic area to cover. We're doing really well that we're so close. Stop making everything unacceptable! It just means that people don't listen to you because you've shown an ineptitude at interpreting data.
- ivankirigin 18y agoThe US is not a small country. The economics of broadband penetration are different. It is not the job of the federal government to pick a winner in methods of distributing TCP/IP packets.
- pivo 18y agoThe government ensures that everyone gets postal and land-line telephone service if they want it. Considering how TCP/IP packets are used, are they really much different from those other services? In this case it's not about picking a winner, it's about making sure people have access to resources. Once there's choice the monopoly can be disposed of, like we did with Ma Bell and the postal service.
- gojomo 18y agoThe US has not disposed of the postal service monopoly. It remains illegal to compete with the USPS in the delivery of "first-class" mail. Other services also may not use the same mailboxes, even if the customer wants them to. And the USPS has neither been privatized nor broken into competing units.
- pivo 18y agoTrue, we obviously didn't get rid of the post office or its legal monopoly but we did get rid of its practical monopoly with companies like FedEx, UPS, etc. and of course with email.
- ivankirigin 18y agoFiber could cost billions, and in the end, wireless might be a much better option. This is clearly a make-work project, and that is simply a waste of my money.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- astine 18y ago
- axod 18y agoI think the bigger issue is the lack of choice/competition.
- vaksel 18y agothere is competition, the problem is that since the whole broadband thing is just starting out, they companies are focusing their efforts on the big cities. I mean think about it..why would the companies put all that effort and resources into laying fiber to and around a town of 10,000 people, if for only a little bit more they can lay down the fiber in a city of 10 million
- jmtame 18y agoI think you're mistaking the word "competition" for "oligopoly." Let me introduce you to 99% of the broadband market, their names are Verizon, Comcast, and AT&T. By the way, they don't let municipalities build their own infrastructures. It's "anti-competitive." Any company that is profitable enough is acquired, otherwise they will charge you an arm and leg just to use their cables. The focus on "wealthy" neighborhoods is called redlining. These three guys I just introduced you to don't care about poor people. They only want to charge as high a price as possible for the people who can afford it. They're not too worried about actually building a good network (ie fiber optics, instead of their 100-year old coaxial cables designed for telephones). Just thought I'd chime in and clarify that.
- Xichekolas 18y agoTwo companies trading customers back and forth isn't exactly vigorous competition. The nature of the last-mile problem means that the only way you are going to get more than one cable company and more than one phone company to compete is to treat them like electrical utilities and either regulate their rates or force them to share their lines with competitors. Wireless broadband solutions don't have this last mile problem, so don't need to be regulated in the same way. Their Achilles Heel will always be latency, which is why I don't think they are a long-term replacement for wired connections.
- astine 18y ago
- cpr 18y ago"It is unacceptable that the United States ranks 15th in the world in broadband adoption," Mr. Obama said. "Here, in the country that invented the Internet, every child should have the chance to get online." Why did I read that as "... every child should have the chance to download porn at a high rate"? Sigh, does anyone really believe that internet access is going to make a serious difference in the lives of those children who are struggling educationally or whose families are on the economic margins? All it will do is drag them down further in a wasteland of social networking sites (Facebook, Myspace) and (usually) much worse.
- noonespecial 18y agoSigh, does anyone really believe that internet access is going to make a serious difference in the lives of those children... Me. I do. Maybe not all of them. Maybe not even most. But some, certainly. I never was much for the argument that we shouldn't give poor people X because they won't know how to use it. Perhaps we shouldn't help them with the electric bill either because they're just gonna sit around and watch "Spongebob". Sure, some will waste the opportunity, but as government help programs go, this one is cheap. Lets let them decide what to do with that opportunity.
- palish 18y agoJust because 99% of children are "in a wasteland of social networking sites" doesn't mean everyone is, or will be. The internet is a vast, valuable resource. It is the only reason I am as competent a programmer as I am today. I'm entirely self-taught, thanks to the internet. As I was growing up, I usually skipped school activities (and sometimes school) in favor of learning programming on the internet. So please don't deny people like me the opportunity just because most people around us misuse it.
- cpr 18y agoSo we should embark on a huge government-funded program to widen broadband availability so 1% of children can benefit from it.
- 18y ago
- gojomo 18y agoI know, let's create some government-sponsored enterprises, like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, but for promoting broadband rather than home ownership! After our big access push, the broadband intertubes will be a publicly-owned resource, like the broadcast airwaves. And we better not subsidize indecency or insensitive content with broad public resources! So content and corporate ownership structures can require FCC review, like over-the-air TV, rather than that messy anarchy that rules over books. (People can print anything in books and we can't fine them!) Don't worry, though -- the FCC is always balanced, with 3 commissioners from the president's party, and 2 from the opposition party. All viewpoints are represented! Remember, net neutrality for packets is only truly acheived when we have neutrality, equality, and justice for all people. Packets which contain hate speech, pornography, content inaccessible to the handicapped, political campaigning beyond the spending limits of the FEC, or an insufficient proportion of underrepresented viewpoints are not neutral. We won't allow them on our public nets! Australia, China, the UK, and Saudi Arabia are all innovating in making their national networks serve national priorities -- the U.S. must not fall farther behind!
- whatusername 18y agoAussie Aussie Aussie - Oi Oi Oi! We're leading the world in something for once.... oh. wait.
- TweedHeads 18y agoI blame it on corporate greed, and stupidity.
- Mistone 18y ago"Borrowing hundreds of billions of dollars today to try to fix the economy, they argue, will leave a huge bill for the next generation." Iraq, Bailout..borrowing billions is the Bush strategy except the give it to private banks and large corps in the form of tax payers with absolutely no return back to Americans.
- petercooper 18y agoSomeone above already said 15 out of 195-ish countries is pretty good, but more specifically, it's actually kinda on par for the US. While its easy to assume the US is #1 on many metrics due simply to having the largest economy, it's not in the top 10 in areas such as quality of life, quality of education, press freedom, crime, and so on. The US's biggest asset is its diversity and I doubt the US will ever be #1 in most of these areas while it retains the power of its diversity.