4 ms·
>security I will be forever appalled that Blizzard rolled out two factor authentication before stock trading services like E*Trade managed it. Bravo for Blizz
by hinkley 3y ago
>security
I will be forever appalled that Blizzard rolled out two factor authentication before stock trading services like E*Trade managed it.
Bravo for Blizzard, shame on the rest of ‘em. A game company.
- bee_rider 3y agoIt doesn’t seem that surprising to me. In the olden days, video game companies served a slightly more technical user base, so it makes sense that they’d be more willing to deal with 2FA. Also, I don’t think the legal system will help you recover your SoJs.
- profmonocle 3y agoI worked with someone who was a Blizzard GM around when they rolled this out. Recovering stolen accounts was some absurdly large % of their customer service tickets. People would use the same email & password on WoW as on various shady / insecure sites. Bots would try any stolen credentials en masse in WoW. When they succeeded, not only would customer service need to restore a user's access, they would need to roll back their character to restore lost items and gold. According to my coworker, adding 2FA was primarily about reducing this customer service workload. Eventually they encouraged it by adding in-game benefits, like additional bag space for your character. Not sure they ever went as far as mandating it.
- Paul-Craft 3y agoSo, what happened after they implemented it? Did CS tickets actually go down a lot? Did it save them a ton of money and hassle? You left off the best part of the story :-) As for mandating it, I could see not requiring people who'd already set up accounts to jump through this extra hoop to play the game. I'm sure even a small percentage might not be able to jump through that hoop. I doubt it's a significant percentage, but I could see it becoming a PR hassle, and those are the worst kinds of hassle from the POV of a technical employee lol... But for a new game? If the CS metrics reflected a big drop relative to the number of people using 2FA, then I'd be sold on requiring it.
- hinkley 3y agoFrom what I understand it went down for a long time, but what people did was if they managed to get into your account the first thing they would do is remove the authenticator. That involved entering a couple sequential values. But if you set up the keylogger right, you could trick users into failing the credential check 3 times at login and get their account.
- jonathanlydall 3y agoAs a former GM, as at the time I left in 2012 I had never encountered a case of a 2FA secured account getting hacked and account compromises were easily >50% of our workload. The problem had become that most players wouldn't add 2FA to their accounts until AFTER they got hacked, so any in-game incentive to add it was in our eyes a good one.
- anonymoushn 3y agoCurrently you cannot customize your group in group finder without 2FA, so you cannot list a group for your friend's keystone or specify what sorts of characters you would like to join. It's quite annoying!
- jonathanlydall 3y agoAs a former Blizzard CS rep (I left in 2012), I can see why they'd do things like this to convince people to add 2FA to their accounts as most people wouldn't do so until AFTER they were hacked for the first time. Based on many players saying to me "I don't know why they chose me", it seems that a lot of people don't realize that account compromising is a drag-net operation, it's like a fish thinking that there's no reason for them to be targeted specifically by a fisher, without realizing that fishing is such a large scale and impersonal activity.
- jonathanlydall 3y agoAs a former GM myself, can confirm all the above.
- toast0 3y agoDid they? I found an article from March 2005 stating that ETrade will soon launch 2fa [1]. And a similar article about Blizzard launching 2fa from July 2008 [2]. Maaaybe ETrade took 3 years from anouncement to launch, but I'm pretty sure I saw ETrade branded RSA tokens around 2005, and Blizzard tokens later. [1] https://www.computerworld.com/article/2569503/etrade-touts-two-factor-authentication-service.html https://www.computerworld.com/article/2569503/etrade-touts-t... [2] https://www.zdnet.com/article/blizzard-introducing-two-factor-authentication-for-wow-gamers/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/blizzard-introducing-two-facto...
- hinkley 3y agoMaybe introduced is the wrong word. Pushed might be closer. At some point Blizzard was trying to make it sound like 2FA was mandatory, and ETrade definitely had made a bit more noise about them at that point, but Blizzard campaigned to get everyone on smart phone 2FA and E*trade did not. Someone else said it might be demographics and I’m not inclined to argue with them. But I think too, a lot of early movers had those key fobs, and because they weren’t on atomic clock time they tended to drift and cause support nightmares. I had 2FA at work a little before I had it in WoW and one of us was having a problem practically every other week. That was only dozens of people. The smart phone answer was so, so much better. But it you invested in fobs, it’s like public infrastructure. Boston has a shitty sewer system because it got firefighters before Chicago and Seattle, which burned down after modern plumbing more or less settled. See also Internet service in late adopter towns versus early. Ripping out cost more than green field.
- saghm 3y agoNot only that, but they had dedicated hardware for it since smartphones weren't ubiquitous yet. I still remember the first time I saw a friend use one, and how mystified I was by this mysterious "authenticator". It's still absolutely wild to me to think about how ahead of the game Blizzard was on the 2FA front. They only recently replaced their dedicated smartphone app for 2FA by rolling it into the existing Battle.net app. The 2FA codes they use are longer than 6 digits, which I assume is why they don't support something that can be used by more "mainstream" 2FA apps; by the time those become established enough to support third parties, I suspect their infrastructure had been around long enough that it just wouldn't be worth rewriting it. I do sometimes wonder if someday apps like Google Authenticator will support a wider variety of TOTP configurations; I think Steam also uses something non-standard, which means the only mobile option is a dedicated app, and I'd much rather not have to install extra apps just for 2FA support.
- hinkley 3y agoThey handed them out at Blizzcon one year, but only one per person, which I think was a mistake. Should have sent people home to entice their friends.