4 ms·
If you stick the amplifier in the speaker, then you have much lower voltages and currents in the cable to the speaker, so you are, perversely, much more sensiti
by amluto 3y ago
If you stick the amplifier in the speaker, then you have much lower voltages and currents in the cable to the speaker, so you are, perversely, much more sensitive to noise that couples into your wiring.
As a silly and dramatic experiment, touch a wire connected to a passive speaker (without power applied — don’t zap yourself!). You won’t hear anything. Now touch the center pin of an RCA wire leading to a powered-on speaker with appreciable low frequency response, e.g. a subwoofer. Bzzzzzzzzz!
- jeffbee 3y agoNo I have a digital connection to the speaker, because I am modern and rational.
- mschulkind 3y agoThis is why balanced cables exist.
- WalterBright 3y agoI really don't know why stereo components do not communicate digitally via ethernet cables. The only thing that won't work for is the output of the power amp. My stereo is the usual rat's nest of various cables and connectors. I also have a tub full of various plugs, adapters, etc. Wouldn't it be nice to have a receiver that just had an ethernet connector on the back? Run it to an ethernet switch, and plug your turntable, TV, cassette player, into the switch? One cool consequence is your components could be anywhere in the house, as any component could play over any powered speaker in the house.
- daydream 3y ago> I really don't know why stereo components do not communicate digitally via ethernet cables. If you’re building a new pro audio setup today, be it studio or even live sound, that’s likely how you’re doing it. Even 20 years ago we had digital audio routers that worked pretty decently (not great, but well enough). This was a recording studio of course, not a home audio setting. The reason we don’t have this in consumer audio is almost certainly cost. Now you need to add a ADC, Ethernet, and a small chip to run it all. Meanwhile nobody wants to run cables anymore and WiFi is everywhere. But of course putting WiFi in everything drives cost too.
- kenhwang 3y agoI've used a couple of single/dual/tri-band wireless transmitters to hook up speakers, and I'd say I'm not really a fan. You have to be ok with dropped packets from interference (which happens pretty frequently if you're also sharing your 2.4/5/6ghz spectrum with WiFi), which is audible as silence or wrong sounds. Or you're using a protocol that does retransmission/buffering, which introduces noticeable latency with the video or even between speakers.
- amluto 3y agoWiFi is not so good as a replacement for wires — the latency is too high. The main contenders seem to be Dirac and AVB, both of which run over Ethernet. Dirac uses entirely ordinary Ethernet, and AVB wants some fancy extensions, which will bump up the price of your switches quite a bit. For good audio, you want known, controlled latency, preferably with quite precise timing. For live audio, or for a fully convenient replacement for analog cable, you want that known latency to be very short. And you either need no drops or you need an entire drop + retransmit cycle to fit within your latency. (Hmm, FEC could be used, I suppose — encode packets such that an entire lost packet could be recovered from the preceding packets plus the next couple packets.)
- rjmunro 3y agoIn the professional world, Dante seems to be taking over as the Audio over Ethernet solution.
- WalterBright 3y agoI stream TV and music over the intertoobs all the time. It works fine. The bandwidth on a home network is much higher, so it should be fine.
- fragmede 3y agoThe $10 Lightning to 3.5mm dongle for my iPhone has a microcontroller with RAM and an ADC, and the $20 lightning to Ethernet adapter has an Ethernet phy in it, so it's just a matter of someone getting funding, building it, and selling such a product. Latency would be a concern, but get a good firmware engineer on it. It should be noted that the wifi version of this is sold by Sonos though I don't think they do surround sound for movie watching, but are focused on multi-room audio.
- CuriousSkeptic 3y agoThere are wireless standards for this, no need for ethernet https://www.wisatechnologies.com/speakers https://www.wisatechnologies.com/speakers
- WalterBright 3y agoI tried wireless speakers. They had poor fidelity and the music was often interrupted by static and dropouts. The same thing happens with my Roku remote when I plug headphones into it. No thanks.
- manuelabeledo 3y agoSonos works over WiFi just fine.
- __turbobrew__ 3y agoDoesn’t twisted pair solve this problem? You can encode signals in the difference in voltage between the two wires which means that any noise which occurs in both wires cancels out? We have gotten pretty good at sending low voltage signals over wires with little to no noise so it seems like we can apply similar principles to audio gear?
- amluto 3y agoBalanced signals are widely used in professional gear, and twisted pairs indeed reduce loop area, but it’s not perfect. I once helped out in a sound booth where the cables picked up AM radio, and some nonlinearity in the system made it audible.
- jeffbee 3y agoThe mechanical design of pro audio balanced cables is poor and it's common to end up with a bad one in the field. A balanced amplifier with one input connected to a long unterminated wire is way worse than a single-ended cable would be under the same conditions. Even in consumer home use XLR cable ends will fail. We're stuck with it unfortunately unless you want full custom gear.
- E39M5S62 3y agoGenelecs and other pro-audio gear can get their signal via AES/EBU. Digital all the way through the chain up to the speaker is fantastic!
- samplatt 3y ago> I once helped out in a sound booth where the cables picked up AM radio This right here is part of the reason the "coathanger versus cable test" annoys me so much. All these wonderful graphs "proving" that cables don't matter never take environmental noise into account, which is frustrating because in reality that's exactly what you're testing. The fact that you could pick up AM radio inside a sound studio means that, for experimental purposes, that environment is simply not good enough. Are expensive cables mostly bullshit? sure. Do better cables still make a difference? My personal experience tells me absolutely yes, just usually not enough to matter to 95%+ of people.
- rossjudson 3y agoIt's digital to the active speakers, and everything necessary happens there. I have a pair of genelec 8361a actives. They can become anything you want.
- btbuilder 3y agoMeridian Audio have been making active digital speakers for over 25 years. SPDIF input to every speaker with custom DSP to do digital crossover tuned to the cabinet and particular cones.