5 ms·
A console wants a competitive GPU and a competitive CPU. Nvidia has the first, Intel has the second, AMD has both. The first one is more important, hence the Sw
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
A console wants a competitive GPU and a competitive CPU. Nvidia has the first, Intel has the second, AMD has both. The first one is more important, hence the Switch, and AMD's ability to do it in the pre-Ryzen era. (The original Intel-CPU Xbox had an Nvidia GPU.) Console vendors are high volume institutional buyers with aggressive price targets, so being able to get both from the same place is a big advantage.
For PCs, discrete GPUs are getting bought separately so that doesn't apply. AMD does alright there but they were historically the underdog and highly budget-constrained, so without some kind of separate advantage they were struggling.
Now they're making a lot of money from Ryzen/Epyc and GPUs, and reinvesting most of it, so it's plausible they'll be more competitive going forward as the fruits of those investments come to bear.
- p_l 3y agoThe original Xbox was supposed to use AMD CPU as well, and parts of that remained in the architecture (for example it uses Hyper Transport bus), backroom deals with intel led to last minute replacement of CPU for an intel P6 variant.
- WhiteDawn 3y agoSo last minute that the AMD engineers found out Microsoft went with Intel at the Xbox launch party [1] [1] https://kotaku.com/report-xboxs-last-second-intel-switcheroo-left-amd-eng-1847851074 https://kotaku.com/report-xboxs-last-second-intel-switcheroo...
- bri3d 3y agoThis also led to a major vulnerability caused by different double-fault behavior between AMD and Intel known as “the visor bug”: https://xboxdevwiki.net/17_Mistakes_Microsoft_Made_in_the_Xbox_Security_System#The_Visor_Backdoor https://xboxdevwiki.net/17_Mistakes_Microsoft_Made_in_the_Xb...
- shmerl 3y agoAlso, AMD is the obvious choice for Valve over something like Nvidia due to AMD having a decent upstream Linux support for both CPU and GPU features. It's something Nvidia never cared about.
- lmm 3y agoNVidia has had more reliable and, at least until recently, more featureful drivers on Linux and FreeBSD for decades. They're just not open-source, which doesn't seem like it would matter for something like the Steam Deck.
- shmerl 3y agoReliablie is very moot when they simply support only what they care about and don't support the rest for those decades. Not being upstreamed and not using standard kernel interfaces makes it only worse. So it's not something Valve wanted to deal with. They commented on benefits of working with upstream GPU drivers, so it clearly matters.
- lmm 3y agoNVidia are the upstream for their drivers, and for a big client like Valve they would likely be willing to support the interfaces they need (and/or work with them to get them using the interfaces NVidia like). Being less coupled to the Linux kernel could go either way - yes they don't tend to support the most cutting-edge Linux features, but by the same token it's easier to get newer NVidia drivers running on old versions of Linux than it is with AMD. (Does Valve keep the Steam Deck on a rolling/current Linux kernel? I'm honestly surprised if they do, because that seems like a lot of work and compatibility risk for minimal benefit)
- jwells89 3y agoThe current SteamOS (what Decks run) is based on Arch but is not rolling. The original for Steam Boxes was based on Debian. Reasoning for the switch: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SteamOS#Development https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SteamOS#Development > The decision to move from Debian to Arch Linux was based on the different update schedule for these distributions. Debian, geared for server configurations, has its core software update in one large release, with intermediate patches for known bugs and security fixes, while Arch uses a rolling update approach for all parts. Valve found that using Arch's rolling updates as a base would be better suited for the Steam Deck, allowing them to address issues and fixes much faster than Debian would allow. SteamOS itself is not rolling release.
- cassianoleal 3y agoFor gaming, AMD GPUs are generally better bang for buck than Nvidia - notably, they tend to be about the same bang for less buck, at least on the high end and some of the middle tier. The notable exception is ray tracing but that's still pretty niche. If AMD gets their act together and get the AI tooling for their GPUs to be as accessible as Nvidia's they have a good chance to become the winners there as you can get more VRAM bang for, again, less buck. In a market where they have similar performance and everything minus ray tracing for somewhere between 50% and 70% of the competitor's prices it will be pretty easy to choose AMD GPUs. They already have the best CPUs for gaming and really are positioning themselves to have the best GPUs overall as well.
- causality0 3y agoSpecifically modern "normal" gaming. Once you get outside that comfort zone AMD has problems again. My 7900XTX has noticeably worse performance than the 1070 I replaced when it comes to Yuzu and Xenia.
- wincy 3y agoIf you’re building a midlife crisis gaming PC the 4090 is the only good choice right now. 4K gaming with all the bells and whistles turned on is a reality with that GPU.
- IggleSniggle 3y agoYup, just did this. Still way cheaper than a convertible or whatever
- kristianp 3y agoEspecially when most convertibles are slower than a Tesla.
- trevyn 3y agoPSA: GeForce Now Ultimate is a great way to check this out. You get a 4080 equivalent that can stream 4K 120Hz. If you have good Internet in the continental US or most of Europe, it’s surprisingly lag-free.
- coretx 3y agoThe playstation 3 was the last "console". Everything that came after was general purpose computing crap.
- charcircuit 3y agoThe PS3 could do general purpose computing. Its built in operating system let you play games, watch movies, play music, browse the web, etc. At the beginning of the console's life you could even install Linux on it. The hardware of consoles has been general purpose for decades.
- rpmisms 3y agoThe Pentagon even built a supercomputer using PS3s as compute cores.
- Dalewyn 3y agoGaming is general purpose computing, or at least a part of it.
- erik 3y agoThe current and previous generations of xbox and playstation do use x86 CPUs with integrated AMD GPUs. But they aren't just PCs in a small box. Using a unified pool of GDDR memory* is a substantial architectural difference. *except for the xbox one & one s, which had its own weird setup with unified DDR3 and a programmer controlled ESRAM cache.
- yarg 3y agoThe CPU really only needs to be adequate - Nvidia can pull that off well enough for Nintendo at least. Intel is in a far worse position - because they cannot do midrange graphics in an acceptable power/thermal range.
- ffgjgf1 3y agoAren’t the midrange GPUs considered to be pretty decent price/performance wise? IIRC they significantly improved their drivers over the last few years
- yarg 3y agoIntel's? They're certainly good enough to be the integrated graphics solution for office work, school computers, media centres, casual gaming (the same as AMD's low end), and other day to day tasks. That's most of the market, but I think it's a stretch to say that they're good enough for consoles.
- ffgjgf1 3y agoThe A770 seems like a solid midrange card, about on par with 4060 Ti and 6700 XT. Even not that far from 4070 in some newer games Intel’s drivers are better optimized for. You also get 16 GB of memory. Of course considering it’s Intel the power usage is way too high. Also AFAIK compatibility with pre DX11 games is poor and its not even clear Intel is eve making any money on it..
- ffgjgf1 3y agoAlso I guess AMD is fine with having much lower margins compared to Nvidia which makes them very competitive in this marker?