Those users don't care much about the ideas, this is where the mistake is, what they want is attention. And they get this attention by ranking low stars (which

Those users don't care much about the ideas, this is where the mistake is, what they want is attention. And they get this attention by ranking low stars (which prompts a dev reply) and commenting on some random very specific detail (which should again should prompt a reply). Every app has those. Those types of users are very different from the feature requests. Those users are the "call your manager!" of the digital world.